|
Edited on Sun Dec-21-03 05:27 PM by PackedForPerth
With all due respect to Chuck Rangel, it ain't gonna ever happen unless WWIII breaks out. Chuck feels very strongly about the character building benefits of national service. He did Korea and has felt ever since that everyone else ought to have a shot at what he went through, I think. He's very passionate about it. I watch at least one interview with him every year where he mounts and rides the "return to the draft" hobbyhorse for all it's worth.
The only way it will be "fair" is if they take all 4 million every year. I did the Vietnam Tango and the constant refrain was that it wasn't fair. They were right. We had the draft board. Anyone who had an influential doctor in town could claim a bad back (like Dean) or a hernia (which was a far more common complaint). I've often wondered just how many hernia operations that were done in the late 1960's and early 1970's were bogus. I suspect that most of them were. :-)
We tried defering people who were going to work in the defense industry, people who were going to teach K-12. Then Bobby Kennedy and later Edward got on their high horses and demanded first a "draft test" to cull out people who were in college who "didn't belong there" and later those bloody lotteries. I've often suspected that many, if not most middle-aged neocons were subjected to the lotteries and as a result wound up with a deep visceral hatred of at least the Kennedys and probably liberals in general who went on their jihad to make selective service fair when it was structurally impossible to do so. I've had many people on the right tell me just that.
It's easy, however, to do the numbers. Here is a first approximation. Let's run 'em on a 40 hour week and pay 'em something like minimum wage.
($7/hr)(52 weeks/year)(40 hours/week)(4000000)(((18 months service)/(12 months/year)))= $87,360,000,000/year for salaries alone.
You then have to house 'em, build bases for 'em, equip 'em with weapons to some extent, give 'em clothing and provide 'em food and medical care. It would bankrupt the US faster than anything anybody has done in the last several administrations.
Furthermore it would give us a standing army that would dwarf anything on the planet and scare the whey out of people like the Chinese, probably touching off an arms race to end all arms races.
With all respect to Chuck Rangel, it's a stupid thing to propose. I doubt seriously that he's serious about it except, maybe as a thought experiment.
|