Reply #90: It isn't necessarily about his soul. [View All]

Catholics are called to lead lives of example, so while the state of his soul is a question that is none of our concern, the public practice of his faith is recorded. Most of us try, but fail, often to lead exemplary lives. The confusion is that there are so many facets to Catholicism that people focus on some aspects and leave others. I think we have an old school "fire and brimstone" priest in that church. I have experienced my share of those as well as priest who are more about the social justice and celebration of God's love. There is a split, even among the leaders of the Church about what makes a "good Catholic". Catholics have liberals and conservatives as well. Ratzenberger is one of the most conservative Cardinals before being elected Pope. He disagreed often with where John Paul II was taking the church even though John Paul was a moderate in most areas.

It is difficult to put up with priests who see faith as a set of shackles and a burden like this old guy seems to. I prefer to celebrate and work towards being good to others rather than live in fear of punishment.