Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

uponit7771

(90,367 posts)
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 06:00 PM Aug 2018

Can a speaker of the house who's been appointed president via succession choose her own

... Vice President then resign making said Vice President ... President Of The United States?

Thx in advance for any input

P.S. Jus sayin, we can all dream no?

63 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Can a speaker of the house who's been appointed president via succession choose her own (Original Post) uponit7771 Aug 2018 OP
Didn't Gerald Ford? Rhiannon12866 Aug 2018 #1
Damn, so the appointed president and former SOTH can literally choose anyone? Didn't know that uponit7771 Aug 2018 #3
But I think the Senate has to approve the nomination MiniMe Aug 2018 #7
Majority approval by both houses is required struggle4progress Aug 2018 #15
Thanks MiniMe Aug 2018 #20
Not gonna happen. Pence and tRump won't resign in the same minute. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #16
Nelson Rockefeller was never Speaker (see OP). Same with Senator Gerald Ford. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #14
Ford was never a Senator dumbcat Aug 2018 #18
I am mistaken. You are correct. And he was Minority Leader in the House. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #19
Here's my fix-- dawg day Aug 2018 #2
K, so the new SOTH doesn't have to be a current member of congress meaning senate & house ? TIA uponit7771 Aug 2018 #4
Right. Speaker is whoevee the house elects. Doesnt matter who it is from my understanding. Tiggeroshii Aug 2018 #8
NICE !!! uponit7771 Aug 2018 #9
Sure. The Republicans can elect Putin. rickford66 Aug 2018 #62
Your scenario even less likely. Trump & Pence resigning in same minute just so HRC can be Pres? Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #17
Resign? I want them IMPEACHED AND CONVICTED. dawg day Aug 2018 #28
It is conceivable they could be impeached and convicted simultaneously in a single proceeding, Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #31
+1 uponit7771 Aug 2018 #43
Yes, if the VP is approved by Congress euphorb Aug 2018 #5
" but that nomination would have to be approved by a majority vote of both houses of Congress" .... uponit7771 Aug 2018 #6
No. You make a common fundamental error. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #13
Not ANYONE in the US-- there are a few people who CANNOT be appointed or elected VP: dawg day Aug 2018 #30
Yes, indeed. Exactly. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #32
LOL - I sure could have used your input into a debate I had Totally Tunsie Aug 2018 #50
yes, but some here are not very supportive of the idea cutroot Aug 2018 #10
That has nothing to do with the OP's question. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #12
Ford was a House member when selected as the VP. Blue_true Aug 2018 #24
Correct, and never Speaker. Even if he had been my point stands. Need simultaneous vacancy. nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #25
You point on the vacancy condition is correct. And your point that it is highly unlikely to happen Blue_true Aug 2018 #27
trumps election was also highly unlikely cutroot Aug 2018 #38
The OP asked for any input cutroot Aug 2018 #29
Very-low-density lipoprotein (VLDL) is a type of lipoprotein made by the liver. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #34
???? cutroot Aug 2018 #37
Exactly my point. ???? Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #40
Did you not read the OP ? cutroot Aug 2018 #44
You did not. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #46
Try the link cutroot Aug 2018 #48
Yes and no. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #11
Appoint is the wrong word MiniMe Aug 2018 #21
Yes, your more precise description is correct. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #22
And if the presidency becomes vacant before a VP is approved, the Speaker becomes president. dawg day Aug 2018 #41
You are correct MiniMe Aug 2018 #49
I think Yes. The Constitution does not prevent a President from resigning. Blue_true Aug 2018 #23
It can takes weeks for the VP nominee to be approved. dawg day Aug 2018 #42
I'm not sure I understand your "dream" or your reference to the SOTH being a "she". Totally Tunsie Aug 2018 #26
Yes, ... just a dream question. But Red Don's selection was a dream also uponit7771 Aug 2018 #45
So..... Pelosi gets to be prez... apcalc Aug 2018 #33
Not going to happen. Pelosi will never be President of the United States. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #35
Yes, I saw the post. Just enjoying the thought of it. apcalc Aug 2018 #63
It may be a dream sarisataka Aug 2018 #36
What could happen is that if the Ds control both House & Senate, they could hold out for only D VP. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2018 #39
Thx, stranger things have happened though uponit7771 Aug 2018 #47
they really haven't. Takket Aug 2018 #59
Thanks for making this concept even sillier than it was before... brooklynite Aug 2018 #51
Sillier than an overt Russian mob tied racist dumb ass becoming president? uponit7771 Aug 2018 #52
Yes, but it would be kind of dumb. Why would they want to do that? The Velveteen Ocelot Aug 2018 #53
Don't think Pelosi has wanted to be president for years but we know Pelosi knows someone who does ;) uponit7771 Aug 2018 #54
But if you had the chance wouldn't you take it? The Velveteen Ocelot Aug 2018 #55
Heeeeeellllllllll to the naw !!! That's a grinder position to even meet par, NO !! Not at all !! uponit7771 Aug 2018 #56
I have no idea what that means. The Velveteen Ocelot Aug 2018 #57
As the Speaker doesn't have to be a member of House, Dems could select Hillary to be Speaker Kaleva Aug 2018 #58
soooooooooooooooooo Takket Aug 2018 #60
There's almost no chance of Nancy Pelosi succeeding to the presidency either Kaleva Aug 2018 #61

uponit7771

(90,367 posts)
3. Damn, so the appointed president and former SOTH can literally choose anyone? Didn't know that
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 06:05 PM
Aug 2018

... Dream got slightly better.

MiniMe

(21,719 posts)
7. But I think the Senate has to approve the nomination
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 06:22 PM
Aug 2018

Not sure if it is the house or the Senate, or both. I don't remember, just know they had to vote on the VP

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
19. I am mistaken. You are correct. And he was Minority Leader in the House.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 08:29 PM
Aug 2018

Kind of alt-Speaker in a way.

But the point remains: the only way a Speaker is raised to the Presidency is by simultaneous vacancy of both the P and VP offices.

Ford, a Republican, was appointed VP by a Republican President who then resigned. He was not raised in one step, he was not Speaker, and he was not from the opposite party. He was not raised to VP, he was appointed to VP.

dawg day

(7,947 posts)
2. Here's my fix--
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 06:04 PM
Aug 2018

The House can choose a speaker who is NOT a member.

Now I'd rather have Pelosi stay-- she's smart and savvy, and I'm tired of women politicians getting trashed and then be called 'politically toxic"--

But if not-- The Democrats could elect a former senator, secretary of state, and first lady-- all in one package.
Hillary Clinton, Speaker of the House.

rickford66

(5,528 posts)
62. Sure. The Republicans can elect Putin.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 11:13 PM
Aug 2018

Constitution's Article 1, Section 2, Clause 5: “The House of Representatives shall chuse [sic] their Speaker and other Officers."

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
17. Your scenario even less likely. Trump & Pence resigning in same minute just so HRC can be Pres?
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 08:11 PM
Aug 2018

Not going to happen.

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
31. It is conceivable they could be impeached and convicted simultaneously in a single proceeding,
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:09 PM
Aug 2018

... but about as likely as tRump suddenly beginning to study foreign policy background briefing books.

I expect they will be tried sequentially if they don't resign sequentially and nominate successors sequentially.

euphorb

(279 posts)
5. Yes, if the VP is approved by Congress
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 06:07 PM
Aug 2018

The new President would be able to nominate a new Vice President, but that nomination would have to be approved by a majority vote of both houses of Congress (25th Amendment, Section 2). After that, I can't see any bar to the President resigning.

uponit7771

(90,367 posts)
6. " but that nomination would have to be approved by a majority vote of both houses of Congress" ....
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 06:09 PM
Aug 2018

... that would be the roadblock then.

But it looks like the house majority can select a non ... CONGRESS ... member to be SOTH and via succession the SOTH becomes president.

Waiting for clarity on that end too.

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
13. No. You make a common fundamental error.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 08:05 PM
Aug 2018

It is not an order of succession, which is a term for everybody moving up one spot.

The only way the Speaker becomes President is by simultaneous vacancy of the P and VP spots.

{ Yes, the President could appoint the Speaker to VP and then resign, but then the person would be ascending from VP and not from Speaker. President can appoint anybody in the US to VP if it is vacant (perhaps subject to 35 years old rule). }

dawg day

(7,947 posts)
30. Not ANYONE in the US-- there are a few people who CANNOT be appointed or elected VP:
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:09 PM
Aug 2018

Bill Clinton
George W. Bush
Barack H. Obama

They have all served two full terms as president and are ineligible to serve as VP (who must be eligible to be president) or president.

Totally Tunsie

(10,885 posts)
50. LOL - I sure could have used your input into a debate I had
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 10:00 PM
Aug 2018

with LakeSuperioriew on this very topic. I had posted the following excerpt, and we went back and forth for 12 posts, with LSV insisting Obama could be named as the VP candidate.

Constitutionally, there is a 10 year limit on anyone's service as President. Someone who has served two full terms would not be eligible to be VP due to the fact there is no guarantee that his President would serve more than half his term. If, say, President dies after first year in office, leaving three years remaining, his (two term served as President) VP would be ineligible to serve out the three remaining years. Thus, Barack Obama could not constitutionally run as VP.

I thought the concept was pretty clear, but apparently not. It started to get heated, and I finally bowed out after their final rudeness:
I can see that you are a person who insists on the last word, so go ahead and make another tortured argument about things that do not exist in the language of the 22nd amendment and have a nice weekend.

[link:https://www.democraticunderground.com/1016211214#post2|


cutroot

(876 posts)
10. yes, but some here are not very supportive of the idea
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 06:45 PM
Aug 2018

Although the Constitution does not require the Speaker to be a Member of the House, all Speakers have been Members. When a Congress convenes for the first time, each major party conference or caucus nominates a candidate for Speaker. Members customarily elect the Speaker by roll call vote.

http://clerk.house.gov/member_info/memberfaq.aspx

A new speaker of the house could be anyone.

