General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsRepublican judges warn of 'tyranny' as they block Trump on 'sanctuary cities'
By James Hohmann April 20 at 9:22 AM
THE BIG IDEA:
A panel of three judges, each appointed by a Republican president to the federal appeals court in Chicago, ruled unanimously on Thursday against President Trumps effort to withhold money from sanctuary cities.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit upheld a nationwide injunction that blocks the Justice Department from using the sword of federal funding to conscript state and local authorities to aid in federal civil immigration enforcement.
Trumps latest courtroom defeat offers yet another civics lesson about checks and balances for the first president in American history who lacks any prior governing or military experience. Unlike congressional Republicans who have by and large kowtowed and capitulated to Trumpism, despite private uneasiness and grumbling in many cases, Republican-appointed judges are free not to care about the wrath of the president or blowback from his loyalists. This gives them the breathing room to worry more about the rule of law than partisanship. That was the point of an independent judiciary and giving lifetime appointments. Its how the Constitution is supposed to work.
Judge Ilana Rovner, who was appointed to a district judgeship by Ronald Reagan and elevated to the circuit by George H.W. Bush, offers a remarkable rebuke of the Trump administration in a 35-page opinion that can be read as a tutorial on the separation of powers. She even throws around words like tyranny that you dont often see in opinions of this nature:
Our role in this case is not to assess the optimal immigration policies for our country, she writes. Rather, the issue before us strikes at one of the bedrock principles of our nation, the protection of which transcends political party affiliation and rests at the heart of our system of government
more
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/paloma/daily-202/2018/04/20/daily-202-republican-judges-warn-of-tyranny-as-they-block-trump-on-sanctuary-cities/5ad94d9d30fb0437119267e1/
procon
(15,805 posts)In appointing Jeff Sessions as the AG, trump wanted a lackluster, compliant toady who would do his bidding without question. Instead of a strong AG who knew the law and was confident enough to tell Trump that his racial hatreds and biases were illegal and could not stand, a weak and indecisive Sessions tried to pass the buck off to the courts to do his job.
Crutchez_CuiBono
(7,725 posts)Sometimes Judges can really surprise you. Such a relief. They are after all, human beings.