Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
61 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Read this Alexander Hamilton quote from 1792. You might want to sit down first. (Original Post) kpete Jul 2019 OP
Real truth transcends time...nt Wounded Bear Jul 2019 #1
Only thing wrong there is malaise Jul 2019 #2
Could persistent and unashamed lying be considered a talent? tymorial Jul 2019 #5
Hehehehehehhe malaise Jul 2019 #10
Oh he has considerable talent. nolabear Jul 2019 #12
Now I want to read it malaise Jul 2019 #13
Bradbury was such an influence on me when I was a kid. nolabear Jul 2019 #14
Also, in the full quote, he describes the tyrant as "having the advantage of military habits". n/t sl8 Jul 2019 #16
Good spot malaise Jul 2019 #21
"having the advantage of military habits crazytown Jul 2019 #33
He is an accomplished con man... n/t radical noodle Jul 2019 #38
Just a polite question. Can not talents also be to do evil as well as good? olegramps Jul 2019 #42
You can see my granny's influence on me malaise Jul 2019 #45
I not here to correct anyone and fully realize that you held this view prior to the post. olegramps Jul 2019 #59
Once ensnared by such nastiness few deplorables will change without intense deprogramming. BSdetect Jul 2019 #3
How poignant for the times we are living in... ProudMNDemocrat Jul 2019 #4
Love it. (nt) Paladin Jul 2019 #6
It may have taken 227 years, but here we are. AJT Jul 2019 #7
Yes, it can be fit into the present circumstances but it sort of twists the original thrust pecosbob Jul 2019 #8
Our founding fathers understood this UpInArms Jul 2019 #9
They certainly did understand this. calimary Jul 2019 #18
Well, Congress Too Cheviteau Jul 2019 #49
Iirc, Hamilton wrote Federalist 68 lonely bird Jul 2019 #56
K&R Gothmog Jul 2019 #11
Source: sl8 Jul 2019 #15
Perspective and context. Duppers Jul 2019 #46
De nada. n/t sl8 Jul 2019 #55
Now Might Be RobinA Jul 2019 #17
Gives a whole meaning to an old saying - "everything old is new again." calimary Jul 2019 #20
+ 1 Raastan Jul 2019 #58
Kicked and recommended Uncle Joe Jul 2019 #19
Unfortunately most Trump supporters TNNurse Jul 2019 #22
or even have a clue as to what the Federalists Papers were. Required reading for high school IMO. YOHABLO Jul 2019 #34
Or they read it and immediately think it's about Obama. progressoid Jul 2019 #40
Copy and Paste is not working for me today. saidsimplesimon Jul 2019 #23
Wow! But I need to add, the super villians here are McConnell and the 1% Auggie Jul 2019 #24
Even more importantly are the MILLIONS and MILLIONS of American citizens Cosmocat Jul 2019 #27
Folks following their group morals ... Auggie Jul 2019 #30
I just can't get past it Cosmocat Jul 2019 #36
Yes, I understand ... Auggie Jul 2019 #37
Well, he had a crystal ball! Thanks for sharing!❤ Karadeniz Jul 2019 #25
Hamilton could not predict the Russians hacking elections... Sancho Jul 2019 #26
There are hundreds of things the founding fathers could never have imagined. But they were brilliant YOHABLO Jul 2019 #35
The man was a prophet. KatyaR Jul 2019 #28
I always like your posts. Thing is, someone who mounts that ol' hobby horse of PatrickforO Jul 2019 #29
We can only hope you are right Patrick. It appears KPN Jul 2019 #31
Founding Fathers were well versed in history bucolic_frolic Jul 2019 #32
I did not know Alexander Hamilton possessed a time machine Brother Buzz Jul 2019 #39
It seems he was either a time traveler, or possibly psychic FakeNoose Jul 2019 #41
Had he been a psychic, he would have avoided Burr. Marcuse Jul 2019 #54
He wrote it BHDem53 Jul 2019 #43
Good one, LOL Nt lostnfound Jul 2019 #57
Burning down the house and then laughing about it... czarjak Jul 2019 #44
"Trumpbillies" Duppers Jul 2019 #47
What does this say about human nature? Duppers Jul 2019 #48
This Is Too Judgemental RobinA Jul 2019 #61
Even more remarkable Stargleamer Jul 2019 #50
I have the abridged version up on the bulletin board at work for all to see. To the tRUMPER I said UniteFightBack Jul 2019 #51
Somebody must have translated that Turbineguy Jul 2019 #52
They were intelligent and well-educated men of their time, & well understood human history Hekate Jul 2019 #53
Unfortunately, demagogues often have ready believers. olegramps Jul 2019 #60

nolabear

(41,987 posts)
12. Oh he has considerable talent.
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 11:40 AM
Jul 2019

He is the reason the term “blarney” was created, and has the low cunning of the professional con artist, the tent revivalist, the sideshow barker. I’ve got a lifelong fascination with those people, which frankly he’s soured a bit because we can’t walk away or get behind the curtain.

