This is really, really stupid as shit. I posted about this back in March and DUer's responded with many signatures for the petition. Probably want to shoot off some more LTTE's in support of Panse, now. The fact that this news article asks the faux-equivalence question "Is it art or is it just lewd?" shows what this poor guy is up against. The link to my original post is below the article.http://www.recordonline.com/archive/2006/05/10/news-dcpanse10-05-10.htmlMay 10, 2006
Nude-figure drawing: Is it art or is it just lewd? School seeks answers
Disciplinary hearing opens on Middletown teacher By Dianna Cahn
Times Herald-Record
dcahn@th-record.com
Middletown
- snip -
In Middletown yesterday, opening salvos were fired in a disciplinary hearing that looks like just such a showdown, pitting a well-rounded art education against sexuality in the classroom. When Middletown High School art teacher Peter Panse offered his students a nude-figure drawing course out of school, he said it was necessary for any art college applicant. He called it art.
- snip -
"Discussions of viewing a nude model injects sexuality into a conversation with a 14- or 15-year-old," Berlin said.
Panse's lawyer Jonathan Lovett called the district leaders "pilgrim-like" and prudish and said the case showed "where this school district leadership is: in a Cro-Magnon state."
The hearing started contentiously when Berlin challenged Friday's ruling by hearing officer Joel Douglas, who denied a district request to close the public hearing when students testify. It violated student privacy laws, Berlin said. Douglas wasn't buying it. As long as parents and students consented, it was not a problem, he said, seemingly annoyed.
- snip -
Panse is also accused of violating a condition of a 1997 memo admonishing him about making "comments that students could construe as being of a personal or sexual nature."
Lovett mocked the memo, noting it was authored by former Superintendent Robert Sigler, who was later convicted of molesting a teen male student.MORE
ORIGINAL POST FROM MARCH:
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=364&topic_id=638134LETTERS TO THE EDITOR FROM JANUARY:
http://www.recordonline.com/archive/2006/01/24/opinion-24opedletterstues-01-24.htmlReaders comment on art teacher's suspension
Regarding the suspension of Middletown High School art teacher Peter Panse, I truly do wonder what the members of the Middletown school board use for brains. He didn't involve the parents while urging art students to take nude figure drawing classes? What does that mean?
- snip -
I do disagree with Panse's lawyer on one point. He claims that on a scale of 1 to 10 in stupidity, this is an 11. I think it's a 47.
Deborah L. Nagle
Chester
* * *
In all the 14 years I was the art critic for Newsweek magazine and, before that, 20-plus years as a college art professor, I never encountered anything quite as idiotic as the suspension of Middletown High School art teacher Peter Panse for encouraging students to take life drawing classes in New York City.
The nude figure is central to the grand tradition of Western art, from the ancient Greeks through Michelangelo to Picasso and beyond. Experience in drawing the nude figure is essential for any serious student of art. On a practical level, the inclusion of well-done figure drawings in a high school student's application portfolio to a college art department or an art school is a huge plus, especially in getting scholarship money. And a life drawing class is one of the safest, least eroticized and most wholesome environments in modern life - including cineplex, the mall and, yes, the hallways of a large public high school.
The school board - whose idea of helping ambitious high school students is to stifle their education and careers - owes Panse not only immediate reinstatement, but also a public apology.
Peter Plagens
Callicoon Center
MORE