Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Dennis Donovan

(18,770 posts)
Sat Jun 15, 2019, 07:31 AM Jun 2019

115 Years Ago Today; Excursion steamer "General Slocum" burns in East River - over 1000 dead

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PS_General_Slocum



The PS General Slocum was a sidewheel passenger steamboat built in Brooklyn, New York, in 1891. During her service history, she was involved in a number of mishaps, including multiple groundings and collisions.

On June 15, 1904, General Slocum caught fire and sank in the East River of New York City. At the time of the accident, she was on a chartered run carrying members of St. Mark's Evangelical Lutheran Church (German Americans from Little Germany, Manhattan) to a church picnic. An estimated 1,021 of the 1,342 people on board died. The General Slocum disaster was the New York area's worst disaster in terms of loss of life until the September 11, 2001 attacks. It is the worst maritime disaster in the city's history, and the second worst maritime disaster on United States waterways. The events surrounding the General Slocum fire have been explored in a number of books, plays, and movies.

<snip>

1904 disaster
General Slocum worked as a passenger ship, taking people on excursions around New York City. On Wednesday, June 15, 1904, the ship had been chartered for $350 by St. Mark's Evangelical Lutheran Church in the Little Germany district of Manhattan. This was an annual rite for the group, which had made the trip for 17 consecutive years, a period when German settlers moved out of Little Germany for the Upper East and West Sides. Over 1,400 passengers, mostly women and children, boarded General Slocum, which was to sail up the East River and then eastward across the Long Island Sound to Locust Grove, a picnic site in Eatons Neck, Long Island.

The ship got underway at 9:30 am. As it was passing East 90th Street, a fire started in the Lamp Room in the forward section, possibly caused by a discarded cigarette or match. It was fueled by the straw, oily rags, and lamp oil strewn around the room. The first notice of a fire was at 10 am; eyewitnesses claimed the initial blaze began in various locations, including a paint locker filled with flammable liquids and a cabin filled with gasoline. Captain Van Schaick was not notified until 10 minutes after the fire was discovered. A 12-year-old boy had tried to warn him earlier, but was not believed.


Carrying away a body from North Brother Island

Although the captain was ultimately responsible for the safety of passengers, the owners had made no effort to maintain or replace the ship's safety equipment. The fire hoses had been allowed to rot, and fell apart when the crew tried to put out the fire. The crew had never practiced a fire drill, and the lifeboats were tied up and inaccessible. (Some claim they were wired and painted in place.) Survivors reported that the life preservers were useless and fell apart in their hands. Desperate mothers placed life jackets on their children and tossed them into the water, only to watch in horror as their children sank instead of floating. Most of those on board were women and children who, like most Americans of the time, could not swim; victims found that their heavy wool clothing absorbed water and weighed them down in the river.


Victims of General Slocum washed ashore at North Brother Island.

It has been suggested that the manager of the life preserver manufacturer placed iron bars inside the cork preservers to meet minimum weight requirements at the time. Many of the life preservers had been filled with cheap and less effective granulated cork and brought up to proper weight by the inclusion of the iron weights. Canvas covers, rotted with age, split and scattered the powdered cork. Managers of the company (Nonpareil Cork Works) were indicted but not convicted. The life preservers had been manufactured in 1891 and had hung above the deck, unprotected from the elements, for 13 years.

Captain Van Schaick decided to continue his course rather than run the ship aground or stop at a nearby landing. By going into headwinds and failing to immediately ground the ship, he fanned the fire. Van Schaick later argued he was trying to avoid having the fire spread to riverside buildings and oil tanks. Flammable paint also helped the fire spread out of control.

Some passengers jumped into the river to escape the fire, but the heavy women's clothing of the day made swimming almost impossible and dragged them underwater to drown. Many died when the floors of the overloaded boat collapsed; others were battered by the still-turning paddles as they tried to escape into the water or over the sides.

By the time General Slocum sank in shallow water at North Brother Island, just off the Bronx shore, an estimated 1,021 people had either burned to death or drowned. There were 321 survivors. Five of the 40 crew members died.


