|
1. For religious people, everything is a religious issue. (I knew that, and I grew up atheist. Jeez.)
2. Everything is political.
Anyway, they're not the ones we need to reach. It's the moderates who can be swayed by values-based arguments, especially when Democrats don't offer a contrasting moral vision. You have to convince them that the right to abortion is part of a coherent value system that stands for more than "abortion on demand" (which to many people, sounds like "abortion as birth control").
If it were me, I'd start by arguing that decisions about abortion are too complex and personal for simple laws, something along the lines of the "between a woman, her doctor, and her God" bit Kerry used. Then I'd get tough, and start pointing out why absolutist positions taken by right-wingers do more harm than good.
First, some high-profile candidates need to stand up and say that abortion isn't just for bad girls. (Why? Because that's what the Republicans are thinking, and that's what they want everyone to think. It's easier to take rights away from women if you convince the public those rights are only used by irresponsible women.) Sometimes, wives need abortions. Sometimes, moms need abortions. Outlawing abortion doesn't punish wicked women; it punishes all women.
Second, I'd stop taking shit about late term abortions. No normal person chooses a late-term abortion casually; they choose late term abortions because they're in medical danger. If we let the right-wingers outlaw all late-term abortions, women will die. I don't know about the rest of you, but I'm against laws that will cause women to die just because we've outlawed doctors treating them.
Third, I'd stand up for the judicial override of parental consent laws. If you don't give judges the power to override parents, you will eventually have some crazy parent (probably in Arizona) force a girl to give birth to her uncle's child. I think America should be anti-inbreeding, and if the Republican party considers the rights of incestuous child molesters more important than the victims, we should be making them explain why.
There are moral reasons to defend reproductive rights. (These were the creepy, jaw-dropping ones meant to stun people into thinking harder -- there are subtler ones, like the connections between unplanned pregnancies, high-school dropouts, and long-term poverty for women.) If Democrats want to protect reproductive rights in a values-voting America, they've got to stop acting apologetic for supporting the right to abortion, and start remembering that there are undeniable moral arguments to be made in favor of the right.
|