Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 01:22 PM Oct 2019

There Are Only Four Ways a President Leaves Office Unwillingly

1. Impeachment and Removal by Congress - This is a very difficult thing to accomplish. So far, in our history, no President has been removed from office through Congressional action.

2. Action under the 25th Amendment - This must be initiated by the President, or the Vice-President and a majority of the current Cabinet. The President, in the second case, can object and resume office. Only a 2/3 vote of both houses of Congress can reverse the President's decision. The 25th Amendment has never been used to remove a President.

3. Failure to be re-elected after a first term in office - This common method of removing a President is the simplest way to do so. It is the most popular method, because of that fact.

4. Death - Presidents have died in office, either of natural causes or by assassination. Historically, death has been the second most common cause of a president leaving office unwillingly.

That's it. Presidents can also leave office in a couple of other ways, but they do not involve an unwilling President being forced out of office.

A President can only serve two terms in office, so any President is automatically removed after the second term, willing or not. Since that is a constitutional process, a President's willingness or unwillingness is irrelevant. The Constitutional Amendment putting this limit in place was created after FDR served multiple terms in office.

A President can also resign from office. That rarely happens, because Presidents generally enjoy holding that office. Richard Nixon is a good example, though. He resigned to avoid the impeachment and removal process. By definition, though, resignation is an action taken by the President, rather than an involuntary removal from office.

35 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
There Are Only Four Ways a President Leaves Office Unwillingly (Original Post) MineralMan Oct 2019 OP
and acting cabinet officials have no vote in 25th amendment scenario. nt Grasswire2 Oct 2019 #1
Do you have a cite or link saying acting cabinet secretaries are not "principal officers" onenote Oct 2019 #35
Any of those methods would be just fine with me. The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2019 #2
Number 3 is the most likely. And that's one we can all help make happen. MineralMan Oct 2019 #3
i think they should continue with the impeachment investigation, The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2019 #5
Absolutely. Show voters how dangerous he is and what he's up to. lagomorph777 Oct 2019 #15
Trump won't resign LeftInTX Oct 2019 #24
What about (space) alien abduction? Cirque du So-What Oct 2019 #4
Would they even want him for probing? The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2019 #9
I think if abducted by aliens it still requires 25th action to say he can't perform Takket Oct 2019 #17
5. swat team and in handcuffs. nt Javaman Oct 2019 #6
You realize that such a thing cannot happen, right? MineralMan Oct 2019 #7
It's silly but it's fun to think about anyhow. The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2019 #8
When it comes to political realities, I don't do fantasy. MineralMan Oct 2019 #10
I do, because it's fun. I can do reality and fantasy at the same time. The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2019 #11
I'm sorry my comment was a waste of your time. Javaman Oct 2019 #25
Gotta laugh these days to keep from crying. I'm with you. The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2019 #26
Yes, time for fun and games is long past! at140 Oct 2019 #29
I see a lot of that here. cwydro Oct 2019 #12
Yes. All sorts of wild-eyed ideas get tossed around here. MineralMan Oct 2019 #16
I suppose some find it funny, and some may even believe these loony theories. cwydro Oct 2019 #22
As I understand 2 the process can keep going exboyfil Oct 2019 #13
Yes. If it comes to push or shove, the 25th Amendment doesn't work very well. MineralMan Oct 2019 #14
It's never been used. I think it was intentionally designed to be very difficult to implement The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2019 #20
There's really no way to use it, unless the VP is on board, and MineralMan Oct 2019 #21
I wonder if a president fearing 25th amendment action could fire his entire cabinet tritsofme Oct 2019 #31
"Nuttier than squirrel poop" !!! cwydro Oct 2019 #23
4 is not always unwilling n/t FreeState Oct 2019 #18
Really? Which President died of suicide? MineralMan Oct 2019 #19
um. ok. Lib 4 Life Oct 2019 #27
Item #3 is the best approach to removing Trump from office..eom at140 Oct 2019 #28
voluntary resignation gopiscrap Oct 2019 #30
5) Hops on a plane to Moscow... tinrobot Oct 2019 #32
But here in the real world. We win in 2020 or he serves till 2024. GulfCoast66 Oct 2019 #33
Exactly. So, we need to be focused on that. MineralMan Oct 2019 #34

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,734 posts)
2. Any of those methods would be just fine with me.
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 01:26 PM
Oct 2019

And the sooner, the better. Fat Nixon wrecks something every day he's squatting in our house.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
3. Number 3 is the most likely. And that's one we can all help make happen.
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 01:30 PM
Oct 2019

Why we are not spending most of our time on that, I do not understand. The next Presidential election is just over a year away. That is the method I recommend, and it's also the most reliable one.

However, I also recommend pursuing the impeachment and removal option, even if removal is highly unlikely. That process can trigger a resignation.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,734 posts)
5. i think they should continue with the impeachment investigation,
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 01:34 PM
Oct 2019

even with the understanding that it probably won't result in a conviction, because the evidence that it uncovers is likely to influence public opinion before the election. Nixon won every state but Massachusetts in the 1972 election and started his second term with an approval rating in the 60+% range. By the time he resigned after the Watergate investigations it was about 25%. But obviously the best hope is to defeat Fat Nixon's ugly orange ass in 2020, and every effort should be made to be sure that happens - but while the House keeps turning over rocks.

