General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsLarge protests spooling up in Iran over the Ukraine airliner shootdown
Jesus, could this accidental shootdown actually bring down the regime? Probably not, but this is an interesting development...
On edit:
Link to tweet
"Editor in Chief of Tasnim, IRGC's media." State media's even taking IRGC to task!
On edit: Live updates here:
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/11/world/middleeast/plane-crash.html
Thomas Hurt
(13,903 posts)Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)The IRGC fucked up hard, and even its supporters are pissed.
Sherman A1
(38,958 posts)He doesn't deserve any credit for anything, but he will certainly take credit for everything.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)He always, at least, tries...
Thomas Hurt
(13,903 posts)Trump assassinates a foreign leader
Iran retaliates and warns Iraq they are going to do it.
Almost at the same time they eff up and shoot down a civilian airliner.
That malignant f**k started this mess and by circumstance and luck, Iranians have managed to make him look better than he deserves.
underpants
(182,921 posts)jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Trump is bound to exult in the deaths of these innocent victims as a victory.
dalton99a
(81,626 posts)Afromania
(2,771 posts)SQUEE
(1,315 posts)The Iranians are a wonderful and resourceful people, hamstrung by religious zealots, and extremist madmen. A democratic Iran would be a wonderful and powerful hedge against KSA.
What the hell does that mean?
SQUEE
(1,315 posts)OF all types.
We have ways to get them both, weapons, and devices to communicate. They deserve a chance to be free of the mullahs, but have no realistic way to do this by vote, they are completely at the mercy of a regime that has all the weapons.
Dorian Gray
(13,503 posts)stumbled ass backward into unleashing democracy in Iran? It would be a great accomplishment for any president, and Donny Dotard may accidentally fall on top of it. I'll take it for the people of Iran. Wishing safety and security to the iranian people. Godspeed.
evertonfc
(1,713 posts)absolutely despise thier leader and states if not for being killed like dogs, the under 40 demographic would overthrow the current govt. I hear stories of people being pulled from thier homes and executed in street for opposition. I have a large group of Iranian friends that have migrated here over ladt 40 years and they want this dudes head but not via military action that might make it worse
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)Praying for them.
Igel
(35,359 posts)And to a person they all despised the Soviet state and Putin.
They looked down on Eltsin as simply incompetent, that's different from despising for cause.
They were all emigres.
Then I found myself in some situations with Russians that were not emigres. Some were studying abroad, at a time when there were no favors for loyal Communists. Some were sent abroad as instructions or they came to the US for a while to conduct business or as part of a sister-city project.
And to a person they all loved the Soviet state and, later, Putin.
Made me stop and realize that all the Russians that left the USSR/Russia had a reason for it, and in a country where the economy is the government, education is the government, employment is the government, etc., etc., every dissatisfaction that could lead to emigration--from ethnic discrimination to unemployment to political repression--necessarily was aimed at the government. So my sample was skewed.
underpants
(182,921 posts)Can't buy online (if they have online) no Twitter etc.
It's basically the same thing that brought down the Soviet Union - blue jeans and rock n roll.
I've always thought the nuke deal was the Iranian Governments effort to placate the younger folks. Get some banking access into the rest of the world and steps towards relieving sanctions.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)enid602
(8,658 posts)Funny. I don't remember massive protests here in the States in 1983 after we 'accidentally' shot down Iran Air Flt 655. 290 died.
tblue37
(65,490 posts)are especially upset. Americans tend not to get that upset if innocent people from countries they consider hostile end up getting killed. If the plane the U.S. shot down had been filled with innocent Americans, then there would have been protests here, too.
Maybe then, we would not have awarded the commander of the Vincennes with a Medal of Honor.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)Igel
(35,359 posts)Wasn't a big deal in the news because we had important things to read about.
It was one of the complaints from some activists about the Soleimani killing. Suddenly all the anti-government protests had something that bound them to the government they had protested, and it was viewed by some as Trump's betrayal of the protestors.
It wouldn't have been nearly so bad if the government hadn't said, immediately, "No, it most definitely wasn't us." From the news reader to the top-dog ayatollah. Followed by denials of the obviously false accusations of the West that it was Iran who was responsible--basically, "they're just saying that because they hate us and always accuse us of lying."
Oops.
rollin74
(1,990 posts)past efforts by the masses to stand up to the govt have been met with extreme violence and lots of activists disappearing
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)dware
(12,449 posts)They had the sympathy of the world, it united the citizens against the US, and then, shockingly, they didn't do what common sense would dictate, shut down IKA to commercial air traffic while on high alert and exert more control over their AA defenses.
I wouldn't want to be that missile battery's commander or personnel right now.
This has the potential to really blow up in the Iranian leadership's faces.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)rollin74
(1,990 posts)demos in the past have been met with gunfire in the street or attacks by Basij thugs
lets hope that the outcome here is different
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)Link to tweet
Link to tweet
?s=20
Robert (Rob) Nigel Paul Macaire CMG (19 February 1966) is a British diplomat. He was previously the Director of Political Risk in BG Group plc before going on to become the UK Ambassador to Iran.
On edit - detained and released:
Link to tweet
EX500rider
(10,872 posts)Some demonstrators chanted for the resignation of the commander in chief - Ayatollah Khamenei.
The semi-official Fars news agency carried a rare report of the anti-government unrest, saying up to 1,000 people had gathered, chanting slogans against leaders and tearing up pictures of Soleimani.
I knew he wasn't as popular as portrayed, only with the hardliners, he and the QUDS force have some involvement in the heavy handed treatment of protesters in Iran.
Soleimani was a general in the IRGC (Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps) whose main job was to keep the religious dictatorship in power. Thus while Soleimani spent most of his time causing mayhem in other countries (as commander of Quds Force), he was called in when unruly Iranians had to be pacified. In Iran, it is no secret that Soleimani was a hardliner when it comes to domestic unrest.
calimary
(81,518 posts)Takket
(21,635 posts)0 Americans died in retaliation for Soleimani. Their leadership killed more Iranian civilians on that plane than they did Americans. Not the retaliation they were sold on.
NCLefty
(3,678 posts)See: Iran.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)The activists have retreated to campuses. Hopefully re-grouping for another go. The Iranian people deserve better than Ayatollahs and Shahs.