Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

StevieM

(10,500 posts)
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 03:25 PM Jun 2014

The Catholic Irish babies scandal: It gets much worse

Last edited Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:14 PM - Edit history (2)

~snip~

It gets worse. One week after revelations of how over the span of 35 years, a County Galway home for unwed mothers cavalierly disposed of the bodies of nearly eight hundred babies and toddlers on a site that held a septic tank, new reports are leveling a whole different set of charges about what happened to the children of those Irish homes.

In harrowing new information revealed this weekend, the Daily Mail has uncovered medical records that suggest 2,051 children across several Irish care homes were given a diphtheria vaccine from pharmaceutical company Burroughs Wellcome in a suspected illegal drug trial that ran from 1930 to 1936. As the Mail reports, "Michael Dwyer, of Cork University’s School of History, found the child vaccination data by trawling through tens of thousands of medical journal articles and archive files. He discovered that the trials were carried out before the vaccine was made available for commercial use in the UK." There is no evidence yet – and there may never be – that any family consent was ever offered, or about how many children had adverse effects or died as a result of the vaccinations. Dwyer told the Mail, "The fact that no record of these trials can be found in the files relating to the Department of Local Government and Public Health, the Municipal Health Reports relating to Cork and Dublin, or the Wellcome Archives in London, suggests that vaccine trials would not have been acceptable to government, municipal authorities, or the general public. However, the fact that reports of these trials were published in the most prestigious medical journals suggests that this type of human experimentation was largely accepted by medical practitioners and facilitated by authorities in charge of children’s residential institutions." In a related story, GSK revealed Monday on Newstalk Radio that 298 children in ten different care homes were involved in medical trials in the sixties and seventies that left "80 children ill after they were accidentally administered a vaccine intended for cattle."

https://trove.com/?hash_nav=1#me/content/V7Ra7?chid=82583&_p=trending&utm_source=wp&utm_medium=Widgets&utm_campaign=wpsrTrendingExternal-1-opt

This story is so awful. How can people treat their fellow humans with such contempt?

34 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Catholic Irish babies scandal: It gets much worse (Original Post) StevieM Jun 2014 OP
from the article Liberal_in_LA Jun 2014 #1
Thanks, I should be better about copying and pasting, I just never know which section StevieM Jun 2014 #2
It's good to give a bit of info in the OP though, what I do, is copy the first five six paragraphs.. bettyellen Jun 2014 #12
Thanks for the advice!! I'll try to keep that in mind in the future. In the meantime, I edited my OP StevieM Jun 2014 #18
You're welcome! I'm not so good with the formatting myself... bettyellen Jun 2014 #34
This is tabloid sensationalism gerogie2 Jun 2014 #3
The pathetic scramble to rationalize the Irish babies scandal me b zola Jun 2014 #4
Yeah, I couldn't bring myself to respond. It's just so exacerbating. StevieM Jun 2014 #6
I think you might also find this article to be of interest theHandpuppet Jun 2014 #7
Thank you for these links me b zola Jun 2014 #10
In 1915 gerogie2 Jun 2014 #8
But that is NOT what happened in these homes me b zola Jun 2014 #9
"These women and children were used as human guinea pigs in medical research." rug Jun 2014 #17
The records have been turned over to the investigators me b zola Jun 2014 #19
It is reminiscent of the Tuskegee experiment. StevieM Jun 2014 #20
Any time a group of people is seen as less than human they can & will be exploited me b zola Jun 2014 #22
yes, exact parallel. BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2014 #23
A more apt comparison are the radiation tests suffragette Jun 2014 #26
your post has nothing to do with the neglect and abuse that happened there during the era of modern bettyellen Jun 2014 #13
The first paragraph cites 19freaking30. displacedtexan Jun 2014 #15
The infant mortality rates in the homes far exceeded the rates in Ireland at the time. Gormy Cuss Jun 2014 #21
Were they all buried on top of each other in mass graves like yesterday's garbage? Starry Messenger Jun 2014 #28
you must do some background research.. Duppers Jun 2014 #31
uhm, no. just no mercuryblues Jun 2014 #33
K&R me b zola Jun 2014 #5
Any comment from Pope Photo-Op yet?.... SidDithers Jun 2014 #11
How? Just look around...all over the world. nt kelliekat44 Jun 2014 #14
This is what I am reading Sivafae Jun 2014 #16
+100 Duppers Jun 2014 #30
Women at best are 2nd class citizens and in places like WhiteTara Jun 2014 #24
Francis is of course silent. As he is about the horrors his Bishops are making in Uganda. Bluenorthwest Jun 2014 #25
I remember the outcry when Sinead O'Conner tore the photo of the pope. WCLinolVir Jun 2014 #27
links, links, links MisterP Jun 2014 #29
What we actually know is: (1) Catherine Corless obtained death certificates struggle4progress Jun 2014 #32
 

