|
Edited on Sun Jul-20-08 02:31 AM by housewolf
I can think of 2 or 3 things to suggest to her -
What type of bread is she baking - white, whole wheat or multi-grain? Whole wheat dough presents some challenges, so if that's what she's working on, I might have some additional ideas.
Also, what is she using to knead her dough - by hand or machine (if machine, what sort of machine?)
1) Consistency of the dough - Make sure that the loaf has enough water. The biggest problem people have when learning to make bread is that they make their dough too dry. The dough should be soft and moist, a bit tacky but not sticky. Not dry. Sticky is when you touch the dough with your fingers, gobs of dough stick to your fingers. Tacky is when you touch the dough with your fingers, the dough tries to stick to your fingers but most of it stays with the dough ball (maybe a tiny bit sticking to your fingers). You might suggest that she purchase a package of frozen bread dough from the supermarket, thaw it out and then work with it some to get the feel for what the proper consistency and gluten development should be for a maximum rise. The type of flour could be playing a part too - Bread flour needs more water than all purpose flour does, and whole wheat flour needs even more than that. Other grains or add-ins could cause the dough to require more water, too.
2) Yeast - What brand/type of yeast is she using and is it still fresh and is she using the correct amount? If it's active dry yeast she can proof it in some water with a little sugar to ensure its viability. Instant yeast is harder to proof, but she could make a little sponge of some water, flour and a little sugar and watch it over the course of an hour or so to see how much it rises. What's important to figure out is where the bread is failing... is it that the dough isn't rising sufficiently during the rise phase or are the loaves failing after they've been shaped, prior to or during baking.
3) Gluten development - If she's not getting a sufficient gluten development, she'll get dense loaves, The windowpane test works great for evaluationg your gluten development (let me know if you need some info on the windowpane test).
4) Punch down/shaping - Could be she's being too agressive and working all/most of the carbon dioxide out of the dough either when she punches down or shapes her loaves. "Punch down" is sort of a mis-nomer... you really want to treat the dough fairly gently and fold the dough in on itself to re-distribute the yeast cells, but you don't want to knock all the air out of the dough.
5) Altitude - Is she baking at high altitude? If so, her bread dough probably needs extra water (because of the dryness) and less salt (to prevent over-rising). Bread rises faster at high altitude, so it might be that the dough is over-rising and falling back down.
Good luck!
|