Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDetroit Judge rules Congress can't block mutilation
Link to tweet
.
Dr. Jumana Nagarwala wants a judge to dismiss a conspiracy charge involving two 7-year-old Minnesota girls who were brought to Metro Detroit for what prosecutors call an illegal procedure performed by the Northville doctor. The procedure is practiced by some members of the Dawoodi Bohra, a Muslim sect from India that has a small community in Metro Detroit.
The request came nine days after U.S. District Judge Bernard Friedman dismissed female genital mutilation charges against Nagarwala and others. The judge's order was a significant, but not fatal, blow to a novel criminal case because Friedman left intact conspiracy and obstruction charges that could send Nagarwala and three others to federal prison for decades.
Prosecutors allege Minnesota mothers Haseena Halfal and Zainab Hariyanawala brought their daughters to Detroit in February 2017 to undergo female genital mutilation. Prosecutors say the trip constituted a crime: conspiracy to travel with intent to engage in illicit sexual conduct.
Judge opined Congress has no authority to make laws concerning issues of this nature.
https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/detroit-city/2018/11/20/judge-dismisses-key-count-genital-mutilation-case/2066855002/
JUDGE Friedman removed four defendants from the case including three mothers accused of subjecting their daughters to female genital mutilation while concluding Congress had no authority to enact a law criminalizing female genital mutilation, known as FGM.There is nothing commercial or economic about FGM, Friedman wrote in a 28-page opinion. (Female genital mutilation) is not part of a larger market and it has no demonstrated effect on interstate commerce. The Commerce Clause does not permit Congress to regulate a crime of this nature.
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
8 replies, 993 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (3)
ReplyReply to this post
8 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Detroit Judge rules Congress can't block mutilation (Original Post)
laserhaas
Dec 2018
OP
"The Commerce Clause does not permit Congress to regulate a crime of this nature."
Glorfindel
Dec 2018
#1
Glorfindel
(9,733 posts)1. "The Commerce Clause does not permit Congress to regulate a crime of this nature."
Surely there are state laws that regulate these crimes! What is the difference between FGM and cutting off someone's hand?
Cicada
(4,533 posts)3. States absolutely can outlaw it, and most have, including michigan
Maybe the statute has expired in Michigan on these specific cases?
Sgent
(5,857 posts)4. I think the last count
was 36 have outlawed it.
Michigan's law was enacted after this case happened, so she can't be charged with it (ex-post facto law).
Cicada
(4,533 posts)5. No fair knowing the facts
X_Digger
(18,585 posts)8. There is no federal law against cutting off someone's hand..
.. unless they're a federal officer, traveling over state lines, are on a federal naval vessel..
ie, something explicitly ties them to a federal jurisdiction.
If I recall from the earlier discussion of this topic, 26 out of 50 states have laws against FGM.
Hermit-The-Prog
(33,400 posts)2. there are real monsters in this world
And I'm not talking about the judge.
DFW
(54,436 posts)6. I would be astounded to hear that Michigan has no laws against aggravated assault
And if genital mutilation isn't aggravated assault, then neither is cutting a judge's face to ribbons with a Swiss army knife.