Liberal_in_LA

(44,397 posts)
1. from the article
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 03:36 PM
Jun 2014
What Ireland is only now beginning to fully investigate and understand is a story involving potentially thousands of children who were almost certainly neglected and mistreated, and whose deaths were addressed as a mere trash disposal issue. It is now believed a total of upwards of 4,000 children were similarly disposed of in other homes across the country. It's a story of untold even higher numbers of children who were unwitting subjects in a vaccine test that further refused to see them as human beings, capable of fear and pain. And an interesting insight into why so very children may have been so casually treated and tossed away was revealed in a recent feature on the scandal in the Independent. Babies born to unwed mothers – and this, let it be noted, would have included mothers who were raped – "were denied baptism and, if they died from the illness and disease rife in such facilities, also denied a Christian burial." In other words, the Catholic institutions that these women and their children were forced to turn to as their only refuge viciously turned their backs on them -- treating them, quite literally, as garbage. This is abuse of the highest order. Abuse in life, abuse in death. Carried out by religious orders so warped, so perverted in their utter lack of mercy that they participated in the suffering of an unfathomable number of babies and children. This is what the Catholic church of Ireland is capable of, when it is given free reign over the bodies of its most vulnerable members. And an official inquiry hasn't even begun. As Michael Dwyer told the Mail this weekend, "What I have found is just the tip of a very large and submerged iceberg."

StevieM

(10,500 posts)
2. Thanks, I should be better about copying and pasting, I just never know which section
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 04:06 PM
Jun 2014

I want to focus on, so I always wind up just posting the link.

Then again, I don't start too many threads. This whole thing in Ireland has me so upset that I feel the need to post about it. The mainstream media in the U.S. isn't covering the story. And yes, I do think that this should be receiving international coverage, arguably leading off the news.

 

bettyellen

(47,209 posts)
12. It's good to give a bit of info in the OP though, what I do, is copy the first five six paragraphs..
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 06:26 PM
Jun 2014

and then, when I see it pasted into the OP, make a quick decision on which three (the limit) are best, and delete the others. Just put "snip ...." to show it is missing a bit between paragraphs. A LOT of people do not click on links, and only skim.
Good article- thanks for posting it!!

StevieM

(10,500 posts)
18. Thanks for the advice!! I'll try to keep that in mind in the future. In the meantime, I edited my OP
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:04 PM
Jun 2014

to include some of the article.

I hope it looks OK. Could you let me know if you think I should change the appearance or text format?

 

bettyellen

(47,209 posts)
34. You're welcome! I'm not so good with the formatting myself...
Thu Jun 12, 2014, 11:55 AM
Jun 2014

I never touch the quoted material myself except to put quotes around the part I copy.
What a horrible bit of info, those poor babies. Horrible to think that's the church my parents grew up in. No wonder they had a big fear of god.

 

gerogie2

(450 posts)
3. This is tabloid sensationalism
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 04:36 PM
Jun 2014

Before modern medicine millions of children died from disease and medical complications. That is why parents would have up to five children because often time many of their children died.

me b zola

(19,053 posts)
4. The pathetic scramble to rationalize the Irish babies scandal
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 04:58 PM
Jun 2014

~snip~

There has been a widespread call for a full inquiry into the fate of the children of not just the Home but other similar institutions across the country, including a recent public petition that quickly garnered over 30,000 signatures. This week Enda Kenny has announced a special commission of investigation into the homes, including the high death rates, the burial practices, the vaccine trials and illegal adoptions. It is to be an inquiry into “the kind of country Ireland was, the kind of country where women in particular were the focus of shame and suppression” and out-of-wedlock children “were deemed to be an inferior sub-species.” An inquiry long overdue and utterly essential. Ignoring the misdeeds of the past doesn’t make them go away. And when you try to bury them, eventually, they’re found anyway.

