Good question

There was never a time when America was great for ALL it's citizens.

Never.

Don't just hand the MAGA crowd a mic and let them say "He's making America great again!"

That means nothing.

Ask the follow-up question.

I read the first few responses, and they're actually reasonably troll-free. Maybe that's because a lot of the MAGA crowd cannot answer an actual question with honesty (we want the good old days where we didn't hear much from POC and LGBTQ), or by doing more than simply parroting their Dear Leader's slogan.

Despite their current russophelia

Ouch.

the jingoistic fantasies and delusions of the right wing.

A tv fantasy of Opie Taylor and Leave it to Beaver.

Crime, drugs, did not exist in the mythical past of the Christofascist
Gays were in the closet, pregnancy out of wedlock was hidden
You could beat your child or wife without consequences
Discriminate against minorities
Prayer in schools
lynch and terrorize, safe in knowing that the white juries would let you off
Slavery, genocide, Indian schools, religious violence, of no consequence.

This is greatness to the thuggish right.

The highest tax rate in those days 90%.

Thanks Opie!

If anyone can answer that question, then we would be able to draw the parallels between now and then.