Five years ago today Al Gore phoned George Bush to formally concede the presidency. Since then the United States has suffered it's worst ever terrorist attack, become embroiled in a disastrous foreign war and bungled the response to a natural catastrophe. So what is the Bush legacy after half a decade? Is he a ruthless Machiavellian or a bumbling puppet? A devout idealist or a cynical opportunist? A disaster or a mild disappointment? Here, six top American commentators - from the left and the right - deliver their verdicts
. Jacob Weisberg is the editor of Slate.com and the author of the "Bushisms" series
. Kathleen Parker is a political commentator whose weekly column in the Orlando Sentinel is syndicated to more than 300 US newspapers
.Howell Raines is the former editor of the New York Times and author of a forthcoming memoir, The One That Got Away
· Kitty Kelley is author of Family: The Real Story of the Bush Dynasty
· R Emmett Tyrrell, Jr is the founder and editor-in-chief of the American Spectator
· Dee Dee Myers is a political analyst and commentator, and a former White House press secretary in the Clinton administration
http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,12271,1665837,00.html