~much more @ link~
http://www.salon.com/2014/06/11/the_pathetic_scramble_to_rationalize_the_irish_babies_scandal/?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=socialflow


I read an article from an Irish newspaper yesterday when one of the survivors tells of the conditions. Meanwhile, I am biting my lip to meet your post with civility.


StevieM

(10,500 posts)
6. Yeah, I couldn't bring myself to respond. It's just so exacerbating.
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 05:23 PM
Jun 2014

This scandal is shocking, but not surprising, if that makes any sense.

theHandpuppet

(19,964 posts)
7. I think you might also find this article to be of interest
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 05:55 PM
Jun 2014
http://www.irishexaminer.com/viewpoints/columnists/gerard-howlin/our-public-anger-is-the-incoherent-expression-of-our-private-shame-271620.html
Very interesting article about how the oppression of women within the society and church manifested itself by what happened in these "mother and baby" homes.

Ireland still has a long way to go in terms of reproductive rights.
http://www.nwci.ie/discover/what_we_do/womens_right_to_health/reproductive_rights

me b zola

(19,053 posts)
10. Thank you for these links
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 06:22 PM
Jun 2014

This topic should be important to DUers as it is about reproductive rights, women's rights, and ultimately human rights.

 

gerogie2

(450 posts)
8. In 1915
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 06:11 PM
Jun 2014

my Grandmother was eight years old in Oklahoma City, OK when several diseases swept through the city and over 1,000 children died.

me b zola

(19,053 posts)
9. But that is NOT what happened in these homes
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 06:20 PM
Jun 2014

These women and children were used as human guinea pigs in medical research. One of the homes had two outdoor toilet facilities for the children that were overflowing.

The children who were deemed to be less marketable were neglected and malnourished which is why so many died of malnutrition. One person investigating just before the laundries were closed reports of putrefied diarrhea in the diapers of babies.

This was systematic abuse and neglect because these women and their children were seen as sub-human.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
17. "These women and children were used as human guinea pigs in medical research."
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:03 PM
Jun 2014

Is that from The Mail or do you have a reputable link?

me b zola

(19,053 posts)
19. The records have been turned over to the investigators
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:24 PM
Jun 2014
Records from mother and baby homes passed to child and family agency
Children in homes were used in scientific experiments

^^^audio available @ link provided^^^

~snip~

Earlier, Newstalk revealed that experimental drug trials were conducted on 298 children across 10 mother and baby homes during the 1960s and 70s.

Three trials were conducted at homes at Bessborough in Co. Cork, St. Peter's in Westmeath, St. Clare's in Stamullen, and The Good Shepard in Dunboyne - both Co. Meath - as well as six Dublin homes.

The research was carried out between 1960 and 1976.

In one of the trials, 80 children became unwell after they were allegedly given a vaccine intended for cattle as part of an experiment run at five care homes and orphanages in Dublin during the mid 70s.

~more, including audio, @ link~

http://www.newstalk.ie/shows/47.305.358/26433/0/


This isn't about bashing the Catholic Church. This is about the results of a society shaming women.

StevieM

(10,500 posts)
20. It is reminiscent of the Tuskegee experiment.
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:31 PM
Jun 2014

The mindset is sickening. And just as Tuskegee was rooted in racism, this was rooted in misogyny. And the misogyny ran so deep that even extended to their children.

me b zola

(19,053 posts)
22. Any time a group of people is seen as less than human they can & will be exploited
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:38 PM
Jun 2014

And that is exactly how single mothers and their children were thought of and treated during this time period~subhuman.

suffragette

(12,232 posts)
26. A more apt comparison are the radiation tests
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 09:01 PM
Jun 2014

Conducted on children by MIT and Quaker Oats.
In both cases, the children were chosen as subjects because they were powerless and devalued.

