When you have James Taranto criticizing Fox's handling of the 2003 debate for Democrats...you know there were problems. Of course Taranto is wrong, Dean is not a liberal in most views...but at least he saw the unfairness of the Fox debate.
http://www.opinionjournal.com/best/?id=110003993 Wednesday, September 10, 2003 2:47 p.m. EDT
Juan Williams Smears Dean
TARANTO: "Howard Dean deviates from liberal orthodoxy on one issue: gun rights. Coming from Vermont, the state with the nation's least restrictive gun laws, Dean holds a genuinely moderate position. He opposes new federal gun-control laws, but he also believes the 10th Amendment trumps the Second and that states have the authority to pass whatever gun laws they see fit. Here is how Juan Williams, a journalist for NPR and Fox News Channel who was among the panel of questioners at last night's Democratic presidential debate, characterized Dean's position (note: Fox, which co-sponsored the debate with the Congressional Black Caucus, does not seem to have a transcript on its Web site, though the Washington Post does, but the transcriptions are our own, aided by TiVo):
WILLIAMS: Gov. Dean has suggested that states like Vermont, Montana and Wyoming, with overwhelmingly white populations, really don't need gun control, in part because of their rural character, but urban areas, such as Baltimore, Md. , with large minority populations, do need gun control.
TARANTO: "This didn't sound right to us. We've certainly never heard Dean cast his position in racial terms, and indeed it's hard to imagine any politician in the 21st century taking the position that Williams attributes to Dean. Dean's response convinces us we were right":
DEAN: I have never said that African-American cities need gun control and white states don't. I have never said that. What I have said is that rural states--and this includes places like Tennessee perhaps--that have low homicide rates, don't need the same gun laws that urban states do, and if urban states want to have lots of gun control, let 'em have it, but just don't impose the same gun laws that you have in New York City or New Jersey or California on states like Vermont, which have a very low homicide rate.
What can I say. It was pretty bad...and all the Larouche people yelling.
But I am sure Fox has gotten better since then. And they were allowed to go on yelling and shouting. Finally Al Sharpton told them off, someone asked where's Larouche...Dean said maybe in jail and everyone laughed.
I actually felt sorry for Lieberman, they were giving him the worst time.
Fox should have stopped the yelling out and removed them quickly.
The Nevada State chair posted a thread at Daily Kos. I found this comment in the thread. I agree that if you have to ask them to be fair, something is wrong.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2007/2/23/203348/727 "Listen, just the mere FACT that you have to discuss, with a "news" organization that you really REALLY want them to be fair and not pick on the democratic party and their debating candidates - just that fact alone - makes this whole enterprise pathetic.
Why in the world would you even consider such an event if you know - ahead of time - that the way this channel portrays the candidates might be an issue.
The fact that you have to have someone sign on a dotted line not to belittle or trash the candidates in their SIGNAGE, SET DESIGN, and MODERATORS? What universe do we live in that you would even consider something like this? Fair treatment should be a given. It shouldn't even be a question. If you are so unsure that you must sign paperwork saying "pretty please," then it's simply embarrasing."
Hey, I realize they are going to go ahead anyway. I fear it is setting a precedent in dealing with the grassroots groups. Greenwald's group is large, outstanding. MoveOn is millions. Whatever the intent, it is obvious they will do it anyway. Doing it anyway against opposition from our party to reach out to the other...that is getting to be a pattern.
People disagree with me here, and that's ok. But it is too reminiscent of how we went to war in Iraq. One of those things the party needed to do, just like this. It does concern me a lot.