Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

kentuck

(111,101 posts)
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 09:39 AM Jan 2018

The truth about immigration that no one wants to talk about?

Throughout our history, we have had immigrants come to this country, at the behest of the wealthy capitalists that wanted to exploit them for their labor. Whether it be the Scotch-Irish in the coal mines of Appalachia, the Chinese on the railroads, the Polish in the factories, or the Mexicans in our fields, they have come to this country to work and make a better life and each and every time they have been used and abused by the wealthy in this country for their own purposes and greed.

31 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The truth about immigration that no one wants to talk about? (Original Post) kentuck Jan 2018 OP
This country was built on their backs HAB911 Jan 2018 #1
Absolutely true. kentuck Jan 2018 #2
And often on their dead bodies eom Maeve Jan 2018 #3
Hoover Dam holds a few bodies WhiteTara Jan 2018 #8
not sure if you mean melm00se Jan 2018 #27
I love Snopes WhiteTara Jan 2018 #30
+1 dalton99a Jan 2018 #9
The more incredible truth is how subsequent generations have risen above those circumstances oberliner Jan 2018 #4
I agree. kentuck Jan 2018 #6
You'd think this would be something everyone could agree on oberliner Jan 2018 #7
K&R... spanone Jan 2018 #5
True enough treestar Jan 2018 #10
And the reality has changed in our country. kentuck Jan 2018 #11
Like I have said for decades; if they REALLY wanted to fix the illegal immigration in Texas they flying_wahini Jan 2018 #12
I agree 100% Hamlette Jan 2018 #16
I used to work in the construction biz and saw the same thing Luz Jan 2018 #25
How to end the problem in 2 steps Orrex Jan 2018 #29
this turned out a lot worse because of talk radio certainot Jan 2018 #13
And each subsequent generation of immigrants is 'used and abused' by the previous ones... Wounded Bear Jan 2018 #14
the flip side of that truth... tomp Jan 2018 #15
K&R. Truth. See this.... KY_EnviroGuy Jan 2018 #20
good article. who benefits from these policies? tomp Jan 2018 #22
I can believe it Raine Jan 2018 #21
They have also been mistreated by those who are not wealthy. Hamlette Jan 2018 #17
Who doesn't talk about it? qwlauren35 Jan 2018 #18
One of the stories that I always remember re exploitation of immigrants RandomAccess Jan 2018 #19
You left out the largest group malaise Jan 2018 #23
The expoitation class want servants, but they don't want them to vote in their own interests. L. Coyote Jan 2018 #24
The other thing nobody wants to talk about: no_hypocrisy Jan 2018 #26
This! Cracklin Charlie Jan 2018 #28
This is true for some. But some immigrants came here to exploit also. People SweetieD Jan 2018 #31

WhiteTara

(29,718 posts)
30. I love Snopes
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 12:38 PM
Jan 2018

I guess that I should go back and look at old things that were such certainty stories for decades. I hate fake news. Thanks

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
4. The more incredible truth is how subsequent generations have risen above those circumstances
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 10:07 AM
Jan 2018

And how many children and grandchildren of such immigrants (who were treated so poorly) have become so successful.

In theory, that's part of what makes this country great.

kentuck

(111,101 posts)
6. I agree.
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 10:16 AM
Jan 2018

America is unique in that way. It is those circumstances and difficulties that have created the character of our country. It is primarily that struggle that unites us as a people.

treestar

(82,383 posts)
10. True enough
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 11:33 AM
Jan 2018

Though now the capitalists have the whole world and the cheap labor in the underdeveloped countries. And the robots.

flying_wahini

(6,606 posts)
12. Like I have said for decades; if they REALLY wanted to fix the illegal immigration in Texas they
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 12:11 PM
Jan 2018

Would prosecute the people who hire them but it will never happen. The state of Texas
employs thousands who work in construction and state road projects.
All the workers have to do is supply a drivers license and SS # and you can get both at the local flea markets.
I used to keep books for a local millionaire who used illegals in his Big commercial landscaping business and he always looked th other way when they showed up looking for work.

This was decades ago but it still happens.
Most of the state roads (and most construction/building jobs) are built by illegals who work arduously out in the hot sun with very little job security. Pitiful, really. The biggest donors to our Gov. Abbott are in construction.

Hamlette

(15,412 posts)
16. I agree 100%
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 12:36 PM
Jan 2018

We tried to crack down on employers a couple of times but there was a backlash from the business community and we gave up. In one state (I forget which one) that had a big meat packing industry, the state decided to crack down. The slaughterhouses simply moved to the state next door which was ruinous for the state trying to enforce the law. It has to be done at the national level.

