General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Republican powers that be aren't crazy, at least not in a clinical sense.
Howard Dean indicated that William Barr is "mentally unbalanced." I understand the temptation to refer to the likes of William Barr as mentally ill (given his speech about the ills of secularism and his contributing to the Deep State narrative), especially when so much of the rhetoric is increasingly 'unhinged', in addition to being just plain cruel. While there are mentally unbalanced people within the ranks of the powers that be, including narcissistic Trump, and most definitely within the electorate, the likes of Barr and Bannon and Miller and Pompeo and Mulvaney and McConnell are - make no mistake - driven by a specific ideology. They aren't "crazy" in any clinical sense, and some of them are quite intellectual. They're self-interested fascists out to undermine all democratic institutions. Most are racists, sexists and Christian supremacists themselves, or - at the very least - have no problem fomenting and exploiting racism and sexism and religious bigotry, which have proven for a long time to be highly effective tools for realizing their version of fascism (for which the Powell Memo served as an early blueprint).They've seen the writing on the wall (social progression, increased secularism, changing demographics, etc.), so their tactics have become increasingly extreme (intense voter suppression and gerrymandering, extreme deregulation and privatization, full-throated attacks on science and public education, persistent attacks on the "liberal media" in the interest of shifting the Overton Window, stealing a Supreme Court seat and packing the judiciary with right wing ideologues, aligning with dictators who share the goal of undermining democracy for personal enrichment, replacing the dog whistle with a bullhorn, and so on). They take comfort in a tyranny of the minority system which, paradoxically, makes major structural reform nearly impossible to bring about for the very reasons why such reform is so desperately needed. Still, they have reason to fear and thwart the impacts of social evolution.
We can't afford to simply dismiss these monsters as mentally ill, even if they all happen to be sociopaths. It's vital that we understand that with which we're dealing.
applegrove
(118,696 posts)Trump abandoned the Kurds. It was bringing them back into the fold.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)Particularly this part, which Howard Dean quoted:
I'm sure Team Trump gets a bit worried when Pat Robertson talks of Trump potentially losing the "mandate of Heaven," but that wasn't the only reason behind the remarks made by Barr. In Barr, Trump has found his new Bannon, except that instead of just being an advisor, he's the nation's top attorney (and that's pretty frightening).
True Blue American
(17,986 posts)Last edited Mon Oct 14, 2019, 04:16 AM - Edit history (1)
Not Bannon! Barr is a proven sleazeball. Bannon is a Johnny come lately.
Oh, Lord, Lindsey Graham has been caught plotting with 2 pranksters!
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)Bannon's been doing his right wing/"traditional values"/Christian supremacy propaganda thing for longer than Trump has and for just as long as Barr has. That quote from Barr in my last post is precisely the sort of thing Bannon (who worked on Roy Moore's campaign and has been pushing fascism in Europe) would say.
True Blue American
(17,986 posts)I have been reading all along what he is.
But Barr is the Attorney doing great damage to our Institutions. I want that so and so disbarred for life and brought down just like McCarthy!
Rudy thinks he is smart, like Manafort. I hope he rots in jail, but doubt that will happen.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)Barr, like the rest of the department heads, is actively trying to undermine the very department he's leading. It's fucking surreal that the AG is going around the world undermining the FBI and US intelligence agencies.
OnDoutside
(19,962 posts)amoral. They know they are in so deep with Trump, it's all or nothing at this stage. That potentially allows Democrats to secure an earth shattering win in 2020.
True Blue American
(17,986 posts)Amoral, but I do not think they are insane. Evil, maybe, not insane.
OnDoutside
(19,962 posts)Garrett78
(10,721 posts)...version of Trump coming down the pike. I'm cautiously hopeful about 2020, but the level of corruption and desperation is worrisome.
OnDoutside
(19,962 posts)Republican Party. They're not going to be happy with a Mitt Romney type, which presents a problem for those trying to wait out Trump. There is no way Trumpists are going to stay quiet, and that is why I believe Republican voting Independents won't be in a hurry to come back.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)...depends greatly on these next few elections, especially 2020. Democratic success (or lack thereof) will go a long way toward determining if the Republican Party splinters and has to consider fundamental change or if the Republican Party can continue its march toward fascism.
Controlling the narrative has never been more crucial.
OnDoutside
(19,962 posts)they finally figure out the lies they've been told. I hope people have been making a list of stuff to fix !
100% agree about controlling the narrative, and to be fair, Pelosi has done a great job so far. She held the line until Trump made a crucial mistake, in releasing the transcript summary.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)But a big win in 2020 (and 2022 and 2024) can do much to stymie fascism and - hopefully - lead to the outlawing of gerrymandering and voter suppression.
Celerity
(43,415 posts)Garrett78
(10,721 posts)That doesn't, however, excuse his actions.
I_UndergroundPanther
(12,480 posts)I would not define Narcissism as a mental illness. I'd call it a toxic personality type.
It should not be seen as mental illness but as a toxic person.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)But it is treatable and doesn't excuse Trump's behavior.
docgee
(870 posts)As a fellow atheist, I think anyone who believes some god has chosen them to be a holy warrior to bring on the rapture is insane. Looking at the universe objectively and somehow working in that fantasy has to be some form of mental illness.
Hard to tell if he's a liar, nuts or some of both.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)...we'd be suggesting that the vast majority of people are mentally ill, even though a belief in the supernatural is quite possibly an evolutionary adaptation.
Anyway, I doubt that Barr, Bannon and the others I mentioned are looking to bring on the rapture. They may not even believe in god(s). Their fascist ideology doesn't require such belief.
I_UndergroundPanther
(12,480 posts)I think people who believe a popular delusion are still delusional. Conversion and choice of ones delusion is still deluded .
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)Pushing a belief in the supernatural is not even close to being the primary goal of Barr, Bannon, Miller, McConnell, Trump, etc. Religious bigotry, like racism and sexism, is a tool. For all I know, every one of those assholes is an atheist.
docgee
(870 posts)sky is blue and the grass is green, and to believe the exact opposite. Religion belief may be evolutionary, but fanaticism is not.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)It's fascism and destroying democratic institutions that revs their engines. Every department (from the EPA to the DOE to the DOJ) is being run by people bent on undermining those departments. The head of the DOJ is going around doing all he can to undermine the FBI and intelligence agencies. It's surreal.
Buckeyeblue
(5,499 posts)Many of them whole-heatedly believe the shit that Barr was spouting. So it's not so much that they are mentally ill as they are deluded.
Garrett78
(10,721 posts)Of course, I suppose just about everyone does, at one point or another, believe in something that isn't true, which is the definition of being deluded.
But I think the more important point is that the likes of Barr are pushing a dangerous ideology, and they are certainly reliant upon keeping their electorate deluded.