Ever read Ray Bradbury’s “The Jar”? I think of it often these days.

nolabear

(41,987 posts)
14. Bradbury was such an influence on me when I was a kid.
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 12:01 PM
Jul 2019

He knew how to turn psychological reality into fantasy better than almost anybody.

sl8

(13,797 posts)
16. Also, in the full quote, he describes the tyrant as "having the advantage of military habits". n/t
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 12:29 PM
Jul 2019

malaise

(269,057 posts)
45. You can see my granny's influence on me
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 05:52 PM
Jul 2019

Clearly you are right and I am wrong - talent is talent for good or evil.

olegramps

(8,200 posts)
59. I not here to correct anyone and fully realize that you held this view prior to the post.
Tue Jul 9, 2019, 10:43 AM
Jul 2019

Sometimes I just don't state the obvious. Have a nice day, week, year and life time.

ProudMNDemocrat

(16,786 posts)
4. How poignant for the times we are living in...
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 10:45 AM
Jul 2019

I was at my Annual Science Fiction/Fantasy convention this past weekend. Attending were numerous women dressed in the Handmaiden's Tale ensembles. As I processed them through Registration as they picked up their Badges, I said to many of them..."You are dress appropriately for the times we are living in." Many replied, "Amen sister." They gave me high 5's.

pecosbob

(7,541 posts)
8. Yes, it can be fit into the present circumstances but it sort of twists the original thrust
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 10:51 AM
Jul 2019

If anything, Hamilton was a proponent of centralized authority and despised true democracy. His fears were of a popular revolt against the moneyed classes by the mob such as had occurred in France. He certainly wasn't afraid of the propertied class hijacking the entire government for their own purposes...that was the reality of that period. The moneyed class wrote the laws and interpreted them. It's always been about money.

UpInArms

(51,284 posts)
9. Our founding fathers understood this
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 10:55 AM
Jul 2019

It has only been in the rise of ideological tyranny .. ie the partisan republicans... and the willingness of congress to cede its oversight role ... that we have become an endangered country

Cheviteau

(383 posts)
49. Well, Congress Too
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 07:05 PM
Jul 2019

It was more of the Electoral College ceding its oversight that has brought us to the mess we find ourselves today. The founders put the Electoral College in place to protect our republic from the rubes (uneducated, bigots, haters, cowards) that vote for men like Trump. I was never in favor of direct elections for president, but I've changed my mind. It's time for amending the Ol'charter.

lonely bird

(1,687 posts)
56. Iirc, Hamilton wrote Federalist 68
Tue Jul 9, 2019, 07:57 AM
Jul 2019

His explanation for the electoral college and support thereof were incorrect. Prior to primaries the parties picked their nominees in a variety of smoke-filled rooms will horse trading deals. While this was not arbitrarily bad the end result was a lot of presidents who were less than up to the job. Basically the electoral college was a sap to the slave states. Now with primaries we have basically beauty contests prior to the election. Was the old way better or this way? Since the electorate can be counted on to be imbecilic it is difficult to determine.

sl8

(13,797 posts)
15. Source:
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 12:21 PM
Jul 2019

The quote comes from Hamilton's response to a letter sent to him by George Washington.

Letter from Washington to Hamilton:
https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-12-02-0104

From https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-12-02-0184-0002#ARHN-01-12-02-0184-0002-fn-0005


[Emphsis added to highlight portions in Twitter quote]
[...]

Objection XIV The ultimate object of all

To this there is no other answer than a flat denial—except this that the project from its absurdity refutes itself.

The idea of introducing a monarchy or aristocracy into this Country, by employing the influence and force of a Government continually changing hands, towards it, is one of those visionary things, that none but madmen could meditate and that no wise men will believe.

If it could be done at all, which is utterly incredible, it would require a long series of time, certainly beyond the life of any individual to effect it. Who then would enter into such plot? For what purpose of interest or ambition?

To hope that the people may be cajoled into giving their sanctions to such institutions is still more chimerical. A people so enlightened and so diversified45 as the people of this Country can surely never be brought to it, but from convulsions and disorders,46 in consequence of the acts of popular demagogues.

The truth unquestionably is, that the only path to a subversion of the republican system of the Country is, by flattering the prejudices of the people, and exciting their jealousies and apprehensions, to throw affairs into confusion, and bring on civil commotion. Tired at length of anarchy, or want of government, they may take shelter in the arms of monarchy for repose and security.

