General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsI wasn't surprised by the light sentence, were you?
We all have heard from this judge before. Rachel Maddow did part of a show on him. We all knew where he stood and what he is made of. His reputation, from before he ever heard of Manafort, was that of an arrogant, grand standing, emotional and "unusually biased" judge. Next week's judge is different and from what we have seen and heard from her and her court I expect Manafort will receive a fair and just sentence by a professional judge. Her actions and reputation are much more balanced and appropriate than today's judge's light sentencing.
DURHAM D
(32,611 posts)NightWatcher
(39,343 posts)So no, not shocked.
FrankBooth
(1,607 posts)Ellis was horrible during the trial, but I didn't expect this travesty. I am optimistic you are right.
RKP5637
(67,112 posts)UniteFightBack
(8,231 posts)just what the fuck is wrong with this judge?
mikewv
(127 posts)Cattledog
(5,919 posts)This Judge served up "white justice".
True Blue American
(17,989 posts)A blameless life outside of stealing millions and cheating on millions in taxes. Yeah/ right, Judge!
Hoyt
(54,770 posts)usually 20 years.
He is also subject to $24.8 Million in restitution. Hes ruined and has another sentence to go.
LenaBaby61
(6,979 posts)ManFART is a rich, white, right-winged, treasonous male.
Hell, I'm shocked that a fellow right-winged, attentnion-seeking, ignorant fool judge gave ManFART as much time as he DID tbh.
blogslut
(38,018 posts)I was expecting something like 8-10 years.
GoCubsGo
(32,095 posts)And, this fuckstick judge will not be the only one he faces.
wishstar
(5,271 posts)After Judge Ellis' remarks during trial, it was a relief just for the jury to convict on 8 counts even with one Trumper holdout juror
empedocles
(15,751 posts)Iliyah
(25,111 posts)messages earlier that he was going light on him.
But alas, more sentencing to come.
sacto95834
(393 posts)maybe that's the silver lining. At least this POS will spend four years in prison. I think if he had thrown the book at him and sentenced him to 20 or so years makes a pardon easier as being excessive. Believe me I hope Manafort suffers every day in there - for all the evil he has done.
BlueStater
(7,596 posts)Our justice system is a fucking joke.
llmart
(15,555 posts)The older I get the more cynical I get, or rather the more realistic I get. In my younger days I really did believe that we lived in a country of some semblance of fairness and equity in our laws and justice. But with each passing decade of my life I've seen so much inequity in the law that I am no longer that little bit naive person who believed that mostly justice would prevail in our country. Then the election of 2000 happened and all of that went out the window when I saw that even the highest court in our land could be compromised.
So no. I wasn't surprised. Actually I'm more surprised that it wasn't less.
Many people on DU still expect that Trump is going to be carted off to prison. They also believed that Bush/Cheney would be prosecuted for war crimes.
There are different standards for different types of people in this country and we need to wake up to the fact that we've been sold a fairy tale about the USA.
BigmanPigman
(51,632 posts)"BigmanPigman, life isn't fair. Get used to it". Of course I resisted and said that it should be fair. Eventually I changed careers and became a teacher. Since I was the authority figure in my own classroom I made and enforced the rules. One the first day of school, every year, I told my class that "life isn't fair but in my room it is" and it was! We voted on everything and solved problems by listening to all parties. I quickly became known as the "nice and fair teacher" through siblings, friends and word of mouth. Students I never even taught came up to me at recess to solve arguments is a fair way. I wish life were more like my classroom and I could make it more fair.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)There recently was a law and order judge that throws the book at POC defendants who bent over backward to help a young White woman and young White man who were convicted by juries, he was recently reelected for another 6 year term.
Jarqui
(10,130 posts)He sold his country out.
What he seemed to do was worse than Cohen and he broke his plea deal ... and only got an extra year for it.
Jersey Devil
(9,875 posts)When do you recall a rich white collar criminal getting many years in jail for a first offense, no matter how bad the offenses? The only instance I can think of recently was Bernie Madoff and that was because there were so many individual victims (who also happened to be rich).
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)Adrahil
(13,340 posts)Peace06
(248 posts)Mr. Mueller is not finished with Manafort. Also looks like we need a cleanup of the judicial system too. Hopefully, Dems will get to that when they can. Don't despair! There is more to come on Manafort.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)That particular judge has had a tilt form Day1.
CentralMass
(15,265 posts)TDale313
(7,820 posts)The Velveteen Ocelot
(115,869 posts)and he often opposes mandatory minimum sentences - which isn't necessarily a bad thing, as in this instance:
The judge appointed Daniel Suleiman, a former aide to Attorney General Eric Holder, to come up with any argument that might help Gaines win a more lenient sentence. Suleiman, a partner at Covington & Burling, set on one possibility: a Supreme Court ruling in April that invalidated a law very similar to the one requiring the lengthy sentence for Gaines.
He's an eccentric old crank with a reputation for grandstanding. But I disagree with suggestions that he was somehow "bought" or otherwise influenced to do Manafort a favor to help Trump in some way. If he really wanted to help Manafort he could have, for example, granted a defense motion for judgment nothwithstanding the verdict. And if Manafort is going to be pardoned anyhow (which wouldn't surprise me), he could have sentenced him to any sentence at all, or none. He just did what he would have done anyhow, probably because he likes fucking with prosecutors.
JI7
(89,275 posts)Catherine Vincent
(34,491 posts)You know if Manafort was working with Obama or a Clinton, the outcome would have been different.
samnsara
(17,640 posts)theboss
(10,491 posts)I was thinking 60 to 72 months.
Financial fraud is generally treated like this though alas.
CDerekGo
(507 posts)After a history of racism and discrimination in his sentencing, T.S. Ellis certainly needs to be investigated, and removed from his Judicial position. I'm almost to the stance, that every Judge, maybe even Supreme Court Judges, should be given 'Performance Reviews' like the rest of us receive at work. Enough 'demerits' mean removal/termination with no recourse.