Firefighters working to put out the fire on the listing General Slocum.

<snip>

The captain lost sight in one eye owing to the fire. Reports indicate that Captain Van Schaick deserted General Slocum as soon as it settled, jumping into a nearby tug, along with several crew. Some say his jacket was hardly rumpled, but other reports stated that he was seriously injured. He was hospitalized at Lebanon Hospital.

Many acts of heroism were committed by the passengers, witnesses, and emergency personnel. Staff and patients from the hospital on North Brother Island participated in the rescue efforts, forming human chains and pulling victims from the water.

Aftermath
Eight people were indicted by a federal grand jury after the disaster: the captain; two inspectors; and the president, secretary, treasurer, and commodore of the Knickerbocker Steamship Company. Only Captain Van Schaick was convicted. He was found guilty on one of three charges: criminal negligence, for failing to maintain proper fire drills and fire extinguishers. The jury could not reach a verdict on the other two counts of manslaughter. He was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment. He spent three years and six months at Sing Sing prison before he was paroled. President Theodore Roosevelt declined to pardon Captain Van Schaick. He was not released until the federal parole board under the William Howard Taft administration voted to free him on August 26, 1911. He was pardoned by President Taft on December 19, 1912; the pardon became effective on Christmas Day. After his death in 1927, Schaick was buried in Oakwood Cemetery (Troy, New York).

The Knickerbocker Steamship Company, which owned the ship, paid a relatively small fine despite evidence that they might have falsified inspection records. The disaster motivated federal and state regulation to improve the emergency equipment on passenger ships.

The neighborhood of Little Germany, which had been in decline for some time before the disaster as residents moved uptown, almost disappeared afterward. With the trauma and arguments that followed the tragedy and the loss of many prominent settlers, most of the Lutheran Germans remaining in the Lower East Side eventually moved uptown. The church whose congregation chartered the ship for the fateful voyage was converted to a synagogue in 1940 after the area was settled by Jewish residents.

The victims were interred in cemeteries around New York, with 58 identified victims buried in the Cemetery of the Evergreens in Brooklyn. Many victims were buried at Lutheran Cemetery in Middle Village, Queens (now Lutheran All Faiths Cemetery) where an annual memorial ceremony is held at the historical marker.

In 1906, a marble memorial fountain was erected in the north central part of Tompkins Square Park on Manhattan by the Sympathy Society of German Ladies, with the inscription: "They are Earth's purest children, young and fair."

The sunken remains of General Slocum were salvaged and converted into a barge named Maryland, which sank without loss of life in the Atlantic Ocean off the southeast coast of New Jersey near Strathmere and Sea Isle City during a storm on December 4, 1911, while carrying a cargo of coal.

</snip>


9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
115 Years Ago Today; Excursion steamer "General Slocum" burns in East River - over 1000 dead (Original Post) Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 OP
Don't know why I've never heard of this tragedy Bayard Jun 2019 #1
So who needs federal safety laws and inspections when the business owners are so thorough BSdetect Jun 2019 #2
And the lesson? Generic Other Jun 2019 #3
Never heard of this. Didnt know paddleboats carried so many Demovictory9 Jun 2019 #4
As a former New Yorker, I had heard of this tragic disaster. smirkymonkey Jun 2019 #5
Thanks. I was just reading about this at Wikipedia. I figured you might mahatmakanejeeves Jun 2019 #6
There was another steamboat disaster about 2 miles away from where I am now Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 #7
Saw a documentary on this a few years ago. Unbelievable tragedy. Alea Jun 2019 #8
I'm embarrassed to admit I've never heard of this. SMC22307 Jun 2019 #9

Bayard

(22,119 posts)
1. Don't know why I've never heard of this tragedy
Sat Jun 15, 2019, 10:53 AM
Jun 2019

More than 1,000 people on board......they must have been packed in like sardines.

Awful.

Generic Other

(28,979 posts)
3. And the lesson?
Sat Jun 15, 2019, 11:21 AM
Jun 2019

Do not let them get rid of safety regulations put in place by earlier generations for a good reason.

