Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Redfairen

(1,276 posts)
Tue Mar 26, 2013, 07:15 PM Mar 2013

Federal judge dismisses EWTN lawsuit against HHS contraception mandate

Source: AL.com

U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Lovelace Blackburn on Monday dismissed EWTN Global Catholic Network's lawsuit challenging the federal mandate that employee healthcare plans must provide coverage for contraception, voluntary sterilization procedures and abortion-inducing drugs.

"While we are extremely disappointed that Judge Blackburn did not rule on the constitutional issues that were at the heart of the EWTN lawsuit, we are not surprised by the decision," said EWTN President and Chief Executive Officer Michael P. Warsaw, in a statement issued today by EWTN. "In every lawsuit filed against the mandate, the government has made promise after promise to amend its unjust rules. As a result, nearly everyone, including the courts, is left waiting to see what the government might or might not do to address the serious issues of conscience that have been raised since the first set of rules were published over a year ago."

Blackburn's order found that the "real prospect of harm from a concrete regulatory mandate" gives EWTN adequate legal standing to file the lawsuit. However, because the government has promised to yet further amend the mandate's rules, Blackburn's opinion held that the moving target of the mandate was not yet "ripe" for review, and that the promise of future revisions to the mandate made the court reluctant to rule at this time. Blackburn's opinion concludes that "in this case, common sense weighs in favor of withholding judicial review until the new regulations are created and finalized. At that point, if EWTN still has objections, it may then file suit."

.......

EWTN filed its lawsuit Feb. 9, 2012 against the Department of Health & Human Services, HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, and other government agencies seeking to stop the imposition of the contraception mandate as well as asking the court for a declaratory judgment that the mandate is unconstitutional. Luther Strange, Attorney General of the State of Alabama, filed a motion to join EWTN on March 22, 2012 as a plaintiff in the lawsuit. Blackburn's decision essentially dismissed that motion as well.

Read more: http://blog.al.com/spotnews/2013/03/federal_judge_dismisses_ewtn_l.html#incart_river_default

9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Federal judge dismisses EWTN lawsuit against HHS contraception mandate (Original Post) Redfairen Mar 2013 OP
Where would it end? joesdaughter Mar 2013 #1
good point indivisibleman Mar 2013 #4
Conservatives always think that laws are either not applicable to them, or can be picked and WinkyDink Mar 2013 #2
the big three indivisibleman Mar 2013 #3
The Pill and Plan B Freddie Mar 2013 #6
thanks for that distinction. indivisibleman Mar 2013 #9
I guess they prefer dead mothers and babies Freddie Mar 2013 #5
The mandate still needs to be upheld by the courts. Dawson Leery Mar 2013 #7
I just read that the founder of EWTN is still alive. Archae Mar 2013 #8

joesdaughter

(243 posts)
1. Where would it end?
Tue Mar 26, 2013, 07:34 PM
Mar 2013

The issue is still unsettled by this decision. However, if the owner the company I work for is a vegitarian can they prohibit coverage for me if I got hurt in a hunting accident or get ecoli from some meat product I ate ?

How does denying medical care based on YOUR* religion not infringe on MY spiritual beliefs/non-beliefs ?

*RCC

This makes me absolutely crazy!

 

WinkyDink

(51,311 posts)
2. Conservatives always think that laws are either not applicable to them, or can be picked and
Tue Mar 26, 2013, 07:55 PM
Mar 2013

chosen, as they wish.

I have a friend who likes to complain that "she" should not have to see her taxes support abortion rights.

I always reply that MY taxes should not go towards illegal invasions of sovereign nations, but that isn't how democracy works.

indivisibleman

(482 posts)
3. the big three
Tue Mar 26, 2013, 07:56 PM
Mar 2013

contraception=the pill, condoms etc. (Something Catholics use but claim they don't)
voluntary sterilization procedures=hysterectomies, tubal ligation, vasectomies. (Very common procedures for all people)
abortion-inducing drugs=day after pills and some contraceptives.
All pretty normal and necessary things for good health.

Freddie

(9,232 posts)
6. The Pill and Plan B
Tue Mar 26, 2013, 08:00 PM
Mar 2013

Are **not** "abortion inducing drugs. They prevent ovulation. This is another RW myth.

indivisibleman

(482 posts)
9. thanks for that distinction.
Wed Mar 27, 2013, 01:53 AM
Mar 2013

I understand that some bc pills prevent fertilized eggs from attaching inside the uterus. Some well respected institutions have stated such. I was speaking from a right wing perspective, thus to them it is a form of abortion which is ridiculous.

Freddie

(9,232 posts)
5. I guess they prefer dead mothers and babies
Tue Mar 26, 2013, 07:58 PM
Mar 2013

The reason behind the contraception mandate is that doctors are now recommending that a woman wait at least 2 years between pregnancies for the healthiest outcome for her and baby. Given that most married couples are not enthused about celibacy, contraception allows her to space her pregnancies in a healthy way. It's not about "lifestyle choices", it's about HEALTH. Assholes.

Archae

(46,262 posts)
8. I just read that the founder of EWTN is still alive.
Tue Mar 26, 2013, 08:46 PM
Mar 2013

"Mother Angelica."

She is 90 years old and has had several strokes.

I remember especially her throwing a royal fit about the movie "Last Temptation Of Christ," wanting the movie to be banned.
Had she just kept her big mouth shut it would have died on it's own, it's an awful movie.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Federal judge dismisses E...