General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNo Guns In Church – Georgia Preacher Loses Case To Allow Weapons In House Of Worship
This is how debased and twisted our gun culture has become. The New Testament, the book that ostensibly drives Christianity, is chock full of peace, love and turning the other cheek. This, however has not stopped conservatives from the push to carry guns into every corner of creation:
Tabernacle pastor Jonathan Wilkins
claimed that the gun ban violates Georgia residents First Amendment right to the free exercise of religion
This would be bad enough from just your average citizen, but to have an actual preacher demand the right to be armed in a house of worship? There is a deep sickness in our country when the religious (or at least those who pretend to be) feel the need to bring violence where none is permitted. It raises the specter of fire-breathing bigots waving their gun from the pulpit, egging their followers on to protect themselves from the hordes of radical socialists and homosexuals.
For now, at least, Georgia has maintained a semblance of sanity. Via Courthousenews:
A Baptist preacher and one of his congregants cannot fight a Georgia law that blocked them from bringing their guns to church, the 11th Circuit ruled.
Senate Bill 308, which Georgia passed in June 2010, modified a law that at the time prohibited gun owners from bringing their weapons to a public gathering. The amendment specifies eight unauthorized locations to bring firearms, including courthouses, jails or prisons, most bars, mental health facilities, and churches or other places of worship.
The court ruled that, despite Wilkins disturbing interpretation of the Bible in which a gun is part of Christianity, banning guns from a church does not, in any way, infringe on anyones religious freedom. Further they ruled that the Second Amendment claims seek to destroy one cornerstone of liberty the right to enjoy ones private property in order to expand another the right to bear arms.
http://www.addictinginfo.org/2012/07/26/no-guns-in-church-georgia-preacher-loses-case-to-allow-weapons-in-house-of-worship/
Turbineguy
(37,365 posts)But then again, Preacher, guns are not allowed in mental health facilities, so why should they be allowed in your church?
gregoire
(192 posts)And the people that go to churches are crazy? That's what it sounds like, and I think nearly all of us agree.
Turbineguy
(37,365 posts)not all.
Response to DainBramaged (Original post)
Post removed
TheCowsCameHome
(40,168 posts)This is just so unfair
Go Vols
(5,902 posts)freshwest
(53,661 posts)RC
(25,592 posts)Omnipotent? Apparently not so much when you need killing machines in a church to protect yourself.
You'd think that divine intervention would be a good way to prove their religion was true.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)There is plenty in the scriptures on fearing nothing but God. That guy is full of fear because he has no faith. The power of love and the peace of Christ is supposed to keep him safe. If he was 'right with God,' he'd be ready to 'be with the Lord.' I'm not into that any more but know what it was about.
Glad he didn't get his way in that case, but none other than Bobby Jindal (R-Romney Lapdog) called for guns to be allowed in the churches in Louisiana. No leadership solutions to deal with people who commit crimes other than kill. None of this crap they preach passes the smell test spiritually.
LiberalFighter
(51,084 posts)Don't you think that God wants to strike down anyone it wants?
freshwest
(53,661 posts)I found it bogus and self-serving. I's more effective, I've found, to go at them with what they feel is sacred. This is the common ground in which one can meet them, and it's not disrespectful.
There are reasons people get into some of the more rigid groups, generally need an authority figure to feel safe and that they belong and they're very touchy about being criticized. It's mixed in with 'Mommy and Daddy said so, and they wouldn't lie and they loved me, so you're attacking me personally.'
That is what we confront when we diss them. Just puts that wall right up, can't get around it. But you can get to common ground and make a few dents in that to work with them on what you really need done. It's not a game of winning and losing, it's just getting things done.
They'll see the 'God strikes down anything it wants' as the polytheistic belief of the ancient Greeks, Romans, etc.in which their gods mimicked human behaviors and not trustworthy. So they won't listen. That is the Madalyn Murray O'Hair gambit. and they have been taught to guard against it.
The desert religions insist on permanence and obedience. The typical religionists and or authoritarian wants something they can count on. Like Mommy and Daddy. They keep themselves in a childish state of dependence and want to be rescued.
Anyway, those are just some observations, not professional ones. This is not that interesting to me anymore as I have done my time arguing with the folks. Someone who knows them best and loves them can help them, not me, I'm out of it.
Tom Ripley
(4,945 posts)or a sadistic braggart in the case of poor Job
freshwest
(53,661 posts)Greek mythology with a whimsical deity who just screwed around with humans in order to score points with other gods. The story of Job, and Abraham having enough 'faith' to kill his own son is that sort of sadistic theme that you're talking about. It's torturous logic. I just said what works for me.
But I'm not going to argue for or against, and will probably delete my comments here. They were quickly expressed and dealt only with what I envision this pastor to be about. I don't do God, Guns, Gays and Gynecology, even with Democrats or especially with RW nuts, it's too primal to discuss with them.
Any opinion or thought is argued as any word is a trigger. I feel at times I am struggling to talk to a child, trying to be as diplomatic as possible to not be misconstrued. I am NOT referring to anyone here, or you. But I can feel the feelers put out trying to see what camp I am in and really, I am neutral except that I believe in the equality of all, which also means I have to live with the beliefs of others I find repugnant.
I am not in any of these camps and refuse to corralled. So that may not be what you wanted, but I remember the last time I opened my mouth like this the replies were very aggravating, trying to get me to commit to atheism or religion and work with the arguments. I am no longer a Christian, and do not wish to go after them, either. My ideas on them match more of the Founding Fathers, there is a lot more in life than that.
So I apologize, I am not going to go on an anti-Christian rant nor will I defend religion. Some people feel one must choose sides in these matters. I refuse. Thanks for your question and time, at least you didn't call me a liar or say what I said was BS when after all, it was just an opinion, an observation.
Tom Ripley
(4,945 posts)You are neither a liar or a bs artist.
Your opinions and observations are well presented.
I honestly mean that.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)I just don't like to come back to My Posts and have to deal with someone's anger over something that is merely an observation, as if I am trying to convince them or diss them or sell them something.
So I'll leave it until that first post comes if it does, and I hope that helps anyone wants to work these things out with the different people a tool. People have so many patterns in their lives that help them make it through the world.
And if we think we are all equal, we have to behave that way.
Your comment is much appreciated.
petronius
(26,603 posts)It's an interesting argument, and I hope the USSC weighs in, but as I said in that thread I'm uncomfortable with a law that attempts to give a special privilege to houses of worship, based on their religious character. (Or conversely, a law that discriminates against religious organizations based on that character - it depends on how you look at it...)
jmowreader
(50,562 posts)Does he want his parishioners armed in case the snakes get out?
JI7
(89,264 posts)fascisthunter
(29,381 posts)remember
ileus
(15,396 posts)gkhouston
(21,642 posts)Initech
(100,102 posts)Tom Ripley
(4,945 posts)LiberalFighter
(51,084 posts)Tom Ripley
(4,945 posts)Zoeisright
(8,339 posts)A GUN is part of CHRISTIANITY??
That is the fucking stupidest thing I have ever; EVER read.
Response to DainBramaged (Original post)
Post removed