Luz

(772 posts)
25. I used to work in the construction biz and saw the same thing
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 10:34 AM
Jan 2018

time after time. I guarantee that if the owners would have been prosecuted, it would have ended.
#1 he could abuse them by withholding pay (backcharge him for blah, blah...) and obviously paying lower wages.
#2 he used them as "sub-labor" so held no responsibility to actuallycheck their status, or provide any benifits, all the while growing their bank account.

Undocumented workers also built the homes we live in.

Orrex

(63,215 posts)
29. How to end the problem in 2 steps
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 10:54 AM
Jan 2018

Hiring an illegal immigrant, first offense: $100,000 fine per hire, plus a written warning.

Hiring an illegal immigrant, second offense: $1M fine per hire, then immediate revocation of citizenship followed by deportation

It's broadly similar to how prostitutes face heavy legal penalties, but their customers often escape with minimal repercussion.

Apply the punishment to the one committing the greater crime, and watch the results.

 

certainot

(9,090 posts)
13. this turned out a lot worse because of talk radio
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 12:15 PM
Jan 2018

the rich like the cheap labor and use it also to keep overall wages down, but the rove white house used talk radio to use immigrants for the voter suppression legislation and dems ignore talk radio so the republicans just kept going.

dems are deluded thinking anything good can be done with republicans on this issue as long as limbaugh and sons are still deciding what's acceptable or not - the minutemen, the wall, the voter id laws - all products of a a few hundred shitholes on the radio working for billionaire think tanks selling voter suppression and voter fraud fraud and lower wages

all because the left keeps ignoring talk radio

Wounded Bear

(58,662 posts)
14. And each subsequent generation of immigrants is 'used and abused' by the previous ones...
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 12:21 PM
Jan 2018

It isn't just racial, although that is how the current situation is playing out. Look at how many current Hispanic residents view our country's moves on immigration. It is not as evenly angry as we might expect.

IAE, we have a chance here to work to improve how we treat people and it shouldn't be wasted.

 

tomp

(9,512 posts)
15. the flip side of that truth...
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 12:32 PM
Jan 2018

...is that greedy capitalists created the conditions in other countries that caused people to want to leave their homes in search of a better life.

 

tomp

(9,512 posts)
22. good article. who benefits from these policies?
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 08:42 AM
Jan 2018

it's not even logical at this point. the only benefit is to the egos of racists, who think they have struck some kind of blow for racial purity.

Hamlette

(15,412 posts)
17. They have also been mistreated by those who are not wealthy.
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 12:38 PM
Jan 2018

People moving up the ladder tend to kick those on the lower rungs.

 

RandomAccess

(5,210 posts)
19. One of the stories that I always remember re exploitation of immigrants
Sat Jan 13, 2018, 06:49 PM
Jan 2018

comes from my beloved Portland, Oregon.

When we lived there in the early 80s, we visited Pittock Mansion, on a bluff overlooking Portland and the Willamette River. Beautiful.

And the mansion is gorgeous too. It has a lot of beautiful woodwork, which we were told was painted and sanded a number of times in the process of building the place.

Sanded? Not what you might think: it was done by Chinese workers isomg pumice with their bare hands.

Mind boggling.

malaise

(269,044 posts)
23. You left out the largest group
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 08:46 AM
Jan 2018

slaves - from Africa stolen from their homelands and treated worse than animals.

L. Coyote

(51,129 posts)
24. The expoitation class want servants, but they don't want them to vote in their own interests.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 08:55 AM
Jan 2018

If everyone gets a voter, their interests do not dominate, and they have to pay the help more. Things like minimum wages will be fair and people will have health care and retirement security. That's the truth that is being ignored, political power versus democracy.

Australia: $13.5
France: $11
Ireland: $10.4
UK: $10.1
Netherlands: $10.1
Germany: $9.9

no_hypocrisy

(46,119 posts)
26. The other thing nobody wants to talk about:
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 10:37 AM
Jan 2018

Immigrants become citizen and register as Democrats and vote democratic.

That's a prevailing fear among Republicans.

Cracklin Charlie

(12,904 posts)
28. This!
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 10:46 AM
Jan 2018

Could be expanded into a Facebook screed, a book, a movie, a mini series, or a Ken Freaking Burns documentary!

Please, folks...Spread. This. Far. And. Wide!

March On, Democrats!

SweetieD

(1,660 posts)
31. This is true for some. But some immigrants came here to exploit also. People
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 01:21 PM
Jan 2018

who had no social status could come here and have a built in system where they could exploit slave labor or benefit from the third class situation of black people in the US.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The truth about immigrati...