Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mcar

(42,334 posts)
Wed Jul 3, 2019, 07:27 PM Jul 2019

Pierce: Once Upon a Time, These Photos Would Have Sent the Whole Country Aflame

Once Upon a Time, These Photos Would Have Sent the Whole Country Aflame

The government is holding thousands of immigrants in "ticking time-bombs" at the border—according to reports from Trump's own government.

BY CHARLES P. PIERCE
JUL 3, 2019

Time was when information as damning as that released on Tuesday by the Inspector General of the Department of Homeland Security—whether an official government report, or testimony by a whistleblower, or by the dogged work of investigative journalists—would set the country aflame. It's what Upton Sinclair did with meat-packing and Ida Tarbell did with Standard Oil. It was what happened when Life published the photos of one week's worth of American dead in Vietnam, and when the first photos of the slaughter at My Lai appeared. You could see through the country as though it were one of those transparent figures from high-school biology. You could stare into its viscera and find it unrecognizable as the body of the country in which you thought you'd been living.

The IG's report, complete with pictures, is unsparing in its conclusion and brutal in its truth. We are running along our southern border a desert-bound gulag of what are indeed concentration camps, if that phrase has any meaning at all. ...

In addition, over the past week, thanks to ProPublica, we discovered that the Border Patrol is shot through with armed officers who believe the people in their charge to be less than human. Members of Congress have been roughed up trying to inspect these hellholes, and they have been greeted by well-organized hecklers when they emerged. There are parallels in history....

The people running the facilities on the border told the IG's inspectors that these camps are "ticking time bombs." I'd take their word for it....

It's the week of the Fourth of July, which means that Founder Worship is going to be at high tide for a few days. One thing of which the Founders were sure was that America was going to be such a beacon of freedom that people from all over the world were going to want to come here. The Declaration of Independence cited as one part of its bill of indictment against George III that he'd restricted immigration to the American colonies. The Constitution specifically forbade the passage of any law restricting immigration for the first 20 years of the country's existence. Pick a Founder. They all talked about it....

McAllen and Clint are going to live in the memory of the people confined there, and of their descendants, for decade upon decade. Sooner or later, of course, this country will decide even more firmly than it does now that these people brought these horrors on themselves by "breaking the law." That is the way empires think, especially dying ones.

https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a28277138/migrant-detention-facilities-inspector-general-report/

16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Pierce: Once Upon a Time, These Photos Would Have Sent the Whole Country Aflame (Original Post) mcar Jul 2019 OP
Maybe, maybe not misanthrope Jul 2019 #1
The magic of incrementalism PSPS Jul 2019 #2
Great post and so true. Hard to believe. We have Fox and Murdoch to thank for this. Pepsidog Jul 2019 #6
+1 dalton99a Jul 2019 #13
Excellent post! nt The_jackalope Jul 2019 #16
K&R UTUSN Jul 2019 #3
KnR Hekate Jul 2019 #4
This post strangely lacks photos lame54 Jul 2019 #5
Posting some of the photos from the article iluvtennis Jul 2019 #7
Sorry mcar Jul 2019 #8
once upon a time trump could not have been 'elected' 'president' spanone Jul 2019 #9
Whoever replaces him will have a tough job mcar Jul 2019 #10
it's going to be tough with all the judges trump has appointed across the nation spanone Jul 2019 #11
That always was my biggest concern mcar Jul 2019 #12
he is a coward and liar bdamomma Jul 2019 #14
He wasn't elected the Russians helped him uponit7771 Jul 2019 #15

misanthrope

(7,418 posts)
1. Maybe, maybe not
Wed Jul 3, 2019, 08:06 PM
Jul 2019

Not in the 1940s when American citizens of Japanese ancestry were herded up and locked into camps.

Not when two centuries of terror, destruction and execution -- including bombing from the air -- were visited upon African Americans.

Not when we forced indigenous people from their ancestral lands, then waged biological and outright warfare on them because we wanted them out of our way.

PSPS

(13,601 posts)
2. The magic of incrementalism
Wed Jul 3, 2019, 08:16 PM
Jul 2019

You are subjected to one outrage after another, but each is calibrated to be short of the tipping point. After a while, people look around and think, "how the hell did we get to this?" Hitler did it. Trump is doing it now.

We've already graduated through the election rigging, roving gangs of political thugs beating up journalists and others, bombs sent to critics, politically-motivated mass shootings, I really don't care do u, looting the treasury, glad-handing murderous dictators, secret kremlin meetings, bone saws, destroyed translator's notes, midnight calls to putin, ignoring subpoenas, foreign agents roaming freely throughout government, neutering the justice department, shutting down the senate, "acting" heads of departments to escape scrutiny, improper security clearances, family members openly working against the country's interests, tanks in the streets, and the list goes on. Each one provokes an outrage but, apparently, not quite enough for anything to be done about it. Each step makes the next one easier. If you want to step up to the top of a 10-foot wall, you won't do it in one step. You must take smaller steps. Those are easy and will get you up there.

We're at the concentration camp stage now. You can't equate them with the likes of Buchenwald, at least not yet. There are no ovens, "showers" that are gas chambers, or machine guns. At least not yet. Innocent people are still dying at our hands, though. Cram enough of them together typhus will do the job for you, thanks to the lice fostered by the withholding of sanitary facilities. Actually, any communicable disease will do because there are no medical services.

This is a really important step because this involves outright lawlessness, cruelty and sadism. This may cause a little more outrage, but it, too, will evaporate. They're foreigners, after all. They chose to be here. They can always go back, they say. But the critical boundary has been breached. The steps ahead of us expand further into this world of lawlessness, cruelty and sadism that would never have been possible without these camps.

Ahead of us lie the steps where this "new normal" of lawlessness, cruelty and sadism creeps into everything like a rising tide. Each step ahead will become easier because the "incremental" change is just under the flash point that will trigger action, and the top of that wall gets closer and closer until, finally, there you are. You've made it. What will it be like? To quote a line from a scene in Star Trek The Next Generation:

PICARD on the Enterprise: "Number One. What is it? What do you see?"
RIKER on the planet below: "I don't know, Captain. But it's not good."

mcar

(42,334 posts)
8. Sorry
Thu Jul 4, 2019, 09:40 AM
Jul 2019

Been here since 2002 and still haven't figured out how to post photos.

I presumed we'd seen them elsewhere or could go to the link.

spanone

(135,844 posts)
11. it's going to be tough with all the judges trump has appointed across the nation
Thu Jul 4, 2019, 09:44 AM
Jul 2019

We will have his rancid stench long after he's gone

mcar

(42,334 posts)
12. That always was my biggest concern
Thu Jul 4, 2019, 09:46 AM
Jul 2019

That, and the environment. In 2016, I was gobsmacked at how many supposed Democrats said the courts weren't a big issue.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Pierce: Once Upon a Time,...