General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsComments on Parkland shooting by Al Franken
(From Facebook)
Last week, a young man used an AR-15 semiautomatic assault rifle to murder fourteen students and three members of the staff at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida. As a father of two and a grandfather of three, I cannot imagine the heartache and the pain endured by the families who lost loved ones that day.
In the wake of this tragedy, President Trump announced that he would work to help secure our schools, and tackle the difficult issue of mental health. Regrettably, the president did not immediately acknowledge the American gun violence epidemic or commit to confronting just why we tolerate the proliferation of military-grade guns. He was, however, right to mention the issue of mental health but I worry that here as well, his rhetoric does not match his actions.
As a senator, I spent a lot of my time and effort on mental health issues. There is no question that the shooter in Parkland is, like the perpetrators of all these mass killings, deeply troubled; and in this particular case, the shooter appears to have a history of mental illness. But we need to be very careful about stigmatizing mental illness in a way that is counterproductive and may ultimately prevent Americans from accessing the treatment they need.
The truth is the vast majority of people suffering from mental illness are non-violent, and a very small portion of violence in America can be attributed to individuals who suffer from mental illness. In fact, people with mental illness are the victims of violence more often than those without mental illness. What we need more than anything in this country is to recognize that virtually every family in America is touched by a behavioral health issue mental illness or addiction and that we need to provide treatment in a smart, compassionate way to relieve suffering, save families and lives, and give us a more productive workforce.
Unfortunately, all too often, the urgency to address mental illness only appears in the fallout of a tragedy. After Sandy Hook, I heard some of my colleagues who had never seemed particularly interested in mental health say what were hearing a lot of today. Its not just guns. Its mental health. In some cases, it felt like they were checking off a box saying the words mental and health and in the right order and not paying much attention to the subject until the next mass shooting carried out with an assault weapon.
Like almost all of my Democratic colleagues, I supported a ban on assault weapons in 2013. As the students who survived the shooting at Parkland have said so powerfully, there is no reason to have a military-style weapon designed to kill human beings on our streets and in our schools. And despite a history of behavior and warning signs signs that were repeatedly reported by his classmates the nineteen-year-old shooter was permitted to legally purchase a weapon of war.
But the shooting WAS also about mental illness. And if we are to be serious about the subject, we need to acknowledge certain realities and develop a thoughtful and comprehensive approach to addressing them.
In the Senate I pushed for more mental health in schools and have seen the lives of kids and their families turned around by effective treatment. I have been to schools in Minnesota where mental health issues have been so successfully destigmatized that kids high-five their therapist in the school hallway. And the work of mental health professionals in schools also takes some of the burden off teachers to address behavioral issues in the classroom so they can focus on teaching.
The system that Ive seen work effectively in schools involves every adult teachers, the school bus drivers, the principal, the lunch ladies who are trained to recognize what it looks like when a kid may be struggling. The adult asks one of the professionals in the school a counselor, social worker, or, if possible, a therapist who checks in with the student to determine if there is a serious issue, and if there is, makes sure that the student gets diagnosed and treated.
Mental health in schools was supported in the reform of No Child Left Behind, but at a woefully inadequate level. If the administration and Congress are serious about mental health, we need to devote more resources to treatment not fewer resources, as we see in the administrations latest budget.
10K Likes1.7K Comments1.6K Shares
pamdb
(1,332 posts)I miss him.
badhair77
(4,220 posts)Wellstone ruled
(34,661 posts)As usual,you explain the cause with real solution's and remedies.
Martin Eden
(12,874 posts)He was removed from where he could do the most good.
mn9driver
(4,428 posts)And many of us wont forget it.
scarletwoman
(31,893 posts)calimary
(81,421 posts)Thanks for creating more problems than you think you solved, Kirsten.
Stonepounder
(4,033 posts)Amaryllis
(9,525 posts)PatrickforO
(14,586 posts)hook,
line,
and sinker.
pangaia
(24,324 posts)magicarpet
(14,160 posts)Of the smear done to the Black voter registration group - Acorn, and then Planned Parenthood.
Hated by the far Right Wingers so much so they fabricate and concocted the smear and ultimate loss of funding sources then eventually cause total elimination.
pandr32
(11,601 posts)Many of us called out the BS.
dem4decades
(11,301 posts)PatrickforO
(14,586 posts)What was it, 38 Senators piled on and demanded he resign before he'd gotten due process? That's what I always had the problem with - he didn't get due process. Even a slime like Trump deserves, and in fact is entitled to, due process. But Al didn't get it.
Now, I called the offices of most of those Senators and registered my displeasure. So, I'm sure, did a lot of other people on here. I also wrote letters and signed a couple petitions, but alas, it did no good.
I say we, because we are all part of this party. We can't sit here and say 'they' did such and such, because 'them' is actually us.
We are not always going to agree on stuff. But this is OUR party. WE. When we make a mistake, we must own it and take steps that the mistake is not repeated.
LuckyLib
(6,819 posts)Disgusting. He would have been within his rights to put his hands up and declare, "No thanks!"