 

bettyellen

(47,209 posts)
13. your post has nothing to do with the neglect and abuse that happened there during the era of modern
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 06:29 PM
Jun 2014

medicine. Defending tossing these babies away like refuse is repulsive. Shame on the church.

Gormy Cuss

(30,884 posts)
21. The infant mortality rates in the homes far exceeded the rates in Ireland at the time.
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:38 PM
Jun 2014

IOW, the mortality rate can not be explained away as just what was typical of the times.
Even in a country with a high mortality rate such as Ireland in that era, the death rates in these homes were extraordinarily high. When the country had a 7% death rate, the Sean Ross abbey rate was over 30%.

mercuryblues

(14,522 posts)
33. uhm, no. just no
Thu Jun 12, 2014, 05:43 AM
Jun 2014

Women had children because there were no reliable means of birth control. There is a reason the baby boom ended in the early to mid-60's. It is called Griswald vs CT.

Google butterbox babies.

Besides being an unwed mothers home, it was the local maternity ward - for married couples.

In that home the babies were starved to death, if they were deemed unadoptable. Then either tossed into the ocean or buried in a butter crate. The babies were sometimes ripped from the mothers arms to be "adopted". Mothers were told their babies had died because they had already sold them to a waiting couple. There is no way to know how many babies were actually killed. That home was run by evangelical Christians.

I suspect many of the babies in the septic tank in Ireland suffered a similar fate.

The simple fact is, women and babies were thought of as expendable, devoid of human emotions.

The simple fact is women will face a similar fate if the religious right get there way with outlawing birth control and abortion.
I guess the church would rather kill the born babies outright, themselves.

SidDithers

(44,228 posts)
11. Any comment from Pope Photo-Op yet?....
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 06:24 PM
Jun 2014

Or is he too busy washing feet and driving around in his shitbox Renault?

Sid

Sivafae

(480 posts)
16. This is what I am reading
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 07:03 PM
Jun 2014

Let's make all women have babies by not allowing abortion, so that we can throw them away in the septic tank. That is cruelty of the worse kind.

wow. just. wow.

WhiteTara

(29,692 posts)
24. Women at best are 2nd class citizens and in places like
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 08:45 PM
Jun 2014

the Catholic Church in Ireland; these humans were treated as animals, at best. May their agony and misery shame the Catholics in that country.

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
25. Francis is of course silent. As he is about the horrors his Bishops are making in Uganda.
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 08:49 PM
Jun 2014

He will continue to assert his moral authority to judge all others. Hewill continue to attack good gay parents while his own organization will continue to pillage and do harm.

WCLinolVir

(951 posts)
27. I remember the outcry when Sinead O'Conner tore the photo of the pope.
Wed Jun 11, 2014, 09:42 PM
Jun 2014

Every time I hear another horrific story about the Catholic Church in Ireland, I keep thinking it was common knowledge to the people in power what the church was about. And the people knew as well. Sinead certainly did.
What nightmares. I don't think it's possible to shame the Catholic Church. Fundamentally they are all about patriarchy and power, dressed up in robes. carrying a cross, and blaspheming the concept of a higher power. Let's not forget where the money came from. It started as a reign of terror, burning women and taking their assets.

struggle4progress

(118,228 posts)
32. What we actually know is: (1) Catherine Corless obtained death certificates
Thu Jun 12, 2014, 05:07 AM
Jun 2014

associated with the home from public and thus documented 796 deaths; (2) Barry Sweeney says he and a friend, playing in the area in 1975 when he was about ten years old, found about 20 skeletons under a 1.2 x 0.6 square meter concrete slab there; and (3) there is archival evidence of a sewage tank somewhere in that area, before public services were connected in 1937

The larger site had been the public work-house since 1840 or before, and it apparently remained a county institution funded by public monies even after it became the Home staffed by Bon Secours. It's certainly possible the area in question has been used as a burial ground, though the current state of knowledge is very limited

A surprising number of the deaths are from the WWII era, when it seems about 300 of the children died in four years


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Catholic Irish babies...