Green oil--could this be economically produced?
Green Oil: Scientists Turn Algae Into Petroleum In 30 Minutes
Scientists at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory are claiming success in perfecting a method that can transform a pea-soupy solution of algae into crude oil by pressure cooking it for about 30 minutes. The process, called hydrothermal liquefaction, also works on other streams of organic matter, such as municipal sewage. And the crude oil created is lightweight and low in sulfur and can be dropped in to refineries that process fossil crudes.
Its a bit like using a pressure cooker, only the pressures and temperatures we use are much higher, said researcher Douglas Elliott in a statement. In a sense, we are duplicating the process in the Earth that converted algae into oil over the course of millions of years. Were just doing it much, much faster.
(snip)
A big criticism of corn ethanol over the years is that the process of growing it requires so much fertilizer, water and other energy inputs that by the time youve got it turned into ethanol youve lost energy not gained it. If an energy system has a negative net energy balance it is necessarily cannibalizing other energy sources.
This appears to be an inconvenient truth for algae as well. Most methods of cultivating it simply eat more energy than is contained in the algae.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2013/12/23/green-oil-scientists-turn-algae-into-petroleum-in-30-minutes/
KurtNYC
(14,549 posts)if they get that down a little and oil rises again, this method will be cheaper than tar sands or brent crude.
TexasProgresive
(12,157 posts)There ain't no free lunch.
Not to mention how much energy is needed to heat, pressurize and refine the "crude" into fuel.
Leme
(1,092 posts)This appears to be an inconvenient truth for algae as well. Most methods of cultivating it simply eat more energy than is contained in the algae.
-
Ethanol from corn has been known to be a scam for a long time now... the big processors and farm lobby want it
-
perhaps there is some merit in this process though
JayhawkSD
(3,163 posts)kristopher
(29,798 posts)Renewable energy sources with current technology are more than adequate to power modern society.
Biofuels have a role, and algae is a good avenue to explore for those applications that require a portable liquid energy carrier.
The real constraint for algae isn't the processing, it is:
1) keeping the high lipid strains pure while you are growing it - contaminating strains ruin the 'crop' so growing in the open air tends to be problematic.
2) getting an adequate supply of carbon dioxide infused into the growth medium. Even the hopeful scenarios only see commercial viability if the process taps into exhaust from a fossil fuel power plant. Even then it only recovers a small fraction of the CO2 released by the FFs so, at best, it can be seen as a slight efficiency improvement re CO2 for the FF industry.
That is looking at it within the structure of our present energy system. As fossil fuels are ending their reign, however, picture changes somewhat and the use of algae diesel will make a lot more sense both environmentally and economically. The window of opportunity for it really isn't here yet though.
BTW, the military is a big driver of research. They're the first to fly jets on algae fuels.
modrepub
(3,493 posts)If this could be incorporated into power generation stations to use the waste heat it might be more economical.