TO: Superdelegates
FROM: David Plouffe, Campaign Manager
RE: An Update on the Race for Delegates
DA: May 7, 2008
There are only six contests remaining in the Democratic primary calendar and only 217 pledged delegates left to be awarded. Only 7 percent of the pledged delegates remain on the table. There are 260 remaining undeclared superdelegates, for a total of 477 delegates left to be awarded.
With North Carolina and Indiana complete, Barack Obama only needs 172 total delegates to capture the Democratic nomination. This is only 36% of the total remaining delegates.
Conversely, Senator Clinton needs 326 delegates to reach the Democratic nomination, which represents a startling 68% of the remaining delegates.
With the Clinton path to the nomination getting even narrower, we expect new and wildly creative scenarios to emerge in the coming days. While those scenarios may be entertaining, they are not legitimate and will not be considered legitimate by this campaign or its millions of supporters, volunteers, and donors.
We believe it is exceedingly unlikely Senator Clinton will overtake our lead in the popular vote and in fact lost ground on that measure last night. However, the popular vote is a deeply flawed and illegitimate metric for deciding the nominee - since each campaign based their strategy on the acquisition of delegates. More importantly, the rules of the nomination are predicated on delegates, not popular vote.
Just as the Presidential election in November will be decided by the electoral college, not popular vote, the Democratic nomination is decided by delegates.
If we believed the popular vote was somehow the key measurement, we would have campaigned much more intensively in our home state of Illinois and in all the other populous states, in the pursuit of larger raw vote totals. But it is not the key measurement. We played by the rules, set by you, the DNC members, and campaigned as hard as we could, in as many places as we could, to acquire delegates. Essentially, the popular vote is not much better as a metric than basing the nominee on which candidate raised more money, has more volunteers, contacted more voters, or is taller.
The Clinton campaign was very clear about their own strategy until the numbers become too ominous for them. They were like a broken record , repeating ad nauseum that this nomination race is about delegates. Now, the word delegate has disappeared from their vocabulary, in an attempt to change the rules and create an alternative reality.
We want to be clear - we believe that the winner of a majority of pledged delegates will and should be the nominee of our party. And we estimate that after the Oregon and Kentucky primaries on May 20, we will have won a majority of the overall pledged delegates According to a recent news report, by even their most optimistic estimates the Clinton Campaign expects to trail by more than 100 pledged delegates and will then ask the superdelegates to overturn the will of the voters.
But of course superdelegates are free to and have been utilizing their own criteria for deciding who our nominee should be. Many are deciding on the basis of electability, a favorite Clinton refrain. And if you look at the numbers, during a period where the Clinton campaign has been making an increasingly strident pitch on electability, it is clear their argument is failing miserably with superdelegates.
Since February 5, the Obama campaign has netted 107 superdelegates, and the Clinton campaign only 21. Since the Pennsylvania primary, much of it during the challenging Rev. Wright period, we have netted 24
and the Clinton campaign 17.
At some point - we would argue that time is now - this ceases to be a theoretical exercise about how superdelegates view electability. The reality of the preferences in the last several weeks offer a clear guide of how strongly superdelegates feel Senator Obama will perform in November, both in building a winning campaign for the presidency as well as providing the best electoral climate across the country for all Democratic candidates.
It is important to note that Senator Obama leads Senator Clinton in superdelegate endorsements among Governors, United States Senators and members of the House of Representatives. These elected officials all have a keen sense for who our strongest nominee will be in November.
It is only among DNC members where Senator Clinton holds a lead, which has been rapidly dwindling.
As we head into the final days of the campaign, we just wanted to be clear with you as a party leader, who will be instrumental in making the final decision of who our nominee will be, how we view the race at this point.
Senator Obama, our campaign and our supporters believe pledged delegates is the most legitimate metric for determining how this race has unfolded. It is simply the ratification of the DNC rules - your rules - which we built this campaign and our strategy around.
TALKING POINTS ON NC AND IN RACES
Key message point
� Clinton needed big wins in both states to cut into Obama's overall lead, and she didn't get them. Obama won a commanding victory in North Carolina, and only lost in Indiana because of large numbers of Republicans wanting to face Clinton in the general election. That's not enough to convince superdelegates to overturn Obama's pledged delegate lead.
A huge night for Barack Obama
The tight finish in Indiana and Barack Obama's huge win in North Carolina have fundamentally changed this race. Barack Obama was expected to lose Indiana by a sizeable margin--yet after the toughest weeks of his campaign, he beat every poll and every expectation. And if it hadn't been for Republicans taking Democratic ballots to vote against him, he likely would have on in Indiana, too.
