|
Edited on Tue Nov-29-05 07:25 PM by 0007
Cunningham account of vulgar gesture disputed Congressman says he was returning behavior of heckler Source: San Diego Union-Tribune. 9 September 1998 pp. B-1, B-8.
By Dana Wilkie Copley News Service
Rep. Randy “Duke” Cunningham’s contention that he made an obscene gesture during a recent public appearance in response to similar behavior from a man in the audience has come under dispute from some of those who were there.
The man accused by Cunningham has denied he made such a gesture and others present — though not all — said he didn’t do it.
While speaking Saturday at a gathering of prostate cancer patients, Cunningham cursed at a man the Escondido Republican said was heckling him.
“He flipped me the bird first,” Cunningham, who had prostate surgery last month, later told a reporter. “The guy interrupted me four times, and when he started bad-mouthing the military, I had enough. I didn’t need that crap.”
Rancho Bernardo resident Chuck Cotton, who like Cunningham is a retired Navy man, insists he never made an obscene gesture at the congressman, and that he interrupted only once to suggest that defense spending should be cut even more than it has been.
“That’s when he gave me the finger and said ‘(expletive) you,’” said Cotton, a radioman during World War II and a retired purchaser for McDonald’s restaurants. “I think it’s unfortunate for a public official to make that kind of expletive, and to gesture to anyone publicly is uncalled for.”
“I did not give him the finger,” he added.
John Fistere, a retired engineer from El Cajon who sat near Cotton, said he never saw Cotton make a gesture at Cunningham. A reporter covering the event also said it did not appear Cotton made an obscene gesture.
The 74-year-old Cotton engaged in “a little bit” of heckling, Fistere said, adding that Cotton’s comment was loud enough for the audience of about 100 people at the San Diego Rehabilitation Institute to hear. But, he said, “I didn’t hear a lot of comment from anyone.”
On the other hand, the physician who organized the event, Israel Barken, said Cotton not only made such a gesture but “shouted” at Cunningham after the congressman shifted his remarks on prostate surgery to his opposition to military spending cuts in Congress.
“I was sitting in the first row and this guy (Cotton) was in the second row, very close,” said Barken, who formed the San Diego Prostate Cancer Support Group at Alvarado Hospital. “He started shouting, ‘Cut! Cut! Cut! Cut!’”
“It was an incident that shouldn’t have happened, and the whole meeting was about something else.”
Cunningham’s chief of staff, Patrick McSwain, said the congressman has already apologized and admitted he acted “inappropriately.”
“He has repeatedly interrupted and heckled, and very personally thought that the guy had made this gesture to him,” McSwain said.
“He’s done talking on the issue. He has recognized that he’s made some inappropriate comments, and that’s the end of the story.”
Meanwhile, Rep. Barney Frank — the gay Massachusetts Democrat about whom Cunningham made a crude comment during his speech — said yesterday that Cunningham has an odd fascination with homosexuality.
In describing his prostate cancer experience, Cunningham said that a rectal procedure he had undergone was “just not natural, unless maybe you’re Barney Frank.”
Cunningham later apologized for that reference, too.
“He tends to frequently blurt out stuff on gay issues,” said Frank in a telephone interview in Washington. “He seems to be more interested in discussing homosexuality than most homosexuals.”
But Frank dismissed Cunningham’s insult as coming from a man not well respected in Congress.
“He’s not a guy who’s taken all that seriously,” Frank said. “He does not have a high reputation for the thoughtful, analytical content of his remarks.”
It is not the first time Cunningham — who underwent surgery to remove his cancerous prostate gland last month — has come under fire for controversial remarks about homosexuals or the military.
In 1995, he referred to gays as “homos” on the House floor, and later apologized. He also has suggested that gays in the military would “degrade the national security.”
Referring to President Clinton’s anti-war activities during the Vietnam War, Cunningham once said Clinton “would be tried as a traitor and even shot” if he lived in another nation.
He challenged Rep. David Obey, D-Wis., to a fist fight during a House debate on congressional spending. And in March, when a top Army official told a House subcommittee about efforts to combat sexual harassment and discrimination in the military, Cunningham called the efforts “BS” and asserted that “our kids don’t like . . . political correctness.”
————————— Staff writers Dwight Daniels and Gerry Braun contributed to this report.
Yeah, a real brave man that hasn't a fucking brain in his head.
|