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)she liked Al and considered him a friend. With friends like that...
gyroscope
(1,443 posts)...no investigation required.
ananda
(28,873 posts)Only those like Gillibrand who saw an opportunity.
BlancheSplanchnik
(20,219 posts)Whether it was an underlying agenda or merely overexcited jumping on the #MeToo bus while completely misunderstanding the point of the movement, either way it ended up being anti-Justice and heartbreakingly damaging to Democratic Process and human rights in America. Al is one of our very best.
a kennedy
(29,694 posts)jalan48
(13,879 posts)Susan Calvin
(1,648 posts)I sure hope not.
Stonepounder
(4,033 posts)We only had one car at the time, so it was not at all uncommon for my mom and my sister and I would drive to the hospital to puck him up after work. We would sit on the grounds, watch the squirrels, and often talk to folks. We never knew if we were talking to patients or staff. As Al so beautifully says, the vast majority of mentally ill folks are not violent. Some are, and the need to be locked up. Most are not, and just need help coping with day-to-day life.
We really, really, do NOT need some group to stigmatize.
Thank you, Al. Just for being you. Do not ever stop speaking out.
pazzyanne
(6,556 posts)here is a link to his facebook page.
https://www.facebook.com/search/top/?q=former%20senator%20al%20franken
Stonepounder
(4,033 posts)BREMPRO
(2,331 posts)the complexity and that you can not just deflect blame on mental illness, but have to also deal with the insane easy access to weapons if war by virtually anyone in this country. Also i would add alienation, bullying, boys impulse control and taboo with expression of emotion, violent culture that glorifies war.. Arming teachers is an N RA bullet point, not a solution to a complex problem. I miss Frankens voice of reason ,and still angry he was disposed if so easily by his colleagues.
Cha
(297,503 posts)Thanks brooklyn
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)Cha
(297,503 posts)he's speaking from.
Jackie!
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)Cha!
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)Cha
(297,503 posts)StevieM
(10,500 posts)rainin
(3,011 posts)future. Run for Governor please.
zentrum
(9,865 posts)Miss him. Need him in Congress.
Will never forgive.
lordsummerisle
(4,651 posts)OAITW r.2.0
(24,556 posts)I think we understand how you got railroaded on this issue. For those that don't think that is the case, you can always vote for for for Donald Trump.
Angry Dragon
(36,693 posts)I asked him before
Hekate
(90,769 posts)...DUers can be fickle. Send Senator Franken our best regards and promise to convey his thoughts to us. He and his record are much appreciated.
DFW
(54,428 posts)Right wing trolls peruse boards like ours in the hope of grabbing some convenient quote they can use out of context in some future ad (or smear campaign).
But when he puts out intelligent, coherent commentary like the one posted, we should display it proudly, as was done for this thread.
PatrickforO
(14,586 posts)I think there are a lot of heavy hitters on this site, and I often hope that they are listening to some of the things we say in the threads. I wouldn't be surprised if at least a few staffers, and possibly some office holders, don't post on here without revealing who they are. If I were in office, I would certainly seek out a number of places like this and either assign staff or go in myself and test the waters, so to speak, on issues.
Hekate
(90,769 posts)betsuni
(25,592 posts)BlueMTexpat
(15,370 posts)Your voice is still both needed and heeded.
MyOwnPeace
(16,937 posts)This "brilliance" sitting outside the US Senate while we have dolts "inside" whose contributions to our country are guided by the amount of $$$$$$$ the NRA puts in their pockets.
We miss you, Al!!!!
heaven05
(18,124 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)Tell it like it is, not many can in and out of our political process. I so want to go on..,but this is about Parkland and our citizen brown shirt army, usually mentally unfit, trying to show that they are in charge. How can I say this? Because 99.9% of these cowards are white male.
heaven05
(18,124 posts)we lost him...,
marble falls
(57,145 posts)office again and soon.
MyOwnPeace
(16,937 posts)and I think he's smart enough (well, there's no doubt about how smart he is) to put together a campaign that would answer any questions regarding why he left the senate (or was pushed out!) and again convince an electorate that he's the right person for the job!
Go, AL!!!!
NCTraveler
(30,481 posts)dlk
(11,574 posts)Mc Mike
(9,115 posts)oasis
(49,398 posts)Response to brooklynite (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed
HelenWheels
(2,284 posts)I was a real backer of Baldwin before she threw Al on the garbage heap. I will still vote for her but I no longer donate to her campaign. I have been invited several times to attend fund raisers for Baldwin and each time I tell the caller how I now feel about Baldwin. I am very sad about this.
AL MUST GET BACK INTO OFFICE. HE WAS THE BEST OF ALL THE SENATORS!
Dark n Stormy Knight
(9,771 posts)Not sure if anyone else already did, but not surprised this came from Franken. He is missed.
marieo1
(1,402 posts)Al Franken, you exactly verbalized my thoughts!!! Thank you so much. I just want you to know how devastated I was that you felt you had to step down. I could see you being our next President!!
Morris64
(78 posts)Gabi Hayes
(28,795 posts)The audio book of this is as good as anything hes written, and thats saying something