Newsweek: America the Unwelcoming

America the Unwelcoming

The United States is the only major country in the world to which travel has declined amid a tourist boom.
Nov 26, 2007 Issue


As an immigrant, I've always loved Thanksgiving for all the corniest reasons. It's a distinctly American holiday, secular and inclusive, focused on food, family and gratitude. But the one Thanksgiving tradition I try strenuously to avoid is travel. For those of you who must do it—and that's 27 million people this year—brace yourselves for massive delays and frayed tempers. President Bush announced a few measures to ease congestion, describing this week as "a season of dread for too many Americans." I only wish he would keep in mind that for foreigners now traveling to America, the dread is far more acute, and it's lasted far longer than a few days in November.

Every American who has a friend abroad has heard some story about the absurd hassle and humiliation of entering or exiting the United States. But these pale in comparison to the experience of foreigners who commit minor infractions. A tourist from New Zealand, Rick Giles, mistakenly overstayed his visa in America by a few days and found himself summarily arrested for six weeks earlier this fall. Treaty obligations say his country's embassy should have been informed of the arrest, but it wasn't. A German visitor, Valeria Vinnikova, overstayed her visa by a couple of days and tried to remedy the situation—so that she could spend more time with her fianc?, the Dartmouth College squash coach. Instead she was handcuffed and had her feet shackled, then was carted off to be imprisoned. She now faces deportation and a 10-year ban on entering the United States. (Thanks to AndrewSullivan .com for drawing attention to these.)

According to the Commerce Department, the United States is the only major country in the world to which travel has declined in the midst of a global tourism boom. And this is not about Arabs or Muslims. The number of Japanese visiting the United States declined from 5 million in 2000 to 3.6 million last year. The numbers have begun to increase, but by 2010 they're still projected to be 19 percent below 2000 levels. During this same span (2000–2010), global tourism is expected to grow by 44 percent.

The most striking statistic involves tourists from Great Britain. These are people from America's closest ally, the overwhelming majority of them white Anglos with names like Smith and Jones. For Brits, the United States these days is Filene's Basement. The pound is worth $2, a 47 percent increase in six years. And yet, between 2000 and 2006, the number of Britons visiting America declined by 11 percent. In that same period British travel to India went up 102 percent, to New Zealand 106 percent, to Turkey 82 percent and to the Caribbean 31 percent. If you're wondering why, read the polls or any travelogue on a British Web site. They are filled with horror stories about the inconvenience and indignity of traveling to America.

For many, the trials begin even before they arrive. In a world of expedited travel, getting a visa to enter the United States has become a laborious process. It takes, on average, 69 days in Mumbai, 65 days in S?o Paolo and 44 days in Shanghaisimply to process a request. It's no wonder that quick business trips to America are a thing of the past. Business travel to the United States declined by 10 percent between 2004 and 2005 (the most recent data available), while similar travel to Europe increased by 8 percent. Discover America, a travel-industry-funded organization that tries to boost tourism, estimates that the 17 percent overall decline in tourism since 9/11 has cost America $94 billion in lost tourist spending, 200,000 jobs and $16 billion in tax revenues.

more...

http://www.newsweek.com/id/70991

the fact that Canadian snowbirds don't want to spend much time in Florida........

is in their favor, finally.

What were the reasons given for the reluctance?

First one is the difficulty of getting health care and the expense of traveller's insurance that doesn't cover what needs to be covered. It cost a friend's in-laws pretty close to 35,000 when her FIL had a heart attack in Fla....and had to be med-evacced after catchng a bug in the hospital. The insurance company wouldn't cover most of the costs.

The rules getting there and back to Canada are a PITA. A couple who used to drive from NB every year was stopped at the border because they had a tool box in the trunk...and were accused of going to Fla to work (at 79 and 83?). They were turned back at the border. There are more hassles at the border than ever before, and the flights are uncomfortable, noisy, and you never know when you're going to be stopped.

Hurricanes and pollution, bugs and inconvenience, Disney World is for youngsters, and they can go to casinos and the like closer to home. If these people are travelling at all, they are tending to go to Europe, for the most part, or the Islands. Even Mexico and the Carribean are losing their appeal, partly because of a rash of well-publicized murders.

Mostly, however, it's the horror stories at the border, and the whole hassle of getting somewhere that doesn't seem to want them. Shopping is OK, but even that's getting to be a hassle at the border. Not worth the energy.

And I have to tell you that most Canadians despise this administration and are wary of what happened to Maher Arar.

I grew up across the river from Windsor and going back and forth was a pretty casual affair (except for agents looking for pot). Things have really changed.

Here is an article you might find interesting about three Finnish folk musicians being interrogated by airport customs in Mpls., under suspicion of trying to get rich by playing folk music in rural Minnesota. :D

http://www.startribune.com/462/story/1513926.html

:hi:

From admired nation to despised nation.

some land of the free. :eyes: