Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

TheDebbieDee

(11,119 posts)
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:12 AM Feb 2018

DAVID HOGG, Parkland survivor tells 2nd Amendment supporters...

Last edited Sat Feb 24, 2018, 06:55 PM - Edit history (1)

Give up NOW because we are going to OUTLIVE you!

He is appearing on AM Joy this morning...

Go David!

Wow! This whippersnapper's got GUMPTION!

Thanks Eleny for providing a link to the video:

85 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
DAVID HOGG, Parkland survivor tells 2nd Amendment supporters... (Original Post) TheDebbieDee Feb 2018 OP
He is so articulate and informed Neurotica Feb 2018 #1
We, the passive, jaded and defeated, look to youth to save us. Eyeball_Kid Feb 2018 #12
Yes its time to move aside for a younger, more hopeful and sensible generation. Pepsidog Feb 2018 #23
Perhaps it's location... lambchopp59 Feb 2018 #52
Very well said. I agree Pepsidog Feb 2018 #57
Gen Xers love him here loyalsister Feb 2018 #65
I think "our generation" protests accomplished a lot. Some successes maybe didn't FailureToCommunicate Feb 2018 #25
We did accomplish a lot...civil rights, social programs, anti-war...half of the generation. brush Feb 2018 #40
Agreed. Let's do what we can! FailureToCommunicate Feb 2018 #66
When we were young the existential threat to us was the draft; The Velveteen Ocelot Feb 2018 #32
Yes, way mature beyond his years onetexan Feb 2018 #70
Watching... he is an impressive young man. demmiblue Feb 2018 #2
Ha - I imagine they'll give up when they're dead. Maybe that's all that matters. jmg257 Feb 2018 #3
He's fantastic greymattermom Feb 2018 #4
The best part of his argument is the fact that he was on the wrong end of an AR15 hydrolastic Feb 2018 #22
Ryan, you are doing a wonderful job. Just breathe. demmiblue Feb 2018 #5
(...and stay off of small planes.........) lastlib Feb 2018 #48
Marjory Stoneman Douglas would be proud that her name is on this school and the students from there Pachamama Feb 2018 #6
I agree. I wonder how much they learn about her. TNNurse Feb 2018 #15
We could learn so much from this articulate young man. democrank Feb 2018 #7
Sounds like a good answer to Charlton Heston's gun rant mucifer Feb 2018 #8
He has 210K followers on Twitter greymattermom Feb 2018 #9
Most kids today lead fearless lives. yallerdawg Feb 2018 #10
The NRA crowd is afraid of him. That is why they are trying to discredit him. lkinwi Feb 2018 #11
He should change that to: "We will live long enough to take the guns Aristus Feb 2018 #13
We need to have their backs pandr32 Feb 2018 #14
I know I'm getting old but I'm so glad to see young people like this coming along blueinredohio Feb 2018 #16
I just hope that nothing happens to him vercetti2021 Feb 2018 #17
Great kid! smirkymonkey Feb 2018 #18
Is it just me? SCVDem Feb 2018 #19
Hope for sure. Freedomofspeech Feb 2018 #20
Did you hear the two young men directly take on FedEx DeminPennswoods Feb 2018 #21
I did not hear it but have read that @FexEx is resisting riversedge Feb 2018 #28
I called ebay and told them they need to drop them as a shipping option UpInArms Feb 2018 #58
+1 uponit7771 Feb 2018 #30
He's runs the TV media section at SD malaise Feb 2018 #24
The NRA Just Became The Enemy of a Generation of Younger Americans riversedge Feb 2018 #26
THIS !!!! I pray it continues, the NRA has been poison to US culture and they take Russian ... uponit7771 Feb 2018 #31
The NRA reminds me of the cigarette lobby ... who basically said that ... SWBTATTReg Feb 2018 #35
And now is the time. past time I know but the mojo has landed! riversedge Feb 2018 #38
Thanks rivers! Cha Feb 2018 #53
What I would say to media - get some constitutional scholars on to discuss 2nd amendment, stop it Kashkakat v.2.0 Feb 2018 #27
Well its true... Historic NY Feb 2018 #29
Hes painted a target on his back. Aviation Pro Feb 2018 #33
Yes, I hope he wears a bullet-proof vest MountCleaners Feb 2018 #56
They ALL have gumption. The NRA is poking at the wrong hornets' nest. George II Feb 2018 #34
More Universities and Colleges need to hold NoMoreRepugs Feb 2018 #36
Wow wryter2000 Feb 2018 #37
Is he really going after the 2nd Amendment or was that your shorthand? aikoaiko Feb 2018 #39
He's going after 2nd Amendment SUPPORTERS TheDebbieDee Feb 2018 #43
I'll have to catch the video. aikoaiko Feb 2018 #44
This message was self-deleted by its author Kashkakat v.2.0 Feb 2018 #46
Message auto-removed Name removed Feb 2018 #41
That was one heck of an interview and it's already on YouTube eleny Feb 2018 #42
I'm now officially calling him Boss Hogg. ;-) CaptainTruth Feb 2018 #45
False dichotomy- you can be a 2nd amendment suppporter and still support stringent controls - there Kashkakat v.2.0 Feb 2018 #47
it needs to be updated so ASSHOLES can understand Skittles Feb 2018 #49
Well, yeah, theres that - in the meantime nra does not get any cred as Kashkakat v.2.0 Feb 2018 #50
YES! 2left4u Feb 2018 #61
What an amazing young man NastyRiffraff Feb 2018 #51
I am so impressed by this kid! dhol82 Feb 2018 #54
He said that about people who are claiming the students are being paid by Soros. aikoaiko Feb 2018 #55
You fd up...Give the new generation a chance. oxbow Feb 2018 #59
can we replace wolfie w/him NOW?!? pansypoo53219 Feb 2018 #60
"I wonder why these kids are heard when BLM has been saying essentially the same thing" summer_in_TX Feb 2018 #62
smart young man krakfiend Feb 2018 #63
Let's help them. Lifelong Protester Feb 2018 #64
Does everyone on this thread fully endorse his position? Straw Man Feb 2018 #67
No. They should be banned. They are battlefield weapons. n/t rainin Feb 2018 #71
So you think his position is too weak? Straw Man Feb 2018 #72
You are correct that my position goes beyond David's. n/t rainin Feb 2018 #73
Based on his stated position ... Straw Man Feb 2018 #74
Absolutely! n/t rainin Feb 2018 #75
So AR-15s are OK except for the mentally ill? Straw Man Feb 2018 #76
I'm not running for office, so I answered your question as asked. rainin Feb 2018 #78
No, you didn't. Straw Man Feb 2018 #79
I think I did, but I'll try one more time. rainin Feb 2018 #80
So ... Straw Man Feb 2018 #81
Incremental steps as I explained. The tide is turning. Change is coming. n/t rainin Feb 2018 #82
So when gun control advocates pooh-pooh the "slippery slope" ... Straw Man Feb 2018 #83
Once you argue "slippery slope", you've lost the argument. That's why it's called a logical fallacy. rainin Feb 2018 #84
Nope -- that's a misconception. Straw Man Feb 2018 #85
You can follow him on Twitter.. yuiyoshida Feb 2018 #68
I looked up "impressive" in the dictionary. gristy Feb 2018 #69
Excellent.....I hope he's offered a job with MSNBC right out of college...n/t Upthevibe Feb 2018 #77

Eyeball_Kid

(7,433 posts)
12. We, the passive, jaded and defeated, look to youth to save us.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:36 AM
Feb 2018

We want the young kids to do what we tried, and couldn't do. We stand by in amazement and we're reminded of our own idealistic, passionate youth, when we threw down the gauntlet and proclaimed that EVERYONE OVER 30 COULD NOT BE TRUSTED. Now, those of our older generation who demanded an end to the Vietnam War and an end to international meddling for corporate gain (the AID controversies of the late 60s and early 70s), now find that our own contemporaries are running corporate board rooms and Wall Street offices, repeating the same oligarchic themes as were prevalent fifty years ago and determining that the only good policy is one that's profitable for some billionaire or a transnational corporation. The cycle repeats itself as the corporate roles that express greed, violence, and cruelty are filled by people who once were our fellow students in high school and college many decades ago.

We of the older generations must not sit by in amazement at what high school students have accomplished so far in their short burst of activism. We need to stand by their side, shoulder to shoulder, and be as active as they are. We need to support one another and sustain the drive for a safe society, free of the fear of gun violence, for all of us, regardless of color, religious belief, or economic status.

Pepsidog

(6,254 posts)
23. Yes its time to move aside for a younger, more hopeful and sensible generation.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:22 PM
Feb 2018

I’m 55 yo. My generation has lost its way. The greatest generation was followed by the F’ed up looney generation of science deniers and religious zealots who take comfort in their bibles and guns waiting for the government to break down their doors and take their precious guns away. I blame Fox, Murdoch, Hannity and Limbaugh. They are all immoral purveyors of hate and misinformation who have caused a what someone abtly called “the new cold civil war”. Murdoch, Ailes, Fox are the real enemies of the state.

lambchopp59

(2,809 posts)
52. Perhaps it's location...
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 06:19 PM
Feb 2018

But generation X, Y and M here in greater bay area California nearly puke at the next headline that contains the word "Trump". We were educated by the intellectuals of the 60's revolution- tail end of the boomers.
And there's another aspect: this one is speaking far louder than the hateful words of RW media, at last:
Migrant workers are here on contract, by the thousands. They miss their families. Some won't shut off Fox, spout nonsense at their work and get their contracts cut and sent home to sit on their couches and let
Fox, Limbaugh and Hannity make them angrier. Solves nothing. Stokes fear. Sells guns.
Yet a few of them I've witnessed the change. They're here. They hear. Sometimes they choose to listen. They come to realize going home where their "patriotic anti-socialist" bastard leaders have cut, cut, cut everything until even the WalMart they first lost their jobs to... is now closed.
One must be sly at this, to get them to put on the "THEY LIVE" sunglasses and see Hannity as he really is. There is seldom conversation at our work lunch table that doesn't include how utterly nonsensical, nut job crazy our political leadership is now. Sheepishly watching Fox in their company paid apartment, sometimes, it starts to soak in. Some have learned some new terms to them: corporatocracy, military industrial complex, the "oily-garchy", better survivability of the non-profit incentive. Some have even moved their families here. Some start to realize there is such a thing as "FACTS", and it influences their lives.
I realize there is a silent minority in the "red zones". I was there 3 years ago. They know who not to disturb when convinced by the illusion of denial.
The RWNJ's are trying so hard to stoke the crazy at this point, hoping one of us on "the left" gets driven to irrational acts, confirming their bias and martyrdom. Yes it worries me. Yes it embarrasses the hell out of our international image.
But Dog, now I've heard the conversion numerous times: "I made a terrible mistake. I can't get behind this crap." Keep the faith in reality. GOTV. The science based message has not gotten lost, just obscured, obfuscated, rehashed, branded "anti-patriotic" and still is the solution. I'm watching die-hard "christians" working aside Muslims and realizing they're not the monsters their mesmerizers had convinced them of.
A few of them finally figured out that buying the new SMART cars and hybrids they traded their monster truck in for was a sharp move.
Rachel says it almost daily, and we must maintain the mantra: "This is not normal".

loyalsister

(13,390 posts)
65. Gen Xers love him here
Sun Feb 25, 2018, 12:25 AM
Feb 2018

In MO Xers make up the majority of the RW. The governor is in his 40s and the GOP delegation in the state GA is dominated by them. The younger crowd seems to lean more toward Dems.

FailureToCommunicate

(14,018 posts)
25. I think "our generation" protests accomplished a lot. Some successes maybe didn't
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:47 PM
Feb 2018

last or were co-opted later...

brush

(53,815 posts)
40. We did accomplish a lot...civil rights, social programs, anti-war...half of the generation.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 02:15 PM
Feb 2018

There was always a dichotomy—activists and young repugs. It still exists.

Let's do what we can to help these high schoolers.

Activism seems to have missed college students.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,799 posts)
32. When we were young the existential threat to us was the draft;
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 01:03 PM
Feb 2018

for these kids it's school shootings. When something is personal like that people tend to become passionate; it's just human nature. I hope they can maintain that passion and that we old, passive, jaded and defeated folks will remember what it was like back in the '60s, and get fired up again.

onetexan

(13,054 posts)
70. Yes, way mature beyond his years
Sun Feb 25, 2018, 04:47 AM
Feb 2018
You man's got a bright future ahead of him in the Democratic party.

demmiblue

(36,875 posts)
2. Watching... he is an impressive young man.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:17 AM
Feb 2018

The student survivors from Marjory Stoneman Douglas have really given me a sense of hope for our country.

hydrolastic

(488 posts)
22. The best part of his argument is the fact that he was on the wrong end of an AR15
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:18 PM
Feb 2018

He is pissed and wont stop till he and his friends see a ban on assault weapons. The twisted "arm everybody" argument doesn't fly with them. I like how they immediately planed a march, I will be there and i hope it approaches the numbers the woman's marches have drawn. One issue though and as a white liberal male i may not have a valid opinion on. I wonder why these kids are heard when BLM has been saying essentially the same thing. Or a part of the same thing. If that makes sense. Seems a combination could work.

lastlib

(23,263 posts)
48. (...and stay off of small planes.........)
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 03:27 PM
Feb 2018

I have little doubt that the hoplosexuals and gun-profiteers would resort to putting a hit on someone who stood in the way of their agenda.

democrank

(11,098 posts)
7. We could learn so much from this articulate young man.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:27 AM
Feb 2018

His responses are straightforward and methodically formulated. I admire his courage and determination.

greymattermom

(5,754 posts)
9. He has 210K followers on Twitter
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:28 AM
Feb 2018

already. These students will reach people by using social media and speaking on television. He's suggesting that college students avoid Florida for spring break. What if that catches on? Florida depends on tourists.

lkinwi

(1,477 posts)
11. The NRA crowd is afraid of him. That is why they are trying to discredit him.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:36 AM
Feb 2018

And he isn’t havin’ it.

Aristus

(66,434 posts)
13. He should change that to: "We will live long enough to take the guns
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:38 AM
Feb 2018

from your cold, dead hands!"

I love these kids. They are America.

blueinredohio

(6,797 posts)
16. I know I'm getting old but I'm so glad to see young people like this coming along
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:49 AM
Feb 2018

gives me hope for the future

vercetti2021

(10,156 posts)
17. I just hope that nothing happens to him
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:59 AM
Feb 2018

So many crazies out they'll just do anything to drive their screwed up conspiracy agenda

 

SCVDem

(5,103 posts)
19. Is it just me?
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:06 PM
Feb 2018

Are we seeing the origin story of the next Bobby Kennedy?

Determined and tenacious and more intelligent than most of his opponents.

We also saw that in a young Senator from Illinois.

Hope!

DeminPennswoods

(15,289 posts)
21. Did you hear the two young men directly take on FedEx
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:14 PM
Feb 2018

and Fred Smith? It was after Reid asked them about the number of businesses that are dropping their affiliation with the NRA. Hogg said that FedEx still hadn't dropped it's NRA affiliation and the Fred Smith, the founder, was one of the biggest supporters of and donors to the NRA. They are ready, willing and able to put consumer pressure on FedEx.

UpInArms

(51,284 posts)
58. I called ebay and told them they need to drop them as a shipping option
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 08:47 PM
Feb 2018

That I would cancel my ebay account ... I will not support a company that helps fund a terrorist organization

Got at least one guy’s attention ...

Give it a go

Let’s get them off the streets and out of our driveway

riversedge

(70,270 posts)
26. The NRA Just Became The Enemy of a Generation of Younger Americans
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:49 PM
Feb 2018

I posted this yesterday. Fits well.


https://www.democraticunderground.com/100210281427



The NRA Just Became The Enemy of a Generation of Younger Americans



I did not think there were any silver linings in this tragedy --but if the younger generation will help in the demise of the bloody NRA, then something good may come of this horrible time.



The NRA Just Became The Enemy of a Generation of Younger Americans


https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2018/2/23/1744133/-The-NRA-Just-Became-The-Enemy-of-a-Generation-of-Younger-Americans
Friday Feb 23, 2018 · 6:45 AM CST

The big loser in CNN’s Wednesday night Town Hall to address the horrific shooting last week in Parkland, Florida was the NRA — by far. The NRA not only potentially lost a generation of young people as members but from the sound of the audience at the Town Hall last night, it’s fair to say that many view the NRA as the enemy. And they should.

The NRA and the politicians they’ve bankrolled value easy access to guns over their lives. And the audience Wednesday night filled with younger people — many of whom just last week were dodging bullets from an AR-15, a weapon the NRA fought to legalize after it was banned from 1994 to 2004 as part of the federal assault weapons ban — got that.

These high school students may be teenagers, but they know the deal. They fully understand the power of the NRA and how politicians are beholden to campaign donations. And that led us to one of the most compelling moments I’ve ever seen on this issue.

.................................
And last night Kasky stood up again for others in his generation who truly fear that a gunman will descend upon their school with weapon of war and slaughter them. He had a chance to ask Florida Senator Marco Rubio a question, a man who boasts an “A-plus” rating from the NRA and who has received over $3 million in donations from the organization............................


?1519389832

NRA's Dana Loesch battles AR-15 shooting survivor Emma Gonzalez at CNN Town Hall

uponit7771

(90,348 posts)
31. THIS !!!! I pray it continues, the NRA has been poison to US culture and they take Russian ...
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:59 PM
Feb 2018

... money

SWBTATTReg

(22,156 posts)
35. The NRA reminds me of the cigarette lobby ... who basically said that ...
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 01:27 PM
Feb 2018

cigarette smoking was good for you. Enough voices were finally raised to finally overwhelm the industry giants who had been desperately defending their turf in the sale of cigarette products.

The NRA is now facing their moment, as they so well should. Being so defensive in the face of overwhelming evidence that there are too many guns out there, and too many people that should not have access to guns, period.

The NRA hasn't done 1 thing to address this ongoing, decades-long issue. Not 1 thing, other than threaten our lawmakers and those citizens that spoke out against guns.

Kashkakat v.2.0

(1,752 posts)
27. What I would say to media - get some constitutional scholars on to discuss 2nd amendment, stop it
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:50 PM
Feb 2018

with giving NRA reps any credibility at all. They are not constitutional scholars. THEY ARE GUN MANUFACTURING LOBBY - period, end of story.

Historic NY

(37,452 posts)
29. Well its true...
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 12:51 PM
Feb 2018

one Right Winger was spouting off about these kids, his picture showed him to be about 74. My reply was your going to beat them to the cemetery if some nut doesn't kill them.

MountCleaners

(1,148 posts)
56. Yes, I hope he wears a bullet-proof vest
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 07:41 PM
Feb 2018

As well as the other young activists. Seriously - I am worried for their safety, and the school is a target, too.

NoMoreRepugs

(9,451 posts)
36. More Universities and Colleges need to hold
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 01:38 PM
Feb 2018

High school kids harmless if their protesting the NRA or whatever other public good activity gets them expelled for a bit or arrested... zero black marks against their admission to the school of their choice.

aikoaiko

(34,183 posts)
39. Is he really going after the 2nd Amendment or was that your shorthand?
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 02:07 PM
Feb 2018

Going after the 2nd Amendment is going to backfire.

Response to TheDebbieDee (Reply #43)

Response to TheDebbieDee (Original post)

Kashkakat v.2.0

(1,752 posts)
47. False dichotomy- you can be a 2nd amendment suppporter and still support stringent controls - there
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 03:11 PM
Feb 2018

are different interpretations of the 2nd amendment besides what NRA wants us to thinks it means.

Important to challenge the notion that NRA "owns" the second amendment. They are a gun manufacturing lobby, and that's about it.

Kashkakat v.2.0

(1,752 posts)
50. Well, yeah, theres that - in the meantime nra does not get any cred as
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 03:42 PM
Feb 2018

any kind of authority on the subject.

 

2left4u

(186 posts)
61. YES!
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 09:47 PM
Feb 2018

I am a 100% supporter of our 2nd Amendment rights and completely agree with you.

I do not believe the authors intended high fire rate military type weapons to be covered under it.

The NRA is the propaganda arm of the gun manufactures and the military industrial complex.
The NRA could give a fuck less about America or the 2nd Amendment.

They're not scared of the kid in the least bit either
Their using him and all this to gin up scare tactics that sell more weapons, suck more contributions out of thier low IQ base and spread hate.

The NRA are a bunch of ghouls.

NastyRiffraff

(12,448 posts)
51. What an amazing young man
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 05:36 PM
Feb 2018

He is going to run the country in some capacity, along with Emma, Cameron, and all the rest, some whose names we don't know.

dhol82

(9,353 posts)
54. I am so impressed by this kid!
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 06:54 PM
Feb 2018

He is smart, articulate and passionate.
Hope he has a long career in journalism.

aikoaiko

(34,183 posts)
55. He said that about people who are claiming the students are being paid by Soros.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 07:26 PM
Feb 2018


Not 2nd Amendment supporters in general.

oxbow

(2,034 posts)
59. You fd up...Give the new generation a chance.
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 09:16 PM
Feb 2018

If it’s not their world already, it will be soon. They never agreed to live in this insanity. They deserve to live in a world they feel safe in.

summer_in_TX

(2,741 posts)
62. "I wonder why these kids are heard when BLM has been saying essentially the same thing"
Sat Feb 24, 2018, 11:35 PM
Feb 2018

I'm troubled that BLM didn’t get lots of support. However, other school shootings, the Sutherland Springs one and the Las Vegas shootings didn't trigger this effect either.

I think there are factors that made this take off in a way that BLM couldn't. The sheer number of kids who experienced the attack at once, because of the fire alarm getting them out of their classrooms and then it being a semi-automatic weapon.This group of students being minors but at the young adult stage of life in their ability to speak and organize. The clear case for them being innocent. The video and texts during the attack were one critical factor, because seeing it made it viscerally connect as we could imagine it being our kids, teachers, friends, us.

Somehow they knew that if they could just channel their fear and righteous anger to bring something good out of all the horror and tragedy, that it would help them and all the others dealing with shock, grief, and PTSD or other symptoms of trauma.

The kids’ response has been exceptional. Stoneman Douglas clearly has a large number of kids who have speech and especially debate experience, have had to frame issues for maximum acceptance. They've done a lot to keep the message focused on saving other kids' lives, which evokes a protective response in everyone who has been a mom, dad, or grandparent. They've mostly refrained from attacking those in a position of power like Trump.

It's a delight to watch the entrenched evil power of the NRA start to cave in the face of such a clear emotionally and morally righteous argument. It has caught the hearts and imagination of most of the country, galvanizing a fresh look at a previously intractable situation.

Straw Man

(6,625 posts)
67. Does everyone on this thread fully endorse his position?
Sun Feb 25, 2018, 02:02 AM
Feb 2018

He said you shouldn't be able to own an AR-15 if you're mentally ill. I'm not mentally ill. Should I be able to own one?

Straw Man

(6,625 posts)
72. So you think his position is too weak?
Sun Feb 25, 2018, 01:28 PM
Feb 2018

To a large extent, his statement that I quoted above aligns with what the NRA says.

rainin

(3,011 posts)
78. I'm not running for office, so I answered your question as asked.
Mon Feb 26, 2018, 12:19 PM
Feb 2018

I would vote for someone like him who has his views. I call that incremental steps in the right direction.

Straw Man

(6,625 posts)
79. No, you didn't.
Mon Feb 26, 2018, 12:27 PM
Feb 2018

I said "based on his stated position," and you're avoiding that part of the question.

rainin

(3,011 posts)
80. I think I did, but I'll try one more time.
Mon Feb 26, 2018, 12:45 PM
Feb 2018

I will consider favorably any candidate who proposes taking weapons away from the mentally ill. However, I am FOR making the sale of or the ownership of weapons of war illegal for civilians. I am ambivalent about the ownership of these weapons for retired military. In the case of retired military, I would support highly regulated ammunition and licenses that must be continually renewed.

David Hogg's position is far closer to mine than Marco Rubio's, so I would support David's position, even if it doesn't match mine exactly.

Straw Man

(6,625 posts)
81. So ...
Mon Feb 26, 2018, 01:03 PM
Feb 2018
I will consider favorably any candidate who proposes taking weapons away from the mentally ill. However, I am FOR making the sale of or the ownership of weapons of war illegal for civilians.

... if a candidate comes out in favor of the former but not the latter, you will still support him? That's what he did. If we can assume that he was being sincere, and not merely politically strategic, his position is much softer on this issue than yours. Why, then, would you support him?

Straw Man

(6,625 posts)
83. So when gun control advocates pooh-pooh the "slippery slope" ...
Mon Feb 26, 2018, 01:18 PM
Feb 2018

... and say that "Nobody wants to take your guns," are they lying?

rainin

(3,011 posts)
84. Once you argue "slippery slope", you've lost the argument. That's why it's called a logical fallacy.
Mon Feb 26, 2018, 01:24 PM
Feb 2018

Straw Man

(6,625 posts)
85. Nope -- that's a misconception.
Mon Feb 26, 2018, 02:19 PM
Feb 2018

"Slippery slope" is a fallacy only when it is posited without evidence. You provided the evidence yourself, with the admission that these are "incremental steps." Your ultimate trajectory is toward more and more gun control. Can you deny that?

Does this writer's characterization of Trumpist bigotry as a "slippery slope" invalidate his argument? I hope your answer is "no."

https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2015/12/10/the_slippery_slope_of_trumpism_128988.html

gristy

(10,667 posts)
69. I looked up "impressive" in the dictionary.
Sun Feb 25, 2018, 04:13 AM
Feb 2018

There was a picture of David Hogg. O.M.G. Just amazing. No wonder the right wing nut jobs just can't believe this is a real student. How did this happen?! they say... How did he make it through our no child left behind juggernaut?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»DAVID HOGG, Parkland surv...