 

smirkymonkey

(63,221 posts)
5. As a former New Yorker, I had heard of this tragic disaster.
Sat Jun 15, 2019, 12:49 PM
Jun 2019

It was just unbearably sad, and like the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire, could have been prevented or casualties minimized if it had not been for the negligence and greed of the owners/operators.

And today we see republicans whining about the burden of "regulations". This is a perfect example of why we have and need to preserve regulations.

mahatmakanejeeves

(57,547 posts)
6. Thanks. I was just reading about this at Wikipedia. I figured you might
Sat Jun 15, 2019, 01:47 PM
Jun 2019

have a thread about it.

More:

A Spectacle of Horror – The Burning of the General Slocum

The deadliest disaster in New York before 9/11 killed many women and children and ultimately erased a German community from the map of Manhattan

By Gilbert King
SMITHSONIAN.COM
FEBRUARY 21, 2012

It was, by all accounts, a glorious Wednesday morning on June 15, 1904, and the men of Kleindeutschland—Little Germany, on Manhattan’s Lower East Side–were on their way to work. Just after 9 o’clock, a group from St. Mark’s Evangelical Lutheran Church on 6th Street, mostly women and children, boarded the General Slocum for their annual end-of-school outing. Bounding aboard what was billed as the “largest and most splendid excursion steamer in New York,” the children, dressed in their Sunday school outfits, shouted and waved flags as the adults followed, carrying picnic baskets for what was to be a long day away.

A German band played on deck while the children romped and the adults sang along, waiting to depart. Just before 10 o’clock, the lines were cast off, a bell rang in the engine room, and a deck hand reported to Captain William Van Schaick that nearly a thousand tickets had been collected at the plank. That number didn’t include the 300 children under the age of 10, who didn’t require tickets. Including crew and catering staff, there were about 1,350 aboard the General Slocum as it steamed up the East River at 15 knots toward Long Island Sound, headed for Locust Grove, a picnic ground on Long Island’s North Shore, about two hours away.

Built in 1891 and owned by the Knickerbocker Steamboat Company, the General Slocum was made of white oak, locust and yellow pine and licensed to carry 2,500 passengers. The ship carried that many life preservers, and just a month before a fire inspector had deemed its fire equipment to be in “fine working order.”

As the ship reached 97th Street, some of the crew on the lower deck saw puffs of smoke rising through the wooden floorboards and ran below to the second cabin. But the men had never conducted any fire drills, and when they turned the ship’s fire hoses onto the flames, the rotten hoses burst. Rushing back above deck, they told Van Schaick that they had encountered a “blaze that could not be conquered.” It was “like trying to put out hell itself.”
....



A Nightmare of New York – Frank McNally on the real-life maritime disaster that haunts James Joyce’s Ulysses

Fri, Jun 14, 2019, 18:30
....

By next day, word of the event had travelled across the Atlantic and newspapers, including this one, reported preliminary estimates of 500 dead. In fact, the official toll would be more than twice that, and it too was probably an underestimate.

In the meantime, of course, the story became part of the backdrop to James Joyce’s Ulysses. The epic novel transposes the mythology of Homer’s Odyssey – in which a shipwrecked hero struggles to find his way home after the Trojan War – to the mundane events of June 16th, 1904, in Dublin. But via the day’s news headlines, the real shipwreck in New York also haunts the characters at several points.

Leopold Bloom learns of it from the Freeman’s Journal and reflects on the horror in an internal monologue: “All those women and children excursion burned and drowned in New York. Holocaust.” Elsewhere, the smug Father Conmee worries mildly about the souls of the departed, Lutherans as they were: “In America those things were continually happening. Unfortunate people to die like that, unprepared. Still, an act of perfect contrition.”

Meanwhile, in a pub on James’s Street, Tom Kernan and the barman Crimmins between them summarise the worst aspects. “A thousand casualties. And heartrending scenes. Men trampling down women and children. Most brutal thing. What do they say was the cause? Spontaneous combustion? Most scandalous revelation. Not a single life-boat would float and the firehose all burst.”