Those then, who resist a confirmation of public order, are the true Artificers of monarchy—not that this is the intention of the generality of them. Yet it would not be difficult to lay the finger upon some of their party who may justly be suspected. When a man unprincipled in private life desperate in his fortune, bold in his temper, possessed of considerable talents, having the advantage of military habits—despotic in his ordinary demeanour—known to have scoffed in private at the principles of liberty—when such a man is seen to mount the hobby horse of popularity—to join in the cry of danger to liberty—to take every opportunity of embarrassing the General Government & bringing it under suspicion—to flatter and fall in with all the non sense of the zealots of the day—It may justly be suspected that his object is to throw things into confusion that he may “ride the storm and direct the whirlwind.”

It has aptly been observed that Cato was the Tory-Cæsar the whig of his day. The former frequently resisted—the latter always flattered the follies of the people. Yet the former perished with the Republic the latter destroyed it.

No popular Government was ever without its Catalines & its Cæsars. These are its true enemies.

As far as I am informed the anxiety of those who are calumniated is to keep the Government in the state in which it is, which they fear will be no easy task, from a natural tendency in the state of things to exalt the local on the ruins of the National Government. Some of them appear to wish, in a constitutional way, a change in the judiciary department of the Government, from an apprehension that an orderly and effectual administration of Justice cannot be obtained without a more intimate connection between the state and national Tribunals. But even this is not an object of any set of men as a party. There is a difference of opinion about it on various grounds among those who have generally acted together. As to any other change of consequence, I believe nobody dreams of it.

Tis curious to observe the anticipations of the different parties. One side appears to believe that there is a serious plot to overturn the state Governments and substitute monarchy to the present republican system. The other side firmly believes that there is a serious plot to overturn the General Government & elevate the separate power of the states upon its ruins. Both sides may be equally wrong & their mutual jealousies may be materially causes of the appearances which mutually disturb them, and sharpen them against each other.

[...]

RobinA

(9,894 posts)
17. Now Might Be
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 12:34 PM
Jul 2019

a good time for interested people to read or reread The Federalist Papers, as the writers were very afraid of many of the things that we see happening today. The Founders did a good deal of research into what had caused other government systems to fail catastrophically and tried to avoid many of the same problems. Successfully so far and unsuccessfully, depending on the situation. Humans being humans, however, they were as accurate in their worries today as they were 230 years ago.

TNNurse

(6,927 posts)
22. Unfortunately most Trump supporters
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 12:48 PM
Jul 2019

do not have the education or vocabulary to understand the meaning in this statement,

 

YOHABLO

(7,358 posts)
34. or even have a clue as to what the Federalists Papers were. Required reading for high school IMO.
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 02:50 PM
Jul 2019

Auggie

(31,173 posts)
24. Wow! But I need to add, the super villians here are McConnell and the 1%
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 12:57 PM
Jul 2019

Last edited Mon Jul 8, 2019, 01:39 PM - Edit history (1)

Trump is their hatchett man -- their tool and diversion.

It's a dark money cabal, led by Trump, McConnell's GOP, and oligarchs of the world. These are the true enemies of American democracy.

Cosmocat

(14,566 posts)
27. Even more importantly are the MILLIONS and MILLIONS of American citizens
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 01:02 PM
Jul 2019

who for some inexplicable reason ENTHUSIASTICALLY eat the shit sandwich the GOP, conservative media, 45, McConnell and every other elected republicans serves up to them.

This shit is STONE cold obvious.

The complete suspension of common sense, decency and civility by our friends and neighbors is beyond any reason.

Auggie

(31,173 posts)
30. Folks following their group morals ...
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 01:49 PM
Jul 2019

This book, The Righteous Mind: Why Good People are Divided by Politics and Religion (2012), gives incredible perspective as to why so many people act and vote the way do.

It's an awesome read. Are you familiar with it? https://righteousmind.com

And yes, while enough of them voted for Trump, too many didn't bother to vote for Clinton, or voted for Gary Johnson, or didn't vote at all. They may have hated Trump, but they did help to elect him.

But I don't hold these people in contempt. They're just acting like silly, emotional humans. That isn't going to change.

Cosmocat

(14,566 posts)
36. I just can't get past it
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 03:14 PM
Jul 2019

You and I am not possessed of greater intellect or some kind of superpowers to see through this shit.

It is all plain as day.

I have to live with people and find a way to wall it off.

45 does not bother me in the least, he is what he is.

But, I can't get past how absurd it is that otherwise seemingly decent people so gleefully vote R.