At the same time, we can hope he keeps gorging himself on Big Macs and KFC just to improve the chances of one of the other outcomes.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,734 posts)
9. Would they even want him for probing?
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 01:44 PM
Oct 2019

Sounds like a process too disgusting even for space aliens. On the other hand, if he was chosen for probing maybe they'd be so grossed out they'd go away and never bother Earth again.

Takket

(21,577 posts)
17. I think if abducted by aliens it still requires 25th action to say he can't perform
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 02:49 PM
Oct 2019

Presidential duties. Until then he is still the president.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
7. You realize that such a thing cannot happen, right?
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 01:36 PM
Oct 2019

What SWAT team? From what jurisdiction? Your idea is just plain silly.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,734 posts)
8. It's silly but it's fun to think about anyhow.
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 01:43 PM
Oct 2019

My fantasy involves psych hospital personnel trundling him out of the WH on a hand truck, wrapped up in a straightjacket and wearing a hockey mask like Hannibal Lecter. That's not going to happen either, but it's an entertaining vision.

at140

(6,110 posts)
29. Yes, time for fun and games is long past!
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 08:59 PM
Oct 2019

The only serious method which has the best chance of removing Trump is uniting behind who ever will be the democratic nominee and work your bottom off to help her/him get elected.

 

cwydro

(51,308 posts)
12. I see a lot of that here.
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 02:06 PM
Oct 2019

Let me see: the orange ass will be removed and Hillary will be be installed as the rightful president, Pelosi is going to become president, he’ll be arrested in the White House and frogmarched to the pokey, the 25th will be invoked, then there are the many, many theories regarding death by stroke, heart attack, syphilis, drug overdose....

I’ve seen all that and more here on a startlingly regular basis.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
16. Yes. All sorts of wild-eyed ideas get tossed around here.
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 02:46 PM
Oct 2019

They waste our time and have nothing to do with reality.

Reality is hard. It has rules and steps one has to go through. For impatient people, such rules are ridiculous. So, they come up with cockamamie ideas that are even more ridiculous.

It's very frustrating, since we have real methods that can be used. Personally, I think the 2020 election is how we'll get rid of Trump, so we need to be focused on winning that election. One way or another there will be an election for President next November. That's certain, so why not work on that, where we can actually do something ourselves instead of just chatter on and on about stuff that is impossible?

 

cwydro

(51,308 posts)
22. I suppose some find it funny, and some may even believe these loony theories.
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 05:31 PM
Oct 2019

It’s not a good look for the site imo.

exboyfil

(17,863 posts)
13. As I understand 2 the process can keep going
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 02:40 PM
Oct 2019

indefinitely. After every vote the President (who is still the President) petitions Congress for return to office. The Vice President is only acting until resignation, impeachment, failure to petition Congress again, the next election, or death.

The 25th is like The Walking Dead version of impeachment and practically much harder (1/2 the Cabinet and 2/3rds of both Houses when impeachment only requires majority in the House and 2/3rds in the Senate).

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
14. Yes. If it comes to push or shove, the 25th Amendment doesn't work very well.
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 02:42 PM
Oct 2019

I've always thought it sounded impossible as a way to get rid of a President. Impeachment is much easier, really.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,734 posts)
20. It's never been used. I think it was intentionally designed to be very difficult to implement
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 03:27 PM
Oct 2019

in order to prevent the removal or sidelining of a president for political reasons. Even though Trump seems to be nuttier than squirrel poop these days, I don't see anybody trying to use the 25th.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
21. There's really no way to use it, unless the VP is on board, and
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 03:32 PM
Oct 2019

can get at least half of the cabinet to support him. Without that, nothing happens. If the President becomes ill and cannot act as President, then that's a different matter, but that doesn't seem to be the situation.

Pence isn't much of a leader, and most of Trump's cabinet members owe their position to Trump, so, I can't imagine any 25th Amendment action even getting off the ground.

Yes, it's a difficult thing to use. So difficult, that I can't imagine it actually being used in any situation where there is a President who is even sort of coherent. It's just not a likely course of action.

Congress plays no role in the 25th Amendment unless there is a conflict between a President and his VP and cabinet.

Really, it's a pretty useless thing, except in the case of a sudden illness or disability on the part of the President. The rest of it is a highly improbable scenario.

tritsofme

(17,379 posts)
31. I wonder if a president fearing 25th amendment action could fire his entire cabinet
Mon Oct 7, 2019, 11:02 PM
Oct 2019

And stop action? The 25th amendment calls for the vice president and a majority of the cabinet officers to declare him unfit, I wonder if there are no cabinet officers would the decision fall to the vice president alone, or would he be unable to act, lacking a “quorum” of cabinet officers to constitute a majority?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»There Are Only Four Ways ...