General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsRegarding Black/Brown/Jewish/Muslim/"Other" Republicans
Ive never understood how anyone who identifies with any of the groups in the headline of this post can be a Republican. Yet, many have chosen to join their enemies.
I put join their enemies" in quotes, because people in all of these groups may not understand that they are despised by the majority of the people who make up the Republican Party.
IMO, being a black/brown Republican is like being a black or brown member of the KKK. A Jewish Republican skirts the edges of being a Jewish Nazi. (Yes, Im talking about people like you, and so many others, Alan Dershowitz.) I could go on, but you get the idea.
When were talking about a political party that has no problem with separating Latin children from their loved ones and putting them in cages, who can have any doubt as to where theyre heading. If I used terms like lynching, and concentration camps, many here would be outraged and think I have gone off the rails. But read a little history from, say, the 1930s, in Germany and the American South, and only the morally blind would fail to see the similarities to that period and todays political environment.
(It needs to be said that what many once called the "American South" is much of today's rural America. It stretches far beyond a single geographic region that we once called "The South". Many areas of the old South are enlightened, and countless people there are as outraged about today's political disaster as every other sane person.)
I fully expect that this thread will result in my being verbally attacked by some outraged DUers, for a variety of reasons. Many may call for this thread to be deleted, and that may happen.
But while this thread is still here, can anyone explain to me why any person who doesnt work on Wall Street, or isnt a white bible beating hypocrite, or is in some way mentally impaired, or stupid, or incredibly uninformed, or wallowing in self-hatred, would choose to be a Republican? I really cant grasp it.
Whiskeytide
(4,461 posts)... voters, and dont grasp the bigger picture.
Some are simply not informed enough, and cant figure out the bigger picture.
Some just dont care about the bigger picture.
Some have been so misinformed that they see a different bigger picture.
I also think that the number of people of color who vote republican is overblown at times.
JonLP24
(29,322 posts)The right wing loves their wedge issues.
brush
(53,785 posts)to make a mark in the much larger pond of POCs in the Democratic party so they throw in with the repugs to see what they can get out of it by being"different", allowing themselves to be used as tokens for a quid pro quo.
Others are just uninformed, low-info voters, some simply want to be seen as "different" than those regular black people, and some are just stupid.
JonLP24
(29,322 posts)As far as Muslims they may vote Democratic despite the Islamaphobia (Bill Maher for example). Muslims I follow on social media tend to be very progressive of foreign policy I imagine because of the Iraq war & other blunders.
Vogon_Glory
(9,118 posts)to these other groups and were rewarded by Asian-American and Jewish-American support. I remember George W. Bush trying to get Muslim-Americans to align with the Republican Party before September 11th, 2001.
Of course the Far Right balked. The Republicans turn towards outright bigotry started with the propaganda organs and the Wen Ho Lee case in the 1990s. Then came the anti-Muslim hysteria after 9/11, followed by the Rights balking at Dubyas attempt to legalize undocumented aliens.
Fast forward to Trumps presidential campaign. Bigotry has again become acceptable in Republican circles.
What Im saying is that times have changed, and a lot of other Republicans failed to notice it.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)A lot of conservatives who identify Democrat in unity with their "tribe" share many gut reactions and predilections with conservative whites. They have to hold their nose all those times that voting for themselves also includes supporting liberal principles and goals they may genuinely despise.
The biggest difference between the two personality types, btw, is attitude toward equality. Liberals believe in it, conservatives less. Hierarchies of power and privilege tend to make sense for conservatives; they believe that in healthy societies they are natural and inevitable. The more conservative stronger the disagreements and less in common with liberals, of course.
Skin color, religion, cultures and continents of origin strongly affect but don't erase these fundamental wired-in orientations of all humans.
We saw that in that subset of black male Obama voters who refused to vote for a black woman to be governor of Georgia, effectively throwing in with GA's male-dominated white Republican Party against liberal government and women's equality.