David Sharrock, Ireland Correspondent
A newspaper journalist won the right yesterday to withhold information from the police about the Real IRA and its involvement in the murder of two British soldiers.
A judge ruled that the life of Suzanne Breen, northern editor of the Sunday Tribune, which is published in Dublin, would be in danger if she were forced to hand over the information. She had been subject to a legal application by Sir Hugh Orde, Chief Constable of Northern Ireland, who is seeking information about the murders of the two soldiers at the Massereene army base in March.
Ms Breen, who is based in Belfast, received the Real IRA’s claim of responsibility for shooting dead Sapper Patrick Azimkar, 21, from London, and Sapper Mark Quinsey, 23, from Birmingham, at the gates of the base in Antrim.
Tom Burgess, the Belfast Recorder, said that the journalist’s right to life outweighed the great public interest in catching the murderers. There was objective evidence that the terrorist group would attack Ms Breen if the information were handed to the authorities, even as a result of a court order, he said.
Terrorism wins the day in Ireland. The journalist's life might not be in specific danger now the verdict has gone her way, but the killers are still free, out there and able to continue their campaign of violence. And the families of those murdered are now further away from getting justice for their loved ones.
I confess to being a little bit torn - I can see where she's coming from re. journalistic integrity, and God knows I wouldn't want her life put in danger, but surely catching murderers who are bound to kill again is equally, if not more important? Maybe I'm missing something here, but I can't understand why she simply couldn't be given police protection if she were to turn over the records. :shrug: