General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDo I trust the ME in the Epstein alleged suicide case?
Completely.
I also know she is working with limited information from which she has to decide between only two things
a. suicide
b. strangulation or death by another means made to look like hanging
Absent eye witness testimony that someone else was in the cell (we know the cameras were off, werent they? guards not paying attention etc) she has to make a decision.
Even though she found injuries consistent with strangulation, ABSENT supporting evidence, what choice does she have? None, she cant say it was strangulation without more evidence.
Doesnt mean he wasnt murdered, just means the other evidence she would need is not there, and WHERE or HOW many times have we heard THAT in the last 3 years!
Now if there was a camera on him the entire time, this would be simple,wouldnt it. But for some strange reason, there wasnt, or the eyes of a guard, but again...no.
For instance Mueller says there is no evidence of a conspiracy, well we all know there is a conspiracy but since he cant get witnesses to tell the truth, then he cant get the evidence he needs to prove it.
triron
(22,008 posts)dflprincess
(28,080 posts)Preponderance of evidence does not point to natural, accidental, murder, or suicide, they also have the option of "undetermined" .
Eliot Rosewater
(31,112 posts)undetermined.
I believe he was murdered and I believe she had no choice but to come to this conclusion the same way Mueller said since he couldnt get witnesses to tell the truth he could not get evidence of conspiracy.
dflprincess
(28,080 posts)if they did not feel think most the evidence pointed to the manner they chose. Not just in this case, but in any case & for any of the manners listed.
I used to know a forensic pathologist with the local ME's office and she would talk in general terms about cases where there is suspcion of a murder or suicide but no concrete proof. If an ME calls a murder an accident, natural causes, or suicide, it can be very difficult for the prosecutor to bring a case should new evidence arrive. As a rule, for the family's sake (though maybe not in this case), the M.E. doesn't want to call a death a suicide if it was not. In cases like that, "undetermined" is the best option.
I am skeptical in this case. Epstein may indeed have hanged himself, but I can't help believe he had some excellent help making it look like that & that may be what led the doctor to her conclusion. And, just to add a little tinfoil, we don't know what pressures may have been brought to bear to list a manner of death.
jmg257
(11,996 posts)Maybe thats why she chose a?
Seems reasonable.
Eliot Rosewater
(31,112 posts)jmg257
(11,996 posts)The Velveteen Ocelot
(115,777 posts)Suicidal hanging doesn't have to be from the ceiling. All it takes is something you can wrap around your neck, including your own clothing, and you can hang yourself by tying the other end of your "noose" to anything in the cell. You can hang yourself in a kneeling position if you're determined enough, and it actually happens pretty often in prisons. Epstein had experienced a life of great wealth, luxury and debauchery for years, but he was now facing the fact that he would spend the rest of his life in prison, probably isolated from the rest of the population. He was a narcissist, and narcissists commonly commit suicide when they fall from grace.
Occam's razor. The more assumptions you have to make to support a theory, the less likely it is to be correct.
chowder66
(9,074 posts)mcar
(42,340 posts)Eliot Rosewater
(31,112 posts)But the russian mob could have killed him, an american based mob could have, hell the GOP could have arranged it for all we know.
His death CHANGES EVERYTHING, dershowitz and rump and others were going DOWN, believe it.
mcar
(42,340 posts)The DOJ, I fear, won't do theirs.
Eliot Rosewater
(31,112 posts)her trying to do her job.
Like Mueller, can only work with what they have.
mcar
(42,340 posts)People really shouldn't criticize her.
triron
(22,008 posts)The Velveteen Ocelot
(115,777 posts)whenever there is a death under unusual, suspicious or undetermined circumstances. SOP in any medical examiner's office.
Srkdqltr
(6,307 posts)The ME... she has more experience then you guys who are second guessing with no evidence at all.
Just trashing her.
NutmegYankee
(16,200 posts)While is the bone injury found is very common in strangulation, it's also observed in a decent percentage of suicidal hangings.
brush
(53,801 posts)Eliot Rosewater
(31,112 posts)good one
triron
(22,008 posts)Eliot Rosewater
(31,112 posts)because NOTHING else makes sense. I know it as I know rump did NOT win those 4 states, he had help on election day. No, cant prove it, but I am sure of it.
I am amazed how many are accepting this, sad even.
AGAIN the ME did what she could with the limited evidence she had.