In North Carolina, Obama won a commanding 14-point victory. North Carolina--which Senator Clint hoped would be a "game-changer for her--is the 10th-largest state in country. It's bigger than New Jersey, for example, and this win puts to rest the idea that Obama can't win the big states
Clinton needed big wins in both states to cut into Obama's overall lead, and she didn't get them. She missed her last chance to catch up in the delegate count--the measure that will determine the Democratic nominee.
She now needs huge delegate yields in every remaining state, and needs to win new superdelegates every day. She fell stunningly short of her goals tonight, and I don't think she's in good shape to win over the superdelegates she would need.
Shattering the myths
The chattering class said Barack Obama would get crushed in Indiana because of an alleged problem with working class voters. But the reality is that Barack Obama erased Clinton's big lead in Indiana precisely by connecting with working people.
In fact, over the course of Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Indiana, Senator Obama has steadily improved among white voters, voters without a college degree, and voters making less than $50,000.
The North Carolina results also helped to erase many of the myths that the Clinton campaign has been pushing. In North Carolina, Obama won voters who make under $50,000, and won voters without a college degree.
Voters in both states said Obama shares their values more than Clinton, and saw him as much more honest and trustworthy than Clinton. Voters in both states also said that Clinton attacked unfairly over the course of the campaign.
Delegate race slipping away from Clinton
There were187 pledged delegates at stake today, leaving only 217 pledged delegates on the tablefor the remaining contests--which truly made tonight Clinton's last, best chance to make any sizeable dent in our delegate lead
The math after tonight is simple: counting pledged and unpledged delegates, Senator Obama will need only about 38 percent of the remaining delegates in order to win the nomination, while Clinton will need more than 60 percent of all delegates in order to do so.
At the end of tonight, we will be less than 200 delegates away from securing the nomination.
Clinton couldn't land a key blow even in heavily favorable media environment
As the news media has mostly taken a pass on Clinton, she's been shooting free throws while we have gotten a heavy dose of scrutiny. And the Clinton family made more than 100 campaign stops across the state.
If she can't make up ground in times like these, when the atmospherics are about as good as they are ever going to get for her, after our campaign has spent a week enmeshed in Rev. Wright controversy, there is no reason to believe she is going to be able to make up ground at any other point.
Limbaugh Crossovers
Limbaugh has been urging right-wingers to vote against Obama
There really has never been any question that Senator Clinton would win Indiana, where she has the support of Senator Evan Bayh's political operation and the demographics heavily favor her. But we saw today that perhaps her strongest asset was that Republicans believe she'll be an easier opponent to beat in November.
Right-wing radio host Rush Limbaugh has been urging his listeners to cross over and vote in the Democratic primary in Indiana to help Clinton's chances at becoming the nominee.
Exit polling showed that up to 7 percent of the primary vote came from Limbaugh voters--well above the final spread between the two candidates. Reports from Indiana polling places confirmed that record numbers of Republicans were taking Democratic ballots to vote against Obama. And Limbaugh himself bragged about the success of his effort on his radio show today.
Republicans are desperate to face Clinton, because they know Obama will be harder to beat
Let's be very clear: the Republicans want to face Senator Clinton in November, because they know that Senator Obama will be a stronger nominee for the Democrats, and will help Democratic candidates down the ballot. Republicans are so scared of Obama that they're actually skipping their own primary to vote against him.
That's a stunning testament to the threat that Obama will pose to Republicans come fall.
If I were the Clinton campaign, I don't think I'd be celebrating too hard tonight. Winning a state on the strength of voters who want to see you defeated isn't exactly the kind of win you want--or the message you want to send to superdelegates.
Clinton Campaign Trying to Change the Math--Agai
Having lost their last chance to catch up to Barack Obama in pledged delegates
We will abide by the rules that every candidate agreed to at the beginning of this campaign, no matter how desperate the Clinton campaign is to change them. When he is the nominee, Barack Obama will seat both the Florida and Michigan delegates and build a campaign in both states that can win in November.
Ickes Comments
Comments are beyond the pale--and a distortion
This afternoon, top Clinton advisor Harold Ickes said that if Barack Obama were the nominee, there might be a so-called "October surprise" that would hand the election the Republicans. Using this kind of fear tactic is simply beyond the pale--and a total distortion.
Time after time, we've seen that the Republicans are desperate to face Clinton in the fall because they know that Obama would be a stronger candidate. That's what brought Limbaugh listeners out in droves today to vote for Clinton.
To suggest that Clinton would somehow offer less risk of an October surprise--at the same time as Republicans are actively working to see her nominated--is certainly curious.