Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDahlia Lithwick: The Women Who Still Speak Up
The Women Who Still Speak Up
One used to speak truth to power. Now, one speaks truth to nonsense.
By Dahlia Lithwick
Dec 06, 20191:49 PM
Speak truth to powerthis is how most people standing up to the constant disinformation and bullying of the Trump administration may have once reasonably described their task. Increasingly, though, that work is being honed and refined into something a bit more complicated: speaking truth to nonsense. Its not so much holding up a mirror so that power can see what its become; its simply the job of creating a record, for history if nothing else, of what is actually happening.
Its not, by any means, that the power imbalance is irrelevant anymore. If anything, the power differential between President Donald Trump and those seeking to hold him to account is more chilling than ever: Trump has pressed the entire Justice Department (including new threats of abusing its policing powers) into service to protect his interests above those of the nation, the White House counsel currently serves as his personal lawyer, the foreign service and the military are being purged of experts and patriots, and Senate Republicans have debased themselves to the point that they are openly peddling debunked Russian propaganda in his service. Congress cannot stop him, and the courts will likely be timed out in constraining him. The lopsidedness of his power is now axiomatic.
Also axiomatic is the fact that, frequently, it is women who have come forward, in droves, to speak truth to that power, or to nonsense, or, perhaps most accurately, to the nonsense that feeds his power. From Sally Yates to E. Jean Carroll to April Ryan to Greta Thunberg to Fiona Hill to the undocumented housekeepers who used to work at his properties, it is often women who have stood up to say No to this president. As Sandra Diaz, one of those two undocumented cleaners, explained her decision to finally speak up even though everyone around her warned her not to: How can you know something so big, how someonewho goes on national television and says somethingand you know its not true whether its the president or not, you have the responsibility to say no. To pass through this barrier of fear and say no. Ukraine Ambassador Marie Yovanovitch described, in real time, at a public Intelligence Committee hearing last month, what it feels like to pass through that same barrier of fear: As Trump tweeted threats at her midhearing, she was asked how she was experiencing it. Its very intimidating, Yovanovitch quietly confessed to the members of the Intelligence Committee. I cant speak to what the president is trying to do, but I think the effect is to be intimidating. Lisa Page similarly passed through the barrier of fear this past week, when she told the truth about Trumps relentless attacks on her and defended her record in the face of his lies.
On Wednesday, professor Pamela Karlan was the only woman testifying before the House Judiciary Committees panel on the constitutional framework for impeachment. (Disclosure: Karlan is a friend.) Her presentation was so effective and so crystal clear that House Republicans, of whom all but two were men, were too afraid to question her on history or doctrine, opting for personal threats and shouting instead. Ranking member Rep. Doug Collins suggested in his opening remarks that she hadnt read the witness transcripts (she had). Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., shouted at her about her campaign donations as well as a joke she made on a podcast. When she attempted to respond to his claims that she was mean, he shouted, Excuse me, you dont get to interrupt me on this time. When Rep. Tom McClintock, R-Calif., asked all of the constitutional law professors whom they had voted for in the 2016 election, it was Karlan who shot back that Americans still enjoy the right to a secret ballot. Rep. Jim Jordan just used his time to scream.
But everyone really agreed to melt down when Karlan referenced the name of the presidents youngest son, Barron, to make a point about the difference between monarchs and presidents. Yes, she used it in a bit of wordplay, and yes, people laughed, but, no, it was not a targeted attack on a childit was a targeted attack on claims of monarchic powers. But lets be honest. Whether Karlan had done a joke about the British nobility, or Ninja Turtles, or diet soda, the rage machine at the White House would have singled her out for vivisection, just as it did with Hill, who didnt make a joke, or Yovanovitch, who also didnt make a joke. (The hate machine largely left the male law professors alone, by the way.) These womens words themselves, the substance of them, the truth of them, were never the issue. Do you even recall what they said? Sometimes, they werent even permitted to speak, or respond. The rage machine, in coordination with the White House spokeswoman (who does not do press conferences) and Sean Hannity and Tucker Carlson, finds their rabid talking point and repeats it and tweets it until theres nothing left, until absolutely no fact, or statistic, or idea, can cut through the dry-ice fog it creates. (Tucker Carlson started Wednesday nights news show with This lady needs a shrink and What a moron.) In the end, Karlan apologized for her pun, because Republicans, who put children in freezing cages at the border and leave them to die, told her she was the one being mean to children.
It is worth recalling that Karlanlike Fiona Hill before her, and Yovanovitch before her, and Thunberg, and Carroll, and Karen McDougal, and Christine Blasey Ford, and Debbie Ramirez, and Sandra Diaz, and Lisa Page, and all the other women who have subjected themselves to the raging Trump campaign of abusewas simply speaking the truth. In the face of lies, imaginary conspiracies, smear campaigns, and disinformation, each was simply relating the facts as she knew them.
more...
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/12/pamela-karlan-testimony-barron-trump-republican-outrage.html
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
2 replies, 622 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (17)
ReplyReply to this post
2 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Dahlia Lithwick: The Women Who Still Speak Up (Original Post)
babylonsister
Dec 2019
OP
abqtommy
(14,118 posts)1. It's obvious that reTHUG males are still afraid their Mommies are going to send them to bed
without their supper. What a bunch of trembling/frightened snowflakes! Let's show them how right they are to be frightened!
maxsolomon
(33,432 posts)2. I had forgotten until a HS friend reminded me
that President Narcissist's PR alias was John BARRON. he named his son after his alias.
he is the worst person in the world.