|
This is a good thread topic, but I think it deserves some real thought. Sometimes the problem is not just a "stupid" stereotype/enemy, that we can all fight and be superior to; sometimes, the problem is the typical way that everybody thinks.
There are two problems here, I think, one endemic and one recent: the situation that always exists is the one where a lot of progress has been made, people get used to it, time passes, and they totally forget or a new generation comes along, and they just think the improved condition is "natural" or because we are a "good people" or "modern," and they no longer even attribute it to the right thing, and so when somebody says, "Can't you spend your own money better than the Government?" (since they don't know where anything goes in a budget), or "Why are feminists such male-haters?" (since they know nothing about the great struggle against organized bigotry and legislated discrimination that other people fought, and how anything used to be), then these things can sound "convincing," because they actually have no background of knowledge, and have never even thought about it before. They have no internal guide or sensor correcting them with previous understanding. Also, when extremists first start ripping up the regulations, protections, agencies that once covered these concerns, etc., there isn't an immediate collapse of the system--everything still seems to be "fine," for years maybe. Then, when an overwhelming amount of the former protection has been destroyed, then you really get the disastrous affect; too late You can't get people to understand, and stop it early, because there is always this delayed effect to the collapse. Making it worse is when people use this "panic/horror" approach to "alarm" people--it is always annoying, regardless, and does not convince or inform.
This is especially hard to warn against, when the way they use to undercut unions or deregulate an industry, is just to change the technology it uses to such an extent, that it is no longer considered the "same" entity or situation. One example is the way cell phones, their billing, etc., are so completely different from the old land-line telephones--deregulated--yet most DUers who have them, only think about getting a "fun/new toy", as advertised. It never occurs to them how the change will affect all regulations, nor would anyone know how to stop it. Take the example of old broadcast TV/radio FCC regulations from the 1930s and so on, and how they are claimed not to even apply to cable. Who could have guessed that the switch to cable meant that they would seize the opportunity to kill all societal protections--and on what grounds?
The other problem is the 1990s Clinton/"D"LC corporate lobbyist approach. The worst of the outsourcing and loss of manufacturing jobs and whole plants here in the Midwest, occured here, and began the total slide to economic depression where we are now. We had severe recessions under Reagan, but the actual removal of our workplace began under the law-changes of Clinton, Inc. The thing that was so exasperating, and impossible to fight (besides the fact that they had all the power and money, which meant they were going to win, anyway), was the way they used "impossible to answer" slogans and attacks, the beginning of the mind-fuck sin of "framing." "The era of Big Government is over," "lazy/overpaid/corrupt unions," "the old ways don't work anymore," "New Democrat," "let's be more bi-partisan," etc., etc., etc. They ran right over us like a steamroller, flipping media-savvy slogans and snide remarks, the whole time, and this passed for "debate" or "proof." How do you "answer" the "argument"--"Old"? It is the same as the Obama "Past vs. Future" meaningless shit. All I know is, "Old Equals Bad," when you are actually attacking the very people who invented the only poverty programs that have ever worked in this country!
Well, this message was all over the place, but I think the issue is vitally important, and much harder to solve. It will NOT be solved by simpleminded "framing", but by explaining like adults, as if people deserved it.
|