How did the state of Florida get to this point where people will be voting to give public tax money to private religious schools...and not even know it?
From the AU article below:
Jeb Bush "has engineered onto the November ballot two initiatives that would eliminate the state constitution’s strict church-state separation provisions, mandate funding of religion and water down language requiring a quality public school system. For advocates of church-state separation and strong public schools, it’s a political showdown with breath-taking possible consequences."
If the ballot initiatives work here, they will at once be tried in other states. The word "voucher" is never used in the amendments. The public will not be quite sure what they are voting for in those amendments.
Money given in vouchers to private schools or private religious schools is money taken away from funding good public schools.
From Americans United:
Storm Clouds over the Sunshine State.Jeb Bush pushed forward a series of vouchers in 1999 for students at "failing" schools (so-called) to attend private or religious schools with public money.
After years of legal wrangling, the Florida Supreme Court finally struck down the program in January 2006. The 5-2 court majority said vouchers violated a provision of the state constitution requiring a uniform system of free public schools.
Bush, an ardent advocate of “faith-based” solutions to public problems, was livid and vowed to press for a constitutional amendment. But he found more difficulty in the state legislature than expected. In May 2006, the proposed constitutional amendment fell short by one vote in the Republican-controlled Senate, despite a lot of hardball political pressure from the governor and his allies.
Bush then reached for Plan B. He left office in January 2007, but he and his top advisers crafted a back-door maneuver to revise the state constitution and advance vouchers. They decide to stack the state’s Taxation and Budget Reform Commission
Howard Troxler of the St. Pete Times put it succinctly:
...."Amendment 7 would repeal the "Blaine amendment," an old part of the Constitution that prohibits the use of tax dollars in support of religious institutions.
Amendment 9 would reverse a court ruling saying that Florida has an "exclusive" duty to run public schools. That would seem to mean that the state could use vouchers to educate kids, too."
More on Amendments 7 and 9A favorite Florida Blogger
Ybor City Stogie referred to this issue with the label....
The Citrus Taliban. He mentioned that one of the ones leading this effort is Patricia Levesque, Jeb's former Deputy Chief of Staff for Education.
The journal of DUer
and Floridian Seafan tells more about the role of Patricia Levesque. This was covered by AU.
News media soon alerted the public to the Bush plot. Tallahassee Bureau Chief S.V. Date of the Palm Beach Post obtained Levesque’s e-mails under the open records law. They solicited assistance from the wealthy organizations that supported the Bush voucher program as she worked to craft the constitutional amendments.
“I’m still trying to figure out the right language,” Levesque said.
Some Commission members were upset that the Bush agents were diverting attention to his pet project instead of dealing with the state’s serious financial problems.
“I don’t think it’s our job to be getting into fights with the courts,” said Les Miller, a former Democratic senator from Tampa. “The Supreme Court has spoken, and they have said it is unconstitutional.”
The Bush family is still at work in Florida. As Les Miller said, the Supreme Court has spoken and said this is unconstitutional.
However it still made it onto the November ballot, and no one will know it's true purpose unless we get the word out.
Several groups, including the teachers' unions here are joining with the ACLU in a lawsuit.
Florida trying for two tiers of schools...public and unaccountable private religious schools.Florida ACLU has come out now with more on the lawsuit.
The public schools would be as now, accountable to the public who pays taxes to fund them. BUT, as the ACLU points out,it would also open up a new parallel system of "unaccountable private and parochial schools supported by publicly funded vouchers that operate without a state-approved curriculum, without certified teachers, without state standards for instructional materials and without any mandated student achievement."
Our tax money could go to private religious schools, and we would not be able to hold them accountable. The amendments are couched in confusing language that make them sound like a good thing....instead they will diminish the public school in this state. The vehicles they use will be Amendments 7 and 9 which are due to be on the November ballot.
Jeb Bush's Plan B is on the ballot in November.