|
Jan 26, 2000. The first GOP primary debate, held in New Hampshire. Look at who wins all the logic points. Look at who avoids the question and outright lies in his answer. Look at who won the nomination, and then went on to win the presidency after three debates with Al Gore, who is not a stupid man.
-----------
BROWN: Mr. Forbes, you get the next question.
FORBES: I'll ask it of Governor Bush.
BUSH: I was hoping so.
FORBES: I'm sure.
When you ran for governor in 1994, you criticized Anne Richards for the fact that Texas had 13,000 more state employees than did New York state. Since then, the gap is now 36,000. Texas has 36,000 more employees than the state of New York does at state-level. Under your leadership spending has gone up 36 percent -- almost twice the rate of the Clinton-Gore administration.
On your so-called tax cuts, your own budget director said that six out of 10 Texans did not get a tax cut in this last round. And on education, you've dumbed down the standards to the point where in Texas, your SAT ranking has gone from 40th in the nation to 46th in the nation. What can you tell the people of New Hampshire, and of America, that you won't do in Washington what you've done in Texas?
BUSH: So many half-stories, so little time.
I -- let's start with education. People who've looked at the state of Texas have consistently said that because we've set high standards, abolished social promotion, got a vibrant charter school movement, have got a public school choice movement, that we're making the best progress in the nation for improvement amongst minority students; that our minority students because of our strong accountability system are making tremendous improvement; that are schools are some -- ranked as some of the best in the country, Steve. Our public school system is meeting the challenge.
In terms of the budget, I've slowed the rate of growth down. And when you take out population growth and inflation, it's by far the slowest rate of growth ever in my state's history.
In terms of tax cuts, I not only led our state to a billion- dollar tax cut in '97, I led our state to a $2 billion tax cut in 1999. Real, meaningful tax cuts.
But I guess the way to answer your question is, you know, the people of Texas took a look at my record, the second-biggest state in the Union, a mighty important electoral state for any Republican running for president, and they said, Mr. Governor, we accept your record, and they overwhelmingly voted me back into office. I nearly got 70 percent of the vote.
FORBES: Well, George, on, again, on SATs, Texas is one of the few states where minority scores have gone down, not up. Standards have been dumbed down. Eight-grade science tests in Texas shows four -- picture of four insects and says pick out the fly.
So, that's why the test scores have been not going up. Now again, how are you going to improve education nationally when in Texas it's gone down?
And in terms of tax cuts, yours is a tax cut that only Clinton and Gore could love when most people don't get it.
BUSH: Steve...
FORBES: Your own budget director said six out of 10 didn't get it.
BUSH: Let me answer, OK.
I -- you know the people of Texas looked at the real facts. I just explained them to you. Our test scores...
FORBES: What are the real facts on SAT's?
BUSH: Please don't interrupt me. Let me finish, OK.
FORBES: Well, answer the question.
BUSH: The test scores in my state on the NAPE (ph) test, which compares state to state, show dramatic improvement. And that's -- objective analysis after objective analysis has ranked Texas as one of the best education states in the country. It's not only because of me. It's because of teachers and principles and parents.
One reason our -- our SAT scores have improved since I've been the governor, you need to get your researchers to do a better job, but unlike many states...
FORBES: Your ranking went down.
BUSH: Unlike many states, we make sure as many kids can take the SAT as possible. We include all kinds of children. We want our children in Texas to take the SAT.
---------
Bush is a master at getting his message across and deflecting criticism. Fuck logic, and fuck Yale competitive debate teams with their scored forensics. This is about advertising. Bush is a force to be reckoned with, maybe even feared. Every time we talk him down on this board, we set ourselves up for more disappointment.
The race is not always to the swift.
|