Auggie

(31,173 posts)
37. Yes, I understand ...
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 04:11 PM
Jul 2019

it's mind-boggling. But I found that book I mentioned helped me gain some insight. My friends too.

Sancho

(9,070 posts)
26. Hamilton could not predict the Russians hacking elections...
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 01:01 PM
Jul 2019

...and the traitors who would help them for money.

Otherwise, Hamilton was on target.

 

YOHABLO

(7,358 posts)
35. There are hundreds of things the founding fathers could never have imagined. But they were brilliant
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 02:55 PM
Jul 2019

This is why the Constitution is a living document. Although to amend is hard to do, we could definitely tweak a thing or two.

PatrickforO

(14,578 posts)
29. I always like your posts. Thing is, someone who mounts that ol' hobby horse of
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 01:41 PM
Jul 2019

popularity and seeks to 'direct the whirlwind,' more often than not reaps that very same whirlwind.

I think that will ultimately happen to Trump and ripple among those around him.

KPN

(15,646 posts)
31. We can only hope you are right Patrick. It appears
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 02:12 PM
Jul 2019

that only our vote can make this so. Let’s hope and GOTV.

bucolic_frolic

(43,190 posts)
32. Founding Fathers were well versed in history
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 02:13 PM
Jul 2019

and probably read more than 99% of Americans today. They read Gibbon, knew all about the fall of Rome, and studied Locke, Montesquieu, Hobbes, Machiavelli, the Glorious Revolution, the Enlightenment, Rousseau, and probably many theologians. They knew human nature better than most. That Hamilton might make such an observation reflected the age in which he lived.

FakeNoose

(32,645 posts)
41. It seems he was either a time traveler, or possibly psychic
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 04:39 PM
Jul 2019

In a way I find this very reassuring, don't you agree? We can trust the original framers of the Constitution for their awesome judgment. They couldn't foresee everything, but they got a lot right.

czarjak

(11,278 posts)
44. Burning down the house and then laughing about it...
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 05:32 PM
Jul 2019

Is the plan I’ve heard from three different Trumpbillies.

RobinA

(9,894 posts)
61. This Is Too Judgemental
Tue Jul 9, 2019, 11:48 AM
Jul 2019

We are tribal chimps who do what we believe is necessary to ensure our survival and that of our genes. I don't like dividing our instincts into positive and negative. They are simply instincts. Sometimes the result of them is positive and sometimes it is negative.

Stargleamer

(1,989 posts)
50. Even more remarkable
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 10:28 PM
Jul 2019

is that he wrote all this while in the baggage claim area waiting for his luggage!

 

UniteFightBack

(8,231 posts)
51. I have the abridged version up on the bulletin board at work for all to see. To the tRUMPER I said
Mon Jul 8, 2019, 10:30 PM
Jul 2019

who put that quote up there? And he said I know you did....then I said no truer words huh? And he has nothing to say but he admitted a few weeks ago that rump is doing a 'terrible job'.

olegramps

(8,200 posts)
60. Unfortunately, demagogues often have ready believers.
Tue Jul 9, 2019, 11:33 AM
Jul 2019

I see two groups who are quick to grasp at their propaganda. The wealthy who see it as an opportunity to enhance their grasp on power and money and the ill informed who are looking for scapegoats to blame for their failure to adequately prepare themselves. The fact of the matter is that the industrial revolution provided millions of well paying jobs for people with a minimal education. People who could barely read or write could find gainful employment doing rote jobs.

Increasingly, more advanced robotics will put those who were exploited due to low standards of living will be in jeopardy as wages become lesser of a factor in production. Another factor is demographics that is often ignored, but can be the most important criteria for future societies. For example an article in the July/August issue of "Foreign Affairs" reveals some critical information. China's great leap forward was made possible because of two factors.

Deng Xiaoping's market orientated policies that stimulated the entire economy and favorable demographics. Between 1975 and 2010 China's working age population doubled and coupled with Deng's policies led to a rapid increase in wealth and education. However, the future is less than rosy. The fertility rate is now 1.4 to 1.6 well below the replacement level of 2.1. In some major cities it is under 1.0. China's population will soon peak and begin a dramatic down spiral. The working age population will rapidly diminish by at least 100 million between 2015 and 2040. Its over 65 age population will explode and rise during the same period from 135 million to 325 million. The situation will be acerbated by their drastic one child policy that resulted in the abortion of girls in favor or male children. The result is ten of millions of male without prospects of marriage.

The situation for the United States is dramatically healthier with a positive replacement ration with resulting improvements in every category, health, education, employment, etc. I will not trouble with all the statistics, buy to conclude that the United States' future is very favorable. I would encourage anyone to read the article for detailed information.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Read this Alexander Hamil...