So now I am more and more convinced this was right about
Rahm's urging the candidates at a DCCC forum to take a hard line on immigration.CQ Politics has this from November. Looks like Heath took someone else's plan, kept the enforcement part only. He did it without consulting the proper Democrats. No wonder more Republicans are for it than Democrats.
Divisive Border Bill Faces Tough RoadNorth Carolina Democrat Heath Shuler ’s new immigration-enforcement bill, cheered by immigration hard-liners and jeered by Hispanic lawmakers, now faces a major roadblock: Rep. Loretta Sanchez , who chairs the Homeland Security Subcommittee on Border, Maritime and Global Counterterrorism.
Sanchez says Shuler, a former pro football player, made a rookie mistake by not consulting with her before he introduced the bill, which is deepening an existing rift between politically vulnerable centrist Democrats and Hispanic members. Homeland Security is one of eight committees to which the bill was referred, but the panel has the lead in dealing with it.
“I would say Heath better come talk to me about it,” Sanchez, a California Democrat, told CQ Politics.
..."Rep. Luis Gutierrez , D-Ill., the author of a “comprehensive” immigration overhaul that would combine enforcement measures with a new temporary-worker program and a means for illegal immigrants to become citizens, said Shuler’s bill is incomplete.
“It looked like he grabbed my STRIVE bill , took all the enforcement parts of it and forgot to turn the page. It’s a book he didn’t finish reading,” Gutierrez said. “We might as well put the Republicans in charge.”
Indeed, Shuler’s measure echoes the calls of the most ardent critics of immigration bills that would allow undocumented workers to eventually become American citizens. That includes retiring Republican Rep. Tom Tancredo of Colorado , who has based his campaign for the Republican presidential nomination on opposition to illegal immigration. Tancredo signed on as one of 89 cosponsors, nearly all of whom represent the most conservative factions of the Republican and Democratic parties.
This reinforces my belief that we have to quit encouraging congressmen in red states to act like Republicans. We have done that too long.