Beyond Sicko (The Nation)

Michael Moore's Sicko
Christopher Hayes



About forty minutes into Sicko, Michael Moore's excellent, frustrating new documentary about the American healthcare industry, Ronald Reagan makes his first and only appearance. It's surprising, if only because, unlike in his previous film Fahrenheit 9/11, Moore focuses relatively little attention on the villains in his story, choosing instead simply to allow their victims to tell their tales. It's a montage of hard luck and innocence. But after introducing us to the horror stories all too typical among even the 250 million Americans fortunate enough to have health insurance, Moore takes a few moments for a brief history lesson. How, he asks, did we get here? And it's in this time warp that we encounter the Gipper. This is not Gipper the Governor or Gipper the President or even Gipper the B-list actor. This is Gipper, silver-tongued shill for the interests of capital.

It's a little-studied chapter of Reagan's career, but perhaps the most formative. As chronicled in Thomas Evans's The Education of Ronald Reagan: The General Electric Years and the Untold Story of His Conversion to Conservatism, Reagan was employed by GE first as a spokesman and later as a kind of employer-to-employee ambassador. With management facing a restive labor force, an obscure PR guru named Lemuel Boulware hatched the idea of using the emerging techniques of public relations to turn factory-line workers against their own unions. Reagan would be the vessel for this message, and it was in the hours he spent propagandizing the working class about the benefits of free markets that he forged the distinctive Reagan appeal: hard-right economics delivered in the sunny cadence of an amiable uncle.

So as momentum for national, universal healthcare built during the Truman Administration, foes such as the American Medical Association sought to build grassroots opposition. In an ingenious stroke, as Moore reports in Sicko, it organized thousands of coffee klatches across the country where suburban housewives could sip coffee, gossip and listen to a special recorded message about the evils of socialized medicine, a message delivered by the one and only Ronald Reagan.

The presence of Reagan in the film, making an argument that is the inverse of Sicko's, is fitting. Moore's entire post-Roger & Me career can be understood as a multimedia attempt to undo Reagan's great achievement: persuading blue-collar factory workers and other members of the working class to embrace his heady brew of jingoism, anticommunism, contempt for government and admiration for the virtues of unfettered capitalism.

For years Moore has, like Ahab pursuing the whale, been hunting the elusive Reagan Democrat--the heartland-dwelling, beer-drinking, blue-collar guy (or gal) who bowls on the weekend, loves his country and is fighting to stay afloat in winner-take-all America. He may look on the left with contempt, but it's not because he doesn't intuitively share its views: He is a visceral collectivist and unionist and an enemy of corporations. He is ready, Moore believes, to come over to our side, if only we would talk to him. .....(more)

The complete piece is at: http://www.thenation.com/doc/20070716/hayes

especially the segments on France, the UK and Canada. Moore will do more to educate people in this country how badly they've been fucked over for the past 40 years than any hundred of us. Seeing is believing and he's offering plenty of that.

It's no longer a bountiful country. It has become mean, pinched, and cruel.

The only question is what most people are going to do about it.

You can sign me up as a Social Democrat. We have socialized medicine in San Francisco for anyone making up to about $50k. I've had excellent care when I needed it.

I want to see single payer health insurance and the rest of the package available to everybody. That is what civilized countries have.

I've sent money and signed petitions, etc. for the nurses union here in California. The health insurance companies won't go down easily and I'm sure they have Arnie in their pocket as well as, sadly, Hilary and a bunch of other pols. It will take the rest of American industry like GM ganging up on them.

The thing I don't want is the mandatory insurance bs as they have in MA. That is unrealistic garbage that imples that people don't buy insurance because they are buying Cadillacs or something instead. I dropped out of private insurance when I hit 40 because I couldn't afford it. All the furniture, clothing, car, etc. that I've bought over the last 16 years would not have bought 5 years of health insurance. I just finally got Kaiser so if I lose my rent-controlled apartment here I won't suddenly lose my insurance if I have to move out of town to afford decent housing--one of my big fears in life