|
Edited on Thu Mar-10-05 11:37 AM by DireStrike
The best you can do is look at the individual factors that contribute to whether we will wind up fighting Iran. I'll list the ones I know:
Things that bring us closer to war:
- Petrodollar Hegemony. As the Euro emerges as a stable and trustworthy currency, it provides an alternative to the Dollar. Currently, the dollar is the world's reserve currency - the main currency. Oil prices everywhere are pegged to the dollar, which means you NEED dollars to buy oil. You need dollars to make many trades in the world today. The rest of the world has a vested interest in possessing dollars, and thus in keeping them valuable. This provides the U.S. with a kind of blank check, since it can print unlimited dollars at its sole discretion. If the dollar falls as the world reserve currency, it throws a lot of economic woe onto the U.S. Iraq began trading oil in Euros in 1999.
- Geopolitical Strategy. Our foreign policy is currently very similar to that of a group called Project for a New American Century, many members of which hold positions of power in our government. Their goals are to prevent any rivals, enemies, or even allies from rising in power to potentially challenge the U.S. Currently, we lack presence in the middle east. Iraq is part of our new "footprint" in the region, where we are building 14 permanant U.S. military bases. Whether to gain more turf or simply to show off our power in the region, a war with Iran would fit this strategy nicely - at least, if you believe such a war could be "won" in a non-pyhrric sense.
- Nukes. We don't want Iran to have nukes. They say they're not researching nukes. I don't trust them, but I also find it nearly impossible to trust U.S. intelligence these days.
- Israel. A powerful U.S. presence in the mideast is good for israel. Our leadership thinks that a war would increase our presence/power.
Things that prevent us from going to war:
- Troops. We don't have enough. My point of view, of course.
- Cost of "victory". Even if we won, it would be at far greater cost than almost any possible benefit. Again, my point of view.
- Reasons for war. We don't have any. The international community will not trust our grainy satellite photos of purported nuke facilities, or our supposed knowledge of the clandestine workings in Iran. The same goes for many people at home.
- Syria-Iran mutual defense agreement. They have one. Going to war with one could very possibly mean going to war with both. And if that happens... who knows what else it would lead to?
Double-edged Swords:
- Oil deals. Iran has cut lucrative deals to supply various countries with oil, including China, India, and Russia. This is a double edged sword because a need for oil could cause us to attack Iran and install a friendly government which would trade more with us. Our gung-ho government could also do this to show that we don't care about those other countries because we're so powerful. We would cut them off from the oil they need to gain power and potentially challenge us.
However, the other countries would not like this. They have many ways to hurt us, both militarily and economically.
|