McCain Was in Favor of Talks with Syria, Despite Saying they Were "Sponsoring and Harboring Terrorists"
After the invasion of Iraq there was much talk among conservatives about invading Syria. Then Secretary of State Colin Powell was heavily criticized for taking a trip to Syria to talk to its leadership. Newt Gingrich said, "The concept of the American secretary of state going to Damascus to meet with a terrorist-supporting, secret-police-wielding dictator is ludicrous."
What did John McCain have to say about the trip? Despite the fact that John McCain believed that Syria was a "state sponsor of terror," was "harboring terrorists," and were sending "Syrians in to fight Americans," he thought it was worth talking to them, saying that Powell's trip was "appropriate." (See below)
McCain is directly contradicting himself by attacking Senator Obama on his plan to confront Iran at the negotiating table. A pattern is emerging. While McCain claims to be a deep foreign policy thinker with positions carefully developed from his quarter century in Washington, the reality seems to be that his positions - when not outright crazy - are often knee-jerk and contradictory - often dictated by what his temperament is at that moment or influenced by how the political winds are moving.
Here are the transcripts:
McCain on Chris Matthews said on April 23, 2003"We know the Syrians allowed, or sent Syrians in to fight Americans." But McCain said that:
"I think it's appropriate that Colin Powell is going there...
MATTHEWS: So you don't agree with Newt Gingrich dumping all over him? You don't agree with Newt Gingrich dumping on the Powell trip?
MCCAIN: You know, Dick -- Richard Armitage is Powell's deputy. And he's a wonderful guy. He served in Vietnam. And he's a really tough guy. And he was quoted someplace today that Newt Gingrich is out of therapy.
McCain added:
Colin Powell is going to look Bashar aside in the eye and say, look, you know. You better clean up your act here. It's a new day in the Middle East. And I think it's entirely appropriate to do that.
Five days earlier on the Today Show on April 18th, McCain said the same thing. When asked how he would proceed with Syria - a country that he believed to be a state-sponsor of terrorism - McCain said he would talk first.
LAUER: Let me ask you about Syria.
Mr. McCAIN: Sure.
LAUER: They have denied possessing weapons of mass destruction, they've also denied harboring any senior members of the Iraqi leader. The US administration says they have evidence to the contrary. How would you proceed with that situation?
Mr. McCAIN: I think it's very appropriate that Colin Powell is going to Syria. I think we should put diplomatic and other pressures on them. It's also a time for Mr. Asad Bashar to realize that he should be more like his father was. I think he's too heavily influenced by a lot of the radical Islamic elements and--and militant groups.
LAUER: Do you think Syria meets the criteria set forth by the president in his post-9/11 address to Congress that they pose an imminent threat to the US in that they are either sponsoring or harboring terrorists?
Mr. McCAIN: I think they're--they're sponsoring and harboring terrorists. I think they have been occupying Lebanon, which should be free and independent for a long time, but I don't think that that means that we will now resort to the military action. We--we can apply a lot of pressure other than military--than the military action. So what I'm saying, we're a long way away from it.
LAUER: Under what circumstances--under what circumstances would you back military action?
Mr. McCAIN: When we've exhausted all other options. And we have a lot of options to--to exercise. And I'm glad Colin Powell's going there, but the Syrians have got to understand there's a new day in the Middle East.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/max-bergmann/mccain-was-in-favor-of-ta_b_102099.htmlBen Smith - Politico
e-mail: bsmith@politico.com
aim: benobserver
Rachel Maddow -- Air America Radio
Title: Co-host
Department: Unfiltered
E-mail: syndication_info@airamericaradio.com
Phone: (212) 889-2965
Fax: (212) 447-5292
E-mail Ed Schultz during the show!
ed@edschultzshow.com
STEPHANIE MILLER SHOW
stephanie@stephaniemiller.com
Randi Rhodes
E-mail: randi@novamradio.com
Keith Olbermann -- MSNBC
Title: Host
Department: Countdown with Keith Olbermann
E-mail: countdown@msnbc.com
Chris Matthews -- MSNBC
Title: Host
Department: Hardball with Chris Matthews
E-mail: hardball@msnbc.com
Phone: (202) 783-2615
Fax: (202) 737-4986
Dan Abrams -- MSNBC
Title: Host
Department: The Abrams Report
E-mail: abramsreport@msnbc.com
Tim Russert -- NBC News
Title: Host; Senior VP; Washington Bureau Chief
Department: Meet the Press
E-mail: mtp@msnbc.com
Phone: (202) 885-4548
Fax: (202) 966-4544
Bob Schieffer -- CBS News
Title: Anchor & Moderator - FTN; Interim Anchor - CBS Evening News; Chief Washington Correspondent
Department: Face the Nation with Bob Schieffer
E-mail: ftn@cbsnews.com
Phone: (202) 457-4481
Fax: (202) 457-1533
Jill Abramson -- New York Times
Title: Managing Editor - Newsgathering
Department: Headquarters
E-mail: abramson@nytimes.com
Phone: (212) 556-1234
Fax: (212) 556-3622
Robin Toner -- New York Times
Title: Political, Congressional Correspondent
Department: Washington Bureau
E-mail: rotone@nytimes.com
Phone: (202) 862-0445
Fax: (202) 862-0340
Dirk Mathison -- Los Angeles Times
Title: Online Political Editor
Department: LATimes.com
E-mail: dirk.mathison@latimes.com
Phone: (213) 237-5000
Fax: (231) 237-4712
THE OBAMA CAMPAIGN
http://my.barackobama.com/page/s/contact2watchdog@barackobama.com
Printer-friendly format
Email this thread to a friend
Bookmark this thread
(35 posts)
Send PM |
Profile |
Ignore
