General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhether Trump obstructed justice isn't the attorney general's call to make. It's Congress' decision.
https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/whether-trump-obstructed-justice-isn-t-attorney-general-s-call-ncna986971?cid=sm_npd_nn_fb_ma&fbclid=IwAR2dAf7fVPBbJrXQKHBPqB-43BB_5qPYPIMuzrSsMQ7uxdFUw-m9WDXbcu8Whether Trump obstructed justice isn't the attorney general's call to make. It's Congress' decision.
The Mueller report didn't draw a conclusion about any obstruction of justice. Barr needs to show the evidence on which he based his decision.
March 25, 2019, 11:36 AM EDT
By Michael Conway, Former counsel, U.S. House Judiciary Committee
Attorney General William Barrs four-page summary of the principal conclusions of Special Counsel Robert Mueller still-secret report, released on Sunday, engages in sleight-of-hand when finding that President Donald Trump did not engage in criminal obstruction of justice.
Mueller made no such conclusion. Rather, Trumps hand-picked attorney general, William Barr, in consultation with Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, decided that the evidence found by Mueller was insufficient to convict Trump beyond a reasonable doubt in a criminal trial.
Mueller apparently adhered to the principle of seeking just the facts. And facts matter: Neither Congress nor the public know the facts found by Mueller regarding obstruction of justice. A White House that famously promulgated a theory of alternative facts will find that the actual facts found by Muellers investigation matter.
snip//
Taking this cue, the 2019 House of Representatives would be well served to direct the Judiciary Committee to begin an impeachment inquiry. The special constitutional obligation of Congress to conduct impeachment provides the strongest argument for the courts to order the release of the full Mueller report, if Barr balks at doing so.
Importantly, the Founders believed that the impeachment power of Congress should be readily available if the president engages in acts even if they are not criminal acts that undermine the separation of powers or constitute a presidential abuse of power.
Even leaving aside the investigations of federal and state prosecutors in New York and elsewhere, President Trump is premature in claiming his exoneration by Barrs letter. Congress, the public and history are entitled to decide if Muellers recitation of facts warrants the indictment or impeachment of President Trump for obstruction of justice.
onetexan
(13,067 posts)Demand the release of the full unredacted report. Anything less is a clear sign theyve got lots to hide. Barr is a disgrace.
DallasNE
(7,403 posts)To make this decision on obstruction. Only the House can make that determination.
onetexan
(13,067 posts)duforsure
(11,885 posts)But show who he works for and represents, trump and not the American people . He will regret his actions , and history will not be kind to him for it. He could become a co-conspirator in the cover up.
malaise
(269,206 posts)ITTMF!!
ms liberty
(8,607 posts)democratisphere
(17,235 posts)robbedvoter
(28,290 posts)canetoad
(17,197 posts)Barr needs to explain or be impeached. Or both.
He has no business in that position, and we all knew that from the start.
GoCubsGo
(32,095 posts)If Barr doesn't release the report, I believe Malcolm Nance will be proven right again, in that pallet loads of documents will be dumped on the doorsteps of the NY Times, the Washington Post, and other media outlets. It will be leaked one way or another.
DallasNE
(7,403 posts)Barr needs to cite the case law granting him rather than the House the power to dispose the issue of obstruction. He hasn't done that either. Indeed, Eric Holder said that the reason Mueller cited both sides of the obstruction charge was because the decision was for the House to decide. Indeed, Barr could be in trouble on obstruction himself.
onetexan
(13,067 posts)House intel commtte to answer that exact question - who authorized him to take it upon himself to declare the Idiot's guilt 9r innocence.