General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Tyranny of the 63 Million
The Tyranny of the 63 Million
Impeachment didnt undermine democracy. It vindicated it.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/20/opinion/sunday/impeachment-trump-republicans.html?
<<snip>>
On the surface it seems strange, this constant trumpeting of a vote total that is more than two million less than the total received by Trumps opponent, Hillary Clinton. Trump didnt just lose the popular vote he lost it by a greater margin than any successful presidential candidate in American history. The rights bombastic repetition of Trumps 63 million could be just a propaganda trick meant to bully Americas anti-Trump majority into seeing itself as marginal, despite the more than 65 million votes Clinton received. But as I watched impeachment unfold, it seemed like something more than that an assertion of whom Republicans think this country belongs to.
<<snip>>
The Republican identification with Trump is total. Again and again, histrionic Republican congressmen equated hatred of the president with hatred of themselves and hatred of the sacred 63 million. They spoke of Trump with an awe and a maudlin devotion bordering on religious; Barry Loudermilk, a Georgia Republican, declared that Trump had been given less due process than Jesus Christ himself.
If Trump is a martyr, who are his persecutors? You could watch the debate with the sound off and understand. All day, Republican speeches delivered by old white men alternated with Democratic speeches from women, people of color and young people. White men make up 90 percent of the Republican caucus and 38 percent of the Democratic one, and the day dramatized the representational gulf in the starkest visual terms.
With the sound on, you could hear fury and self-pity from the Republicans, along with, at times, outrage that Democrats would have the audacity to speak on behalf of American values. Clay Higgins, Republican of Louisiana, brought with him one of those color-coded maps Trump supporters love, showing how their fewer 2016 votes were spread over much greater expanses of land. Were not being devoured from within because of some surreal assertion of the socialists newfound love for the very flag that they trod upon, Higgins said. We face this horror because of this map.
In a sense, hes right: We face the horror of Trump because the structure of American democracy gives disproportionate power to a declining demographic group passionately convinced of its right to rule. Trump, with his braying entitlement, his boastful ignorance, his sneering contempt for pluralism, is an avatar of a Republican Party desperate to return to the 1980s, or the 1950s, or maybe the 1910s. He cant betray America if, to those who fetishize the 63 million, he embodies it.
<<snip>>
Farmer-Rick
(10,197 posts)3 million more votes ignored by a democracy. Hmmm, maybe we aren't a democracy anymore.
vlyons
(10,252 posts)millions of voters gave control of the House to the Dems with the express purpose to put a check on out of control Trump.