|
Edited on Thu Jun-09-05 08:17 AM by BlueIris
Murdoch's language is really, really colloquial, and the evidence she uses to back up the arguments she makes is from her own clinical experiences as a psychologist, (so it's genuine, but she is, effectively, her only source) and therefore, I didn't feel comfortable sticking this under "Core Texts." The prose isn't going to be for everyone, the informal nature of her writing is going to strike many readers as "wimpy" or "unconvincing." And, although I doubt that any woman my age (26) hasn't experience a little of what Murdoch is talking about, I think it would be hard for anyone to accept all of the issues she purports to have seen affecting all modern American women who have mothers.
Still, this one really helped me to understand some of the reasons for the less-pleasant aspects of my relationship with my mother. I'd always heard people talk about the so-called gap between Second Wave feminists and their feminist kids, or between Second Wavers and their younger students, assistants, coworkers, fellow election volunteers what-have-you. I'd heard about the problems older feminists allegedly have getting alon with younger feminists, and about how this sometimes results in a feeling that members of these two groups "aren't working together" because of "generational conflicts" and an "inability to understand each other." Finally, lots of people I'd worked and studied with had given me their opinion that the mothers of the Baby Boom/Boom Echo generation, particularly if they were feminist, were somewhat disconnected from their Gen X/Y kids (especially their daughters). I was always like, "well, I've never have those problems. I work and communicate successfully with older women, many of whom are feminists, including my mother, what are people talking about?" (Those of you who are aware of these issues and their sources are probably laughing your heads off right now.) Then I read Murdoch's chapter describing some common conflicts that can occur between women of these age groups, and explanations for why these conflicts take place and I realized, "My mother treats me like that all the time!" So, this book really helped me understand her and our relationship better. We interact more companionably now, there are fewer conflicts.
And yes, there are about six hundered other things Murdoch also examines about the psychology and personality of the modern woman, with, what I think, in the end, are helpful suggestions for how women can simply become more self-actualized, which she manages to do without putting too many qualifications on what self-actualized means, in an emotional, personal, professional or spiritual sense.
|