Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Takket

(21,578 posts)
Sun Dec 22, 2019, 12:18 PM Dec 2019

interesting NBC poll

If you can grit your teeth through Chuck Toad's bullshit (as he started an interview with Claire McCaskill by saying that impeachment had broken congress, and she rightfully shut him down immediately by saying that Congress was already broken and McConnell had destroyed the Senate).... you get to some polling data.

48% sure to vote AGAINST drumpf
34% sure to vote for him
18% say "depends on the Dem candidate"

of the 18% group:
55% approve of drumpf
60% want a GOP congress
48% say drumpf "may have done something wrong but not impeachable"

What does it all mean? It means drumpf has an uphill battle. In the 18% "undecided" group he has support, but he needs to win almost that ENTIRE group to boost his support from 34% to 51%

Now... the bad news............. we already know from 2016 that the majority vote doesn't win elections. As long as he wins enough states, he doesn't need the people behind him. But at the very least, for now, the Dems are ahead.

7 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
interesting NBC poll (Original Post) Takket Dec 2019 OP
K&R UTUSN Dec 2019 #1
let me follow this up too...... Takket Dec 2019 #2
What Trump did in 2016 likely won't work this time around. We know too much. Eyeball_Kid Dec 2019 #3
Anyone who approves of Trump or wants a GOP Congress is not undecided Azathoth Dec 2019 #4
Agree. SharonClark Dec 2019 #5
Majority vote.... boomer_wv Dec 2019 #6
I suspect a minimum of half of that 18% group are the people who say ooky Dec 2019 #7

Takket

(21,578 posts)
2. let me follow this up too......
Sun Dec 22, 2019, 12:43 PM
Dec 2019

with a reminder that this assumes a fair election without voter suppression tactics either...........

so i'm just trying to show there is some hope, but let's not be naive and assume this thing is "wrapped up"

Eyeball_Kid

(7,432 posts)
3. What Trump did in 2016 likely won't work this time around. We know too much.
Sun Dec 22, 2019, 12:46 PM
Dec 2019

Besides, Trump's a one trick pony. All he knows is division, ridicule, fear, and megalomania. The undecideds have seen this for three years. They, too, are getting tired of the shit show. If Trump changes tactics and develops a more conciliatory approach, he'll lose at least half of his base, whom he's cultured and lead into a largely hate-filled, uncompromising lot. So he's painted himself into a shrinking corner.

It's true that the popular vote may not reflect the results of the electoral college vote. But there's nonetheless a breaking point with the popular vote that will render the EC results impotent. Michigan and Pennsylvania won't break for Trump this time around. That's a path to defeat for Trump.

BUT again, none of this matters because...

If the Senate acquits, all bets are off. A resurgent Trump, after acquittal, will make certain that the election is tilted in his favor. He'll have no legal or Congressional restraints to do anything he wishes to fix the election. And if he can't fix it, he'll create a reason to cancel the election.

If the Senate convicts, we'll have to deal with Pence, who also will be a candidate for impeachment, since he's indisputably a co-conspirator in the very unconstitutional acts that will have gotten Trump impeached and removed. IMO, we'd rather have that problem than the aftermath of a Senate acquittal of Trump.

Azathoth

(4,610 posts)
4. Anyone who approves of Trump or wants a GOP Congress is not undecided
Sun Dec 22, 2019, 12:49 PM
Dec 2019

These are people who are simply looking for an excuse to justify their predetermined vote, and Fox will hand it to them no matter who the Dems nominate.

Only about 40% of those undecideds are actually in play, and if Trump wins half of them, he won't win, but it will be a lot closer than these numbers imply.

 

boomer_wv

(673 posts)
6. Majority vote....
Sun Dec 22, 2019, 01:06 PM
Dec 2019

usually does win elections if it is big enough. The margin Clinton won the popular vote by was near the extent of what a person would win by without capturing the EC as well. That can be seen in the narrow losses she has in the tipping point states. Had she won by say, another million votes nationwide, it's highly unlikely that she wouldn't have won enough in those states to take their electors. In our history there have only been a few times that the majority winning didn't also win the EC. It's a pretty rare thing, but have have some recency bias since 2/3 of those times have happened in the past 20 years.

So, let's look at this poll. We have 48% in the bank, and another 18% in the possible category. Of that 60% look to be pretty reliably republican voters, so let's just assume that they call come home to Trump. That's 10% back to him. Not it's 48-34. Let's say that the democrat is able to win about half of that number, so they get 5% of that vote. The other 5% stays home or votes for a 3rd party.

That leaves you with the democrat at 53% and Trump 44%. While it's conceivable that Trump could again sneak out a EC victory with a 4 or possibly 5% nationwide loss, it's going to probably be impossible to do so if you are losing by 9%.

These numbers could change though, the 18% seem to be atleast open to the possibility of voting democratic, even with their largely conservative leanings. That tells me that there are candidates who they think they would vote for. I can't be sure without data on that group, but I'd have to imagine that the larger group of them would be more likely to vote for Joe Biden and less likely to vote for Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders.

ooky

(8,924 posts)
7. I suspect a minimum of half of that 18% group are the people who say
Sun Dec 22, 2019, 01:14 PM
Dec 2019

they are independents, as though they have an open mind, and then always go vote for whoever has the "R" beside their name. They probably prefer a different Republican than Trump but if they don't get it they will vote for Trump. I would count on no less than half of that group voting for Trump again, putting that number up to at least 43% for Trump, roughly the same amount of support that always seems to poll for him.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»interesting NBC poll