Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xchrom

(108,903 posts)
Sun Mar 3, 2013, 09:29 AM Mar 2013

Bradley Manning: The Face of Heroism

http://www.alternet.org/bradley-manning-face-heroism


***SNIP

Manning is absolutely right when he said Friday that the documents he leaked "are some of the most significant documents of our time". They revealed a multitude of previously secret crimes and acts of deceit and corruption by the world's most powerful factions. Journalists and even some government officials have repeatedly concluded that any actual national security harm from his leaks is minimal if it exists at all. To this day, the documents Manning just admitted having leaked play a prominent role in the ability of journalists around the world to inform their readers about vital events. The leaks led to all sorts of journalism awards for WikiLeaks. Without question, Manning's leaks produced more significant international news scoops in 2010 than those of every media outlet on the planet combined.

This was all achieved because a then-22-year-old Army Private knowingly risked his liberty in order to inform the world about what he learned. He endured treatment which the top UN torture investigator deemed "cruel and inhuman", and he now faces decades in prison if not life. He knew exactly what he was risking, what he was likely subjecting himself to. But he made the choice to do it anyway because of the good he believed he could achieve, because of the evil that he believed needed urgently to be exposed and combated, and because of his conviction that only leaks enable the public to learn the truth about the bad acts their governments are doing in secret.

Heroism is a slippery and ambiguous concept. But whatever it means, it is embodied by Bradley Manning and the acts which he unflinchingly acknowledged Friday he chose to undertake. The combination of extreme government secrecy, a supine media (see the prior two columns), and a disgracefully subservient judiciary means that the only way we really learn about what our government does is when the Daniel Ellsbergs - and Bradley Mannings - of the world risk their own personal interest and liberty to alert us. Daniel Ellberg is now widely viewed as heroic and noble, and Bradley Manning (as Ellsberg himself has repeatedly said) merits that praise and gratitude every bit as much.













5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Bradley Manning: The Face of Heroism (Original Post) xchrom Mar 2013 OP
This message was self-deleted by its author Whats_that Mar 2013 #1
k&r... spanone Mar 2013 #2
I understand why we need to have secrecy, but sometimes the ability to keep secrets is JDPriestly Mar 2013 #3
right on. Ola. Mar 2013 #4
Off course he is a hero Bohemianwriter Mar 2013 #5

Response to xchrom (Original post)

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
3. I understand why we need to have secrecy, but sometimes the ability to keep secrets is
Sun Mar 3, 2013, 12:14 PM
Mar 2013

exploited to an unhealthy, criminal extent. That was the case here where the military should have prosecuted the officers who ordered or closed their eyes to violations of international law and the codes of war.

Manning is like those of the first sex abuse survivors who went to authorities and eventually the media about the abuse by Catholic priests. No one wanted to listen to them. Some refused to believe it. No one wanted the embarrassment or the cost of it. The actions of the priest-abusers were to be kept secret in order to protect the hierarchy of the Church and to prevent discussion of the moral issues those abuses raised.

But crimes had been committed. In any hierarchy or bureaucracy, those who speak out against evil or wrongs get no thanks. The molested children weren't supposed to wash the Church's dirty laundry in public. They were supposed to keep their secrets. Submission to the will of God and the Church . .l. .

But the abused did speak up, and now all Catholics have the opportunity and the responsibility to stand up, speak out and rid their Church hierarchy of abusers.

Manning bravely faced a moral dilemma: whether to speak out about wrongs he knew had happened in the military, whether to release the documents that incriminated the command. Had he simply told his story and talked out of school, no one would have believed him. No one would have paid any attention. He didn't. And now we know much of what he knew. We know just how cruel our military was in Iraq and Afghanistan, how immoral were some of their acts, how they killed unarmed children without a pang of remorse.

I suspect that Manning knew when he gave the documents to Wikileaks that he would pay a price for doing so. Perhaps he did not think about it much. Perhaps he did not consider that if he gave the documents to Wikleaks he would be discovered and serve most of the rest of his life in prison.

Perhaps he was just so shocked and incensed at what he was reading that he acted without a lot of thought. In either case, he is now bound to be sentenced to years in prison. He knows it. He has stated that he did it to help mankind and our country. I am inclined to believe him.

Manning has made an enormous personal sacrifice for his country. Like the children who as adults "came out" to accuse their priests, his life is marked. He will never be free from the watchful eyes of those he unmasked.

But Manning has left a record for people of conscience around the world. Even in war there have to be limits as to the cruelty we exhibit to those we are fighting. Our military exceeded those limits.

It is up to us, people of conscience, to remember what Manning showed us and never relent from questioning the acts of our government and the military hierarchies of the world.

Manning is a true hero. Like all true heroes, he will pay a personal price. It is up to us to make sure that price is worth the cost. Never forget.

----

Some may ask why Manning released such a broad scope of diplomatic documents. I wonder whether it was because those documents were well known to the many people in our diplomatic corps who wrote them or received them. He may not have thought about it but it would seem to me that the release of those documents which were known to people in high positions who wrote and read them, insured that no one would doubt the authenticity of the rest of the documents. Those documents were familiar to a lot of our diplomatic and intelligence employees. Manning was no fool. Had he picked just the most incriminating documents, people would not have believed in the integrity of the Wikileaks publication.

I do not normally approve of people breaking a promise to keep secrets. But Manning has placed the world on notice that we need some way to enforce international restraints on our military machinery.

What if the tables were turned? What if the Iraqis had been the aggressor and had treated our journalists and children as our troops treated the Iraqis? Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.

Ola.

(7 posts)
4. right on.
Sun Mar 3, 2013, 03:19 PM
Mar 2013

who even knew people like bradley manning still existed?

we need more bradley mannings in this world.

 

Bohemianwriter

(978 posts)
5. Off course he is a hero
Thu Mar 14, 2013, 03:14 PM
Mar 2013

I am a veteran from the Bosnian War.

I am a writer and translator!

I am a translator!

I am a journeman!

I am Bradley Manning!

That is all!


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Bradley Manning: The Face...