General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDemocrats snoozed while Republicans took over the courts. It's time to fight back
Democrats snoozed while Republicans took over the courts. It's time to fight back
The Democratic base is tired of the party being passive about Republicans packing the judiciary. So whats their game plan?
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/oct/08/democrats-judiciary-right-wing-kavanaugh?utm_term=RWRpdG9yaWFsX0d1YXJkaWFuVG9kYXlVUy0xOTEwMDg%3D&utm_source=esp&utm_medium=Email&utm_campaign=GuardianTodayUS&CMP=GTUS_email
<<snip>>
But the protesters anger at the court went beyond Kavanaugh himself, and beyond, even, the insult to womens dignity and threat to womens rights that the man represents. Representative Ayanna Pressley, of Massachusettes, told the crowd, Kavanaugh may have that seat (for now), but what we are fighting for is so much bigger than one insecure man blinded by his privilege. The protesters see Kavanaugh as only the most egregious symptom of a court system that is gravely diseased. Their action speaks to a growing liberal agitation around the judiciary, led by feminists, that is poised to change the politics of the courts.
Traditionally, it was only the right that cared about the judiciary. Republicans ran on promises to appoint judges that would uphold conservative social values, and oppose abortion and gay rights. Those judges in turn enshrined the legality of gerrymandering, curtailed voting rights, and opened the floodgates of unlimited corporate money in politics, interventions which have enabled the Republican party to maintain power even in districts where they have only a minority of popular support. The result became cyclical: Republicans won by promising to appoint conservative judges, and then those conservative judges issued decisions that helped more Republicans win.
To the left, the judiciary had often been more of an afterthought. Conventional wisdom held that the judiciary could not be counted on as a motivating issue for Democrats the same way that it could for Republicans. But the Kavanaugh appointment brought a new sense of urgency to the matter; the Courts new conservative majority, and the spectacle of the emotional Senate confirmation hearings through which Republicans secured this majority, galvanized the attention of a Democratic base that increasingly feels that its basic civil rights are imperiled under a federal judiciary packed with Trump appointees and a Supreme Court controlled by Trump allies.
There is some evidence that this concern expands well beyond the activist left: in September, a poll conducted by the firm Perry Undem found that a full 60% of Americans thought it likely that Brett Kavanaugh committed perjury during his confirmation hearings, a figure that suggests that popular support for impeaching the Justice may be easy for Democrats to come by. Support for abortion rights is even higher, meaning that the Supreme Court, which is poised to issue the first assault on abortion of its new conservative majority just before the next presidential election, is not only comprised of justices that the people do not trust, but is also likely to hand down opinions that the people do not want.
And this is the problem with the Supreme Court: it is a profoundly un-democratic institution, and has only been made more so by the rights determination to politicize the court and to manipulate it into helping them secure a policy agenda that runs counter to popular will. The gross injustice of the Kavanaugh confirmation made Americansand feminists in particularmore aware of the urgency of the problem, and less accepting of its inevitability.
<<snip>>
NewDayOranges
(692 posts)There just weren't enough of them to block the people Trump nominated or obstruct the republicans who confirmed these backwards judges...
BlueMTexpat
(15,369 posts)NewDayOranges
(692 posts)BlueMTexpat
(15,369 posts)and "expat." But my maternal grandmom was born in Texas, so I take no offense.
NewDayOranges
(692 posts)Land of the Big Sky!
BlueMTexpat
(15,369 posts)StarfishSaver
(18,486 posts)and let the Senate flip to Republican control because they were either too apathetic or too spiteful to vote in the mid-terms.
Polybius
(15,421 posts)Florida especially should have been one.
dajoki
(10,678 posts)toomey won by a very small margin, I don't remember what it was exactly, I think around 1% but that is one of the questionable states with all the interference. It is also my state.
BumRushDaShow
(129,032 posts)was that it seemed to parallel the votes for Hillary as a "close loss", whereas voters overwhelming elected Democrats for all the top state positions (State Attorney General, State Treasurer, State Auditor General).
Polybius
(15,421 posts)Not saying PA is legit or not (I didn't really follow that election as much as I should have), but take Massachusetts Republican Governor Charlie Baker for example. The rest of the state elected Democrats by huge margins, and he wins in a landslide fair and square.
BumRushDaShow
(129,032 posts)but I know looking at 2016 here, you can see a bunch of folks apparently didn't vote for the top of the ticket or for Senate, but did vote for the other top state positions just based on the vote totals. But... that is now water under a bridge. But in 2018, we were able to re-elect a Democrat for governor (Wolf) and keep Casey (another Democrat) in his Senate seat for another 6-year term - which actually made him the longest-serving Democratic Senator here in PA if I'm not mistaken.
still_one
(92,193 posts)in 2016, and who spew the LIE that there was no difference between republicans and Democrats?
It didn't take much either.
In every swing state Hillary lost by less than 1%. Jill Stein received 1% of the vote in those states
Along with Comey, foreign interference they all had a part in helping the Democrats lose two SC nominations
maxsolomon
(33,345 posts)AFTER blocking most of Obama's nominees, up to and including Garland.
"Snoozing" is when you're not paying attention, not when you have no tools to object.
MineralMan
(146,315 posts)about the risk of the Republicans gaining control of all three branches of federal government. And yet, that is exactly what happened in 2016. Too many people who would otherwise vote for Democrats ended up not voting or voted for someone like the detestable Jill Stein. And we ended up with Trump in the White House, with Republicans in control of Congress.
So, that combination allowed Republicans to pack the courts, just like I and others warned about.
There was a way to prevent that from happening. That prevention didn't occur. The warning was there, but went unheeded by too many. Fewer than 90,000 votes in three states combined made all the difference.
Did we learn? I certainly hope we did.
Nitram
(22,802 posts)and Republicans have a majority in the Senate. That's why McConnell has supported Trump through thick and thin. How would Democrats have forced McConnell to bring Garland up for a vote? Taking it to court would have taken too long.
Demsrule86
(68,577 posts)courts and as many of us warned...this is a lifetime appointment for right wing judges some who are not even qualified...what would this country look like if there was no Nader and no Stein...and we had Obama's back in 10 14.
Response to dajoki (Original post)
elocs This message was self-deleted by its author.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)And dishonestly hostile.
The courts are filled by those voters put in power. Our nation shifted more conservative back in the Reagan era, so power became dominated by conservatives.
But it didn't have to stay that way. It's the vote. This is all the fault of those who don't vote or vote mean and stupid. I despise those who don't vote then whine and complain about "they" and "them."
And I really despise those who refused to vote Democrat in 2016 and are now, of course, blaming Democrats because Republicans are packing the courts with RW extremists. What did they expect!? I'd like to beat them all with a stick. They're base, all right, not our party base, just fools who really need to take an honest look in a mirror and try to be better people.
And they can start by not blaming others for what their grave failures and betrayals have caused.