General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsHow Far America Has Fallen
Thats the bit of the United States the rest of the world finds hardest to fathom. Why the scorn for handouts, the equating of universal health care with socialism, the obsession with self-reliance, the refusal to see that a profusion of guns leads to a profusion of mass shootings? Of course a crowded Europe with its wounds seeks solidarity in the name of stability, while America with its wide-open spaces embraces the right to be left alone (at least until you need Medicaid) and the right, whatever its risks, to the next frontier.
I said its different in the West. Its not so different in the West, its just that you see more clearly what the country stood for in its own mythologized self-image, what it was to be an American, what it was to aspire to some new and exemplary measure of freedom, and how far things have fallen to produce President Donald Trump.
No part of the country today is immune to American fracture or the squalid Trump wars, to cultural confrontations over identity and gender and race, to the effects of stagnant incomes over decades, or to the narcissism of modernity.
...
Theres a deeper question, which comes back to the extraordinary Western landscape and the high American idea enshrined in it. Americans elected Trump. Nobody else did. They came down to his level. White Christian males losing their place in the social order decided theyd do anything to save themselves, and to heck with morality. They made a bargain with the devil in full knowledge. So the real question is: What does it mean to be an American today? Who are we, goddamit? What have we become?
Trump was a symptom, not a cause. The problem is way deeper than him.
For William Steding, a diplomatic historian living in Colorado, American individualism has morphed into narcissism, perfectibility into entitlement, and exceptionalism into hubris. Out of that, and more, came the insidious malignancy of Trump. It will not be extirpated overnight.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/24/opinion/trump-colorado-purple-state.html?action=click&module=Opinion&pgtype=Homepage
SWBTATTReg
(22,166 posts)beachbum bob
(10,437 posts)But too many apathetic democrats let this happen...and it's up to them to change it
Farmer-Rick
(10,212 posts)He buys everything with other people's money. He even buys his wives and sex partners.
Eventually all of capitalism will devolve into nothing more than criminality and corruption. It is built into the economic system.
Paka
(2,760 posts)The sad reality of what produced "a Trump."
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)I'm not an admirer of Roger Cohen and his fake equivalencies of America's good people with bad, always averaging out into nation of deplorables in decline. This is such a recurring theme he probably chooses to believe the America-bashing dystopian themes that keep his paycheck coming, but I'm not buying.
Sure, he's quoting large facets of truth that are worth examining, but reality is edited into gross distortion. If Cohen's false equivalencies between America's people were physical he'd be in danger of being crushed if they toppled on him.
Yes, Americans did elect Trump with a great deal of help from structural advantages and illicit election tampering, not at all incidentally from the New York Times.
Americans also elected Obama twice and then Hillary in overall much larger numbers in spite of structural electoral disadvantages and massive election tampering against us.
But, +1000 for the hoards of analysts who recognize Trump as only a symptom, though.
Shame on Cohen, though, for not pointing out that, though some dysfunctions well described by others afflict all sectors of society, the evils of Trump and he illustrates come solidly from the right. Racist, nationalist, pitiless, social and religious conservatives and venal archconservative billionaires are using advantages of power to operate far beyond their numbers as they attempt to drag our nation down into authoritarianism.
Not most of Americans.