|
Had some friends over tonight to watch some hockey. While none of them are very politically oriented, they do tend to lean right. I got in a conversation with one of them about Jessica Lynch. He told me he couldn't understand why "us liberals" wanted to defame her so badly. She'd been through heck, and she deserved to be treated as a hero, and so did the people who rescued her.
There were so many ways to attack this argument, but I decided to try something new. I told him that her story was blown out of proportion and over-dramatized by a media desperate to shed the war in a favorable light with stories of heroes and rescues. They latched onto the story because she exemplifies the ideal American daughter. I told him to imagine if Jessica Lynch was black; how much would we have heard about her were that the case?
He replied that there was a black woman who was a prisoner of war, along with others in her group (many of whom were minorities, he added with some pride). He said they were treated like heroes too, and he saw their story on TV.
I asked him what her name was.
He thought, and thought, and thought. In the end, he could not remember the black woman's name.
And that was my point.
(Later in the evening, in the period break of one of the many hockey games we watched together, the CBC news (Canadian) came on for a couple minutes to mention the explosion in Istanbul, today's downed helicopters and dead US soldiers, and a few other things. I imagine it was a bit of culture shock compared to the Fox "news" he's accustomed to. He was silent throughout the CBC news, totally aphonic. I don't think I made any converts tonight, but I probably got someone thinking...)
|