Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 05:59 PM Jun 2014

Question: How can we establish a government in Iraq that is democratic

but gives the Sunni minority enough political rights and power to make all but a few extremist Sunnis support the government?

Answer: We can't. It will happen there or it won't, and there is little we can do about it. I think Obama knows that and so I hope he resists the pressure to wage war in Iraq.

37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Question: How can we establish a government in Iraq that is democratic (Original Post) Vattel Jun 2014 OP
either let it break up along tribal lines, or install a dictator to rule by power NightWatcher Jun 2014 #1
Having a dictator seems to have been the only way to keep them from turning on each other. LisaL Jun 2014 #15
Ah yes, "Arabs are savages," the common wisdom of DU Scootaloo Jun 2014 #27
I haven't said it was unique to Iraq, have I? LisaL Jun 2014 #29
Well, we're talking about Iraq Scootaloo Jun 2014 #31
1. Your assertion is dead wrong (maybe if you'd said "Christians"). 2. Kuwait WAS stealing Iraqi WinkyDink Jun 2014 #32
We can barely establish a government in America that JaneyVee Jun 2014 #2
And we have an even harder time establishing a government in America that gives minorities here Vattel Jun 2014 #4
They have been fighting for 13 centuries... arthritisR_US Jun 2014 #3
This. Yes. Totally this. DeadLetterOffice Jun 2014 #5
Jon Stewart claims the last time of peace ... GeorgeGist Jun 2014 #6
Ya I thought it was around 300 yrs after Mohamed was massacred that arthritisR_US Jun 2014 #13
That, and since we decided to kill so many of their civilians... joeybee12 Jun 2014 #8
Saddam was a prick but he kept the radicals at bay. The arthritisR_US Jun 2014 #17
You're right, and it's infuriating that the people who messed this up... joeybee12 Jun 2014 #19
You and me both. I can't get over the people who are blaming this on Obama... arthritisR_US Jun 2014 #24
This. bigwillq Jun 2014 #11
Both this and that. Vattel Jun 2014 #12
And we apparently thought we could go in and make it all better. LisaL Jun 2014 #16
The arrogance and hubris born of abject ignorance and an Oedipus Complex run amok. nt arthritisR_US Jun 2014 #18
No, you're thinking of Europe Scootaloo Jun 2014 #28
No I'm not. nt arthritisR_US Jun 2014 #36
Sure you are. Scootaloo Jun 2014 #37
We cannot and will be doing quite well to really gain such for ourselves. TheKentuckian Jun 2014 #7
When Poppy Bush was preparing the first Iraq war, Jesse Jackson pointed out that bananas Jun 2014 #9
Not our job. hunter Jun 2014 #10
And why is it our job, exactly? LisaL Jun 2014 #14
"You break it, you bought it"? Trekologer Jun 2014 #20
Given our track record, what makes you think we could fix it? LisaL Jun 2014 #30
With more soon to be dead American men in their twenties? WinkyDink Jun 2014 #33
Because we can't really do much to help, it isn't our job. Vattel Jun 2014 #22
Split it into three or install a strongman Kurska Jun 2014 #21
Iraq needs wise, farsighted Founding Fathers. Nye Bevan Jun 2014 #23
WE DON'T! Alex P Notkeaton Jun 2014 #25
Iraq should not have existed in the first place. RandySF Jun 2014 #26
Why would they want Americans to establish anything there? TransitJohn Jun 2014 #34
Not my circus, not my monkeys. (Polish proverb.) n/t X_Digger Jun 2014 #35

NightWatcher

(39,343 posts)
1. either let it break up along tribal lines, or install a dictator to rule by power
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 06:02 PM
Jun 2014

And since we overthrew the dictator who was running the place, I guess we'll have to let it fall into regions via bloody local wars, executions, and humanitarian crisis

 

Scootaloo

(25,699 posts)
27. Ah yes, "Arabs are savages," the common wisdom of DU
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 11:27 PM
Jun 2014

No, quite frankly there's a LOT of things we could have done - and a lot of things we could have not done - to escape the current situation.

- We could have NOT supported Saddam all through the 80's.
- We could have NOT imposed crushing, borderline genocidal sanctions against the Iraqi people that utterly failed to impact the government elite.
- We could have either NOT encouraged a Shiite uprising in 1991, OR we could have followed our promise to back it.
- For that matter, maybe we shouldn't have given Saddam a green light on Kuwait.
- Maybe we shouldn't have invaded in 2003.
- Maybe when we did, our priority should have been transfer of power in a peaceful manner rather than standing by, letting desperate peopel loot everything, ignore the rise of militancy, all while posting hundreds of guards around the Oil Ministry offices.
- Not arming and training the militants now attacking in Iraq would have been a good idea.

Yes, let's ignore the last thirty years of history and just pretend it's some unique and inherent Iraqi flaw.

LisaL

(44,972 posts)
29. I haven't said it was unique to Iraq, have I?
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 11:38 PM
Jun 2014

I have no idea why you would just assume something like that.

 

Scootaloo

(25,699 posts)
31. Well, we're talking about Iraq
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 11:57 PM
Jun 2014

And you say,

Having a dictator seems to have been the only way to keep them from turning on each other.


I'm sure there are untold depths to your statement that an unlearned reader like myself could never "get," abstruse thinking and references to great wisdom hidden in coded word order or something. Even so, it just looks to me like you're saying Iraqis - or perhaps Arabs in general? - can't get by without a dictator.
 

WinkyDink

(51,311 posts)
32. 1. Your assertion is dead wrong (maybe if you'd said "Christians"). 2. Kuwait WAS stealing Iraqi
Wed Jun 18, 2014, 12:11 AM
Jun 2014

oil; 3. See: Yugoslavia, the Former.

 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
4. And we have an even harder time establishing a government in America that gives minorities here
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 06:08 PM
Jun 2014

adequate rights and political power.

arthritisR_US

(7,283 posts)
13. Ya I thought it was around 300 yrs after Mohamed was massacred that
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 08:09 PM
Jun 2014

they had a serge of enlightenment and science and math developed/studied big time

arthritisR_US

(7,283 posts)
17. Saddam was a prick but he kept the radicals at bay. The
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 08:16 PM
Jun 2014

Georgie cabal really fecked it up by going into Iraq and destroying the Sunni secularists and now you are witnessing the Sunni fundies at work and oh how they play..indeed, heads will role and they are proving that, literally.

 

joeybee12

(56,177 posts)
19. You're right, and it's infuriating that the people who messed this up...
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 08:51 PM
Jun 2014

Are the ones screaming for more blood...wish i was religious so I believed in heaven and hell and I knew what awaited those tools.

 

Scootaloo

(25,699 posts)
37. Sure you are.
Wed Jun 18, 2014, 03:27 PM
Jun 2014

Europe JUST decided to take a few years' breather from its four-thousand year history of tribal and sectarian warfare and genocide - to say nothing of what those people have been doing around the rest of the world!

By comparison to Europe, Mesopotamia and the territory around it has been pretty damned stable and peaceful for the last 1300 years.

bananas

(27,509 posts)
9. When Poppy Bush was preparing the first Iraq war, Jesse Jackson pointed out that
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 06:43 PM
Jun 2014

if Iraq had a democratic election, Saddam Hussein would win.

hunter

(38,302 posts)
10. Not our job.
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 06:43 PM
Jun 2014

At best we could establish a forum where new national boundaries are established.

But that's not going to happen so long as we think the oil belongs to our imaginary "free" market.

Trekologer

(996 posts)
20. "You break it, you bought it"?
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 08:59 PM
Jun 2014

We royally screwed the place up. We bear some responsibility for trying to fix it.

RandySF

(58,477 posts)
26. Iraq should not have existed in the first place.
Tue Jun 17, 2014, 10:50 PM
Jun 2014

It's a set of regions cobbled together by the British.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Question: How can we esta...