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
12. That has nothing to do with the OP's question.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 08:01 PM
Aug 2018

Senator Ford (the closest example to the OP's question) become President and was never Speaker and wasn't a House member either in the immediately preceding years.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
27. You point on the vacancy condition is correct. And your point that it is highly unlikely to happen
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:00 PM
Aug 2018

is correct also.

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
46. You did not.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:26 PM
Aug 2018

You answered it only as far as you typed the word "Yes".

The rest of the verbiage about the tradition of Speakers being House members has nothing to do with the OP.

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
11. Yes and no.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 07:59 PM
Aug 2018

1) Any President who does not have a Vice President for whatever reason (death, resignation) can appoint one.

2) Any President can resign.

3) Because of points 1 & 2, Speakers only get raised to President if there is a simultaneous vacancy of both President and VP. Not very likely to happen this millennium.

dawg day

(7,947 posts)
41. And if the presidency becomes vacant before a VP is approved, the Speaker becomes president.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:20 PM
Aug 2018

The Nixon years had two VP appts:
Agnew was forced out (bribery conviction).
1. Nixon nominated Gerald Ford, and he was approved.
2. After Nixon's resignation, Ford nominated his own VP- Nelson Rockefeller.

With both occasions, there were weeks-- months with Rocky-- where there was no VP. During these periods, if a vacancy happened in the presidency, the speaker would have become president.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
23. I think Yes. The Constitution does not prevent a President from resigning.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 08:50 PM
Aug 2018

But the President and Vice President have to be sworn in first. I don't know whether there is a minimum time that the President must serve.

But the scenario you are looking at is unlikely. If Trump and Pence get indicted for crimes, when one resigns, the other will pick a replacement. They would both have to stroke out and die at the same time upon getting indicted for the Speaker of the House to take over and chose a VP.

dawg day

(7,947 posts)
42. It can takes weeks for the VP nominee to be approved.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:21 PM
Aug 2018

Rockefeller in 1974 wasn't approved for 4 months almost.

Totally Tunsie

(10,885 posts)
26. I'm not sure I understand your "dream" or your reference to the SOTH being a "she".
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 08:59 PM
Aug 2018

The current SOTH is PAUL RYAN, so that doesn't advance the Democratic dream, IMO.

Are you thinking ahead to after the mid-terms where, hopefully, the Dems win control?

apcalc

(4,465 posts)
33. So..... Pelosi gets to be prez...
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:09 PM
Aug 2018

Picks HRC as VP

Pelosi then resigns...

HRC becomes prez

OMG that is delicious!

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
35. Not going to happen. Pelosi will never be President of the United States. . . . nt
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:13 PM
Aug 2018

See the point about simultaneous vacancies.

sarisataka

(18,792 posts)
36. It may be a dream
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:15 PM
Aug 2018

But at least it is a Constitutional a possible dream unlike some other half baked fantasies floating around

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,047 posts)
39. What could happen is that if the Ds control both House & Senate, they could hold out for only D VP.
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 09:17 PM
Aug 2018

Assume tRump resigns and Pence ascends and needs to appoint a VP.

If the Democrats win both chambers, they could hold the line and demand that the only acceptable nominee for VP would be a Democrat. Not specified. Eventually Pence in desperation nominates a Democrat. That Democrat ascends to President as Pence is impeached / resigns. Said Democrat nominates HRC to VP and then when she is approved, resigns.

The Democrats would have leverage because if there is no approval, then with the VP spot vacant, a Pence resignation would mean the Democratic speaker would become President.

That the only scenario I see that bears any resemblance to the OP's fantasy. But it requires a certain sequence and having control of both houses and Pence being publicly implicated / shown to be complicit.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,879 posts)
53. Yes, but it would be kind of dumb. Why would they want to do that?
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 10:09 PM
Aug 2018

If you've been third in line for the presidency for years and all of a sudden you finally got your chance, why would you appoint someone else? I sure as hell wouldn't.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,879 posts)
55. But if you had the chance wouldn't you take it?
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 10:22 PM
Aug 2018

Realistically, of course, nothing like this is going to happen anyhow.

Kaleva

(36,356 posts)
58. As the Speaker doesn't have to be a member of House, Dems could select Hillary to be Speaker
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 10:31 PM
Aug 2018

(Assuming Dems win control of House. )

Thus if Trump AND Pence go down, Hillary would be next in line to be President.

Takket

(21,639 posts)
60. soooooooooooooooooo
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 10:44 PM
Aug 2018

The GOPs in the Senate are going to vote to remove drumpf and Pence from office knowing that makes literally their most hated person on Earth President?

Nope.

They might remove drumpf, but Pence would remain.

The Dem's best bet to remove drumpf AND Pence is to make some rehtug as close to reasonable as possible the VP under pence. Maybe a Flake or Corker or Collins. With a dem congress the president would be effectively a lame duck until 2020

But there is NO actionable scenario where we come out of this with the White house AND Congress before 2021's swearing in.

Kaleva

(36,356 posts)
61. There's almost no chance of Nancy Pelosi succeeding to the presidency either
Thu Aug 23, 2018, 10:50 PM
Aug 2018

So we are just free thinking here.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Can a speaker of the hous...