But as they hint at the corruption behind it, the tragedy is already being filtered into cynical Dublinese: “What I can’t understand is how the inspectors ever allowed a boat like that … Now, you’re talking straight, Mr Crimmins. You know why? Palm oil. Is that a fact? Without a doubt. Well now, look at that. And America they say is the land of the free. I thought we were bad here.”

Dennis Donovan

(18,770 posts)
7. There was another steamboat disaster about 2 miles away from where I am now
Sat Jun 15, 2019, 06:58 PM
Jun 2019
https://www.fltimes.com/lifestyle/way-back-when-in-seneca-county-disaster-aboard-frontenac-steamship/article_37423d44-f77b-11e5-8f02-2ff6d6e8faf2.html

WAY BACK WHEN IN SENECA COUNTY: Disaster aboard Frontenac steamship



The Frontenac was the largest steamboat ever to operate on Cayuga Lake. It was built in 1870 by T.D. Wilcox of Ithaca for $50,000. It was a “side-wheeler” that was 135 feet long and had a 22-foot beam between the inside cases for the paddlewheels. As many as 350 passengers could be accommodated in her cabins, her decks and dining room.

Four years after Wilcox’s death, his heirs sold the Frontenac and the rest of Wilcox’s lake navigation business to the Cayuga Lake Transportation Co. In 1902, the Cayuga Lake Transportation Co. sold its business to Captain Melvin T. Brown of Syracuse. Brown had parts of the steamboat’s wooden structure rebuilt, and in the spring of 1907 installed new boilers on the ship at a cost of $5,000. In June 1907, the annual state-required inspection of the Frontenac prompted state inspectors Van Keuren and Welling to pronounce the boat “seaworthy and safe against all accidents due to construction.”

The regular schedule of the Frontenac in 1907 was to depart Ithaca at 9 a.m. and proceed north, making 10 to 12 stops before arriving at Cayuga Landing about 1:15 p.m. Then the Frontenac would leave Cayuga Landing at 3:45 p.m. and cross the lake to Cayuga Lake Park and then make stops on the way back to Ithaca, arriving at about 8:10 p.m. This time schedule could be upset, however, by rough weather. Sometimes, the Frontenac would be used for a special excursion group, necessitating the use of one of Brown’s smaller steamers (such as the Mohawk or the Iroquois) to operate on the regular schedule for that day.

It was a special excursion that kept the Frontenac overnight at Cayuga Landing on Friday, July 26, 1907. The next morning, the Frontenac left Cayuga Landing carrying the passengers that were originally scheduled to be on the Mohawk, met the northbound Mohawk at Sheldrake and exchanged passengers, so as to get both boats back on their normal schedules. The Frontenac then proceeded back north with about 60 passengers, Captain Brown and a crew of five men and one woman. The pilot was Albert E. Smith of Ithaca; the chief engineer was Howard Bachman of Seneca Falls. As the boat proceeded north, there was rough water. Captain Brown reported that “the waves were high and the wind was blowing a gale.” The rough water caused the boat not to make its scheduled stops at Aurora and Levanna, at the lake’s widest part. As the boat proceeded toward Farley’s Point, people on shore — such as James Harris — could see the boat was on fire and emergency help would be needed.

<snip>

The Frontenac had grounded near a section of the east shore known as Dill’s Cove, just north of Farley’s Point and about 2.5 miles south of the village of Union Springs. Five women and two children died.

A coroner’s inquest on Monday, July 29, concluded “that the loss of life could not have been prevented by any act of the crew.” The coroner exonerated the captain and crew and said, “They were brave, cool-headed fellows, and did far more under all the circumstances than many others would have done. They are not only entitled to exoneration, but the highest praise.” The inquest report said the fire “which caused the burning of the steamer Frontenac was caused by some unknown source which could not be ascertained by examination of passengers and crew.”



<snip>


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»115 Years Ago Today; Excu...