Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

thesquanderer

(11,990 posts)
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 02:36 PM Mar 2020

The CDC PSA from coronavirus.gov has dangerous misinformation

Have folks here seen this PSA that the CDC is running? It's very misleading.



It starts with answering "who's most at risk for coronavirus?" and answers it with those over 65, those with medical conditions, etc. This is easily dangerously misinterpreted. Those are the people most at risk for DYING from it, but EVERYONE is at risk of catching it, getting sick from it, and most importantly, becoming a carrier for it.

But even worse...

It goes on to answer its next question, "What should you do if you or a loved one is at higher risk?" The answers are to avoid crowds, wash your hands frequently, etc. WRONG! There are not what you should do IF you are at higher risk! These are what EVERYONE should do, whether you are in a high risk group or not!

This ad is perpetuating the dangerous misperception that young, healthy people don't have to worry about it.



10 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The CDC PSA from coronavirus.gov has dangerous misinformation (Original Post) thesquanderer Mar 2020 OP
Totally agree. They are definitely minimizing Phoenix61 Mar 2020 #1
I agree with you that the danger to young people was minimized. LisaM Mar 2020 #2
From what I am hearing, Pence's task force has taken CDC information and reworked it , hlthe2b Mar 2020 #3
True. Trump ran off the people from the CDC that wouldn't play by his playbook BComplex Mar 2020 #6
It has. Pacifist Patriot Mar 2020 #8
WH editing? empedocles Mar 2020 #4
a couple weeks ago barbtries Mar 2020 #5
A contact at the Department of Health & Human Services told me the WH has taken over the CDC... Pacifist Patriot Mar 2020 #7
Some things are equal. Some aren't. Igel Mar 2020 #9
The tag line is "together we can help stop the spread"... thesquanderer Mar 2020 #10

Phoenix61

(17,009 posts)
1. Totally agree. They are definitely minimizing
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 02:40 PM
Mar 2020

the risks. Nothing about young people are less likely to die but may be left with permanently impaired lung function.

LisaM

(27,820 posts)
2. I agree with you that the danger to young people was minimized.
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 02:41 PM
Mar 2020

I think that was wrong, and the consequences have been terrible. It gave a lot of people a sense of false security, and so many didn't understand how viruses are even spread. So while I think a lot of college students showed reckless behavior. I also think that the information they were operating under was dangerously misleading.

A while ago, Lysol or Clorox (can't remember which) ran some ads showing how far a cough can spread through the air, and it was really effective. Something like that would be far more helpful.

hlthe2b

(102,328 posts)
3. From what I am hearing, Pence's task force has taken CDC information and reworked it ,
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 02:43 PM
Mar 2020

cutting out the communication specialists from CDC who have decades of experience with this.

So, while it 'says' CDC, I think it has left a lot of very frustrated career staff mortified.

BComplex

(8,059 posts)
6. True. Trump ran off the people from the CDC that wouldn't play by his playbook
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 02:56 PM
Mar 2020

and made sure the white house/pence controls the message coming out of there. That's why doctors are saying that the actual death toll is far higher than the CDC is saying it is in the USA.

barbtries

(28,810 posts)
5. a couple weeks ago
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 02:53 PM
Mar 2020

I went to their website and there, at the top of the page, was trump's "15 day plan" and a link to the WH.

haven't looked since. Hopefully after trump isn't president anymore the CDC can regain its reliability and standing.

Pacifist Patriot

(24,653 posts)
7. A contact at the Department of Health & Human Services told me the WH has taken over the CDC...
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 02:56 PM
Mar 2020

and to get all my information from WHO.

Igel

(35,337 posts)
9. Some things are equal. Some aren't.
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 04:58 PM
Mar 2020

Dying's certainly not equal. The demographics, even for the US, show the dominance of the 70s. But you can still die if you're young.

In fact "seriously ill" and "hospitalization" aren't equal. Younger = lower chance of hospitalization. It happens, "lower" =/= 0.

Even "getting sick" isn't equal. Just slide the entire range from "no symptoms" to "death" down towards "no symptoms"--lower rate of death, hospitalization, serious case, even sniffles.

Catching it? Yeah, that's equal, as far as I've read. Only idjits say the young are immune.

That's the risk of trying to highlight the risk to one group. Don't listen carefully, you fall into a nice binary opposition--all or nothing. And these are often targeted.

I view it like the voting material at the polling place in Vietnamese. It's not excluding me, it's targeting them. Doesn't mean I can't interpret it as excluding me and take offense--some certainly do--but that's not necessary and not the intent, so it's a wrong inference.

thesquanderer

(11,990 posts)
10. The tag line is "together we can help stop the spread"...
Mon Mar 30, 2020, 07:19 PM
Mar 2020

...and that requires EVERYONE do these things, not just those at high risk.

The ad is one of general information. There's no advantage in telling people at higher risk to social distance and hand-wash, versus telling everyone to do these things. Especially when one of our biggest challenges has been convincing everyone that they need to do these things!

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The CDC PSA from coronavi...