Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xchrom

(108,903 posts)
Mon Jun 30, 2014, 05:34 AM Jun 2014

5 Facts to Set the Dangerously Deluded Education Reformers Straight

http://www.alternet.org/education/5-facts-set-dangerously-deluded-education-reformers-straight



1. Privatized Education Steals from the Poor, Gives to the Rich

Eva Moskowitz makes $72 per student as CEO of the private Success Academy in New York City.

Carmen Farina makes 19 cents per student as Chancellor of New York City Public Schools.

More salary shock: The salaries of eight executives of the K12 chain, which gets over 86 percent of its profits from the taxpayers, went from $10 million to over $21 million in one year.

***SNIP

2. Testing Doesn't Work

In 2013 the Silicon Valley Business Journal reported that "K-12 schools across the United States will begin implementing Common Core State Standards, an education initiative that will drive schools to adopt technology in the classroom as never before...Apple, Google, Cisco and a swarm of startups are elbowing in to secure market share." The state of Texas cut over $5 billion from the public school fund while awarding testing giant Pearson a contract for almost $500 million. Los Angeles spent $1 billion for iPads to facilitate testing, using money from a 25-year bond for school construction.

***SNIP

3. The Arts Make Better Scientists

While testable subjects like math and reading are of the utmost importance in a competitive global economy, inexperienced reformers fail to recognize that STEM proficiency requires an Arts foundation for the creativity that turns knowledge into ideas and implementations. A comprehensive study at Michigan State University found that "success in science is accompanied by developed ability in other fields such as the fine arts." According to a 2007 report in the Journal for Research in Music Education, students in high quality music programs scored 19% higher in English and 17% higher in mathematics than those without a music program. Both the College Entrance Examination Boardand the National Association of Music Education found that music programs improved SAT scores later on.

***SNIP

4. Privatization Means Unequal Opportunity for All

David F. Welch founded Students Matter "to defend children's fundamental right to have an equal opportunity to access quality public education." His NewSchools Venture Fund is heavily involved with charter schools and data collection in schools.
12 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
5 Facts to Set the Dangerously Deluded Education Reformers Straight (Original Post) xchrom Jun 2014 OP
Kicked and recommended! Enthusiast Jun 2014 #1
Bookmarking. Great post, thanks. woo me with science Jun 2014 #2
... xchrom Jun 2014 #4
Students should have recesses, and chervilant Jun 2014 #3
Kick! n/t BuelahWitch Jun 2014 #5
I've always thought that MBA stood for Myopic Business Approaches. Half-Century Man Jun 2014 #6
Bubbling in little circles on a Pearson-written test cannot make one a true critical thinker. Pholus Jun 2014 #7
The charter school people came through Englewood Hotler Jun 2014 #8
An excellent summary of the Haliburtanization of American schools. DamnYankeeInHouston Jun 2014 #9
ALEC is coming up with their next plan for the dismantling tomg Jun 2014 #10
all these five dangers are now almost inevitable because they're bipartisan MisterP Jun 2014 #11
The society based on production is only productive, not creative. Albert Camus Tierra_y_Libertad Jun 2014 #12

chervilant

(8,267 posts)
3. Students should have recesses, and
Mon Jun 30, 2014, 06:41 AM
Jun 2014

study halls -- as it stands, school is deliberately structured to produce factory fodder and service industry drones. Gotta keep our younglings regimented and propagandized.

BTW, testing is NOT intended to educationally benefit our students -- it's "required" so that a small group of businesses can make mega-buckages and so that administrators can get rid of costly veteran teachers.

Half-Century Man

(5,279 posts)
6. I've always thought that MBA stood for Myopic Business Approaches.
Mon Jun 30, 2014, 07:53 AM
Jun 2014

When the majority of American business practices can be easily and definitively explained by the 4 panel cartoon strip "Dilbert"..........

Pholus

(4,062 posts)
7. Bubbling in little circles on a Pearson-written test cannot make one a true critical thinker.
Mon Jun 30, 2014, 07:58 AM
Jun 2014

But we all knew that from the beginning -- this was never about the students, this was about who got paid.

Hotler

(11,396 posts)
8. The charter school people came through Englewood
Mon Jun 30, 2014, 08:34 AM
Jun 2014

a few months back peddling the shit and the citizens ran them off for the time being.

tomg

(2,574 posts)
10. ALEC is coming up with their next plan for the dismantling
Mon Jun 30, 2014, 10:07 AM
Jun 2014

of education. The following link is the draft proposal of their Education Task force.

http://www.alec.org/wp-content/uploads/ED-35-day-AM-2014.pdf
Dallas.
Actually, this pdf is the registration form to attend their national meeting July 30- August 1st in Dallas. It includes the draft proposal after the registration. There are two major proposals in the draft.


One is a proposal directed toward public higher education that would

"require all public four year universities to offer bachelor’s degrees costing no more than $10,000, total, for four years of tuition, fees, and books. The Act would require that ten percent of all public, four year university degrees awarded reach this price point within four years of passage of this act" and "would be instructed to capitalize on the opportunities and efficiencies provided by (1) web-based technology and (2) competency based program."

In other words, set up an impossible task - under current economic conditions, under current instructional conditions, and that requires intensive revising of curricula and ultimately continues and exacerbates contingent faculty - make it required only of publicly-funded institutions and impose penalties if compliance is not met within an impossibly short time period. The best, most reputable entirely on-line public institution is Western Governors ( a project developed by 19 US Governors) and their tuition is approximately 2,890 per six-month period ( semester).

The other, the section on Public Charters, is another disaster in the making, couched in pretty tricky terms. For example, Public Charters cannot be required to take services from their Authorizers, but they can choose to do so. Well here are two quick points on teachers:

"Public charter schools shall comply with applicable federal laws, rules, and regulations regarding the qualification of teachers and other instructional staff. In accordance with Section 8, (A), (4), teachers
in public charter schools shall be exempt from state teacher certification requirements."

"Public charter school employees cannot be required to be members of any existing collective bargaining agreement between a school district and its employees."




MisterP

(23,730 posts)
11. all these five dangers are now almost inevitable because they're bipartisan
Mon Jun 30, 2014, 02:52 PM
Jun 2014

before '08 "reform" could be bashed as yet another ploy by the good-ol'-boys' network: now that an adored technocrat, who's constantly being damned as socialist by the GOP and constantly being praised as a socialist by Dems, is behind it, that makes it seem that "everybody" (i.e., both parties in a duopoly) thinks it's a good idea

same with Af/Iraq: when it's just oil barons and people who worry that Celestial Seasonings tea lets Satan into your home and think that he lives in Fallujah, it's easy to dismiss the "war on Islam": but once Dems and prominent atheist agitators join in, it becomes consensual: it MORE than doubles in support--it's disproportionate, a multiplier effect

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»5 